Software
Houzz Logo Print
homeowner726

Need help with kitchen remodel problem: counter heights not the same

10 years ago

I just got new kitchen cabinets and yesterday the new countertops were installed. There are two runs on opposite walls and the counters ended up at different heights. One is 36 1/2" from the floor and the other is 37" from the floor. The 1/2" is noticeable to me and gives the kitchen an unbalanced feel. The contractor said it's because the floors are uneven but he never mentioned before that the counters might be different heights. Should I accept this? I am wondering why he didn't shave one run of base cabs or shim the other run. (FYI, they are custom cabinets.)

Comments (5)

  • 10 years ago
    last modified: 10 years ago

    You probably wouldn't be able to walk in my old house, lol--I'd never even notice the ½".

    IMO,
    a contractor is paid to know these things, and to make the homeowner
    aware of choices. If he'd brought it to your attention before the
    cabinets were built, maybe the cabinet maker could have adjusted the toekick height on one run. If the contractor missed that opportunity, but informed you before the cabinets were installed, the toekicks could have been shimmed to account
    for the dip in the floor. But would you have been unhappy with toekicks
    on one run being ½" taller than the other? Ideally, do you want him to shim one
    run and shave the other, to make the difference less noticeable?


    If you are
    otherwise happy with the installation of the cabinets and counters, I'd
    forget it--probably no one else will notice the difference, and you
    won't notice it as much when everything is on the counters and you start
    using your new kitchen. If it rankles that you weren't informed, or you think it will bother you forever, tell
    the contractor how unhappy you are, and ask what he is willing to do to
    fix it. My guess is nothing, and he'll mention that the cabinets and/or
    counter top could be damaged if he tries a do-over, to support his stance.

    You might receive some comments about a homeowner being proactive, and informed, and double checking all measurements, but I can tell you from DIYing my own kitchen--I had no idea the floors were so uneven, and it took me a while to figure out why I was having such a hard time leveling a couple of bases that happened to be in the middle of one wall (the low point).

    Good luck!

  • 10 years ago

    Thanks for your reply. They never mentioned uneven floors until after cabinets were installed and I asked why there was a gap between end panel and floor. They said they would use trim to hide the gap, which they did. They never mentioned counter height would be different because of it. Shaving 1/2" off toe kick would have made sense because the cabs are only 12" deep and are hidden by 24" eating counter.

  • 10 years ago

    That's a bummer! Yes, they should have accounted for that on cabinet install. We have more than 1/2" variation in the floors which they told us up front since they were re-doing the floors as well. It goes down the length of the cabs and they just had to shim to get everything level. Toe kick is scribed to the floor and you really can't tell the difference. Probably hard to fix at this point without some damage though and kicking up a very large fuss. Of course we intentionally made one side of our counters 38" high and the other 36" so obviously different heights doesn't bother me! And honestly I've never measured to make sure they are exactly as expected... I suspect no one else will notice 1/2" difference.

  • 10 years ago

    Now you made me go look at my counter heights! Knowing my floor has a decided dip in the corner by the paper towels, I suspected it was possible my island wasn't level with the perimeter cabinets. True, as it turns out. I used the long level to measure between the island and the cabs on two sides of it. Not even close to having that bubble in the center. The perimeter cabs on two walls are all level with each other, that took a lot of careful shimming!, and the island is level on it's own, but not with the perimeters. Does it say something that I never even noticed until you brought this up? I suspect you will not notice your 1/2" in very short order.

  • 10 years ago

    Thanks for everyone's comments! My kitchen is small and the two counter
    runs are on perpendicular walls so the difference, while small, is very
    noticeable. Fortunately, my contractor has agreed to fix it.