Software
Houzz Logo Print
midwestguy33

Aprilaire Air Purifiers

10 years ago
last modified: 10 years ago

Does anyone have any experience with the Aprilaire air purifiers? My wife and son have bad allergies and we thought adding one to our HVAC system might help. Specifically we are looking at the 2000 series (https://www.aprilaire.com/whole-house-products/whole-house-products/air-purifiers/model-2310). Thanks!

Comments (14)

  • PRO
    10 years ago
    last modified: 10 years ago

    This specific model is really just a filter. The filter looks to be good, but to be called an 'air purifier' or 'air cleaner' leaves a little to the imagination in my opinion.

    This filter is rated at 1200 CFM air flow, which means this is the air flow in which it was designed to run... if the unit you use has less air flow the better the 'filter' will perform at removing particles, dust, dander etc.

    1200 CFM is typical air flow on a 3 ton AC system. If you're HVAC system is larger than 3 ton the performance of this 'filter' will suffer.

    Restriction of air flow can cause serious detrimental effects to your HVAC system. An air filter / purifier / cleaner has to be restrictive to capture smaller particles that would otherwise go right thru a less restrictive filter.

    Everyone is different when it comes to allergies and respiratory issues. Find an HVAC contractor well versed in IAQ (Indoor Air Quality) in your area. Just realize there is no such thing as a perfect solution to this problem. It comes down to how much you can afford for better filtration (typically multiple filters with in the unit) and then the maintenance costs of replacing those filters.

    Additional things that can go further than filtration can provide is to update your HVAC system to reduce humidity in the home. Buy a humidity meter and put it in your home. If humidity readings are above 60% on a regular basis this may be part of your problem.

    I also should add that you should never choose a 'air cleaner or air purifier' that produces ozone in any amount. It has been determined that ozone in any amount is not good for you and will make matters worse.

  • 10 years ago

    Thanks Austin. I checked our furnace last night and we have a Carrier natural gas furnace. The model number is 58MCB100-10116. Input is listed as 100,000 BTU and output at 93,000 BTU. This furnace is setup as a dual zone system with dampers and we also have a Honeywell humidifier attached to it. The house is a two story of about 2,700 sq ft plus a 2/3 finished basement.

  • 10 years ago

    How do I determine how many CFM air flow my furnace is? Does any of the info I provided in my previous post on my furnace indicate what the flow is?

  • PRO
    10 years ago

    1750-2000 CFM

  • 10 years ago

    So is the filter not a good fit then?

  • PRO
    10 years ago

    you could pair two filter boxes together and then transition back down to your original duct work OR create an additional second return with the second filter. Depends on how much room you have to work with.

    But performance will most likely be crap if you only use one filter. Unless of course the system is oversized for the house... then nothing really matters what you do because your humidity readings will likely be too high depending on the location of this house.

  • 10 years ago

    Thanks Austin. Aprilaire sent me a brochure which states the filter is .16"@ 1200 CFM, .20"@ 1400 CFM, .25"@1600 CFM, .30"@1800 CFM and 35" @2000 CFM. What does this mean exactly?

  • PRO
    10 years ago

    This is likely referring to static pressure at various fan speeds. But there's more to it than just 'static pressure'.

    The MERV rating or efficiency of the filter is rated at 1200 CFM. The MERV performance drops at higher fan speeds. (what are you putting the filter in for? )

    As the filter gets dirty, this will only decrease (efficiency of) particle removal from air.

    What's the MERV rating of the Aprilaire 2000 series air cleaners? (from website)

    It is MERV 13 at 1,200 cfm, which means it will remove 76% of virus size particles 0.3-1 microns, 90% of dust particles 1-3 microns and 90% of pollen and mold spores 3-10 micron. But that really doesn’t tell the whole story.

    A MERV number is only a reflection of the initial efficiency of the air cleaner and doesn’t tell you a thing about its efficiency over time - how it will perform a month, six months or even a year after installation. A balanced look at whole-house air cleaners looks at initial efficiency, efficiency over time, service life (how long between servicing), service actions (how hard it is to service it), the up-front cost and the maintenance costs. The 2000 Series is designed to have low restriction to airflow and large surface area which allows it to last for an entire year in most applications. The patented Self-Seal media provides a very tight seal to prevent unfiltered air from bypassing the filter. The only maintenance is replacing the media which is quick and easy to do.

    -------------

    The idea behind adding a second filter is to increase performance of the filter and keep static pressure as low as possible. If you're trying to evade cost it's not likely you will have the success you are looking for. With that said, everyone is different in how they suffer from allergies and air borne irritants in the home.

  • 10 years ago

    What about using an electrostatic filter?

  • 10 years ago

    Thanks Austin. We are hoping to add the filter to improve my wife and son's allergies. They both are currently getting allergy shots and both take medication every day. Both are allergic to dust mites, mold etc (the list is long). Right now we are just using a 20"x25"x1" filter (MERV 6). After learning what I have I doubt that the MERV of the current filter is 6 (probably much lower due to the size of our system). We're not hoping for a miracle....just some improvement. By the way, we do have a dual zone system (with dampers) if that matters and our two-story house is approximately 2,700 sq ft not including a half finished basement.

    I do not have enough room to easily install two filters easily(there is only 7" between the cold air return and the furnace). We haven't considered an electrostatic filter due to the price.

  • PRO
    10 years ago

    Electrostatic air filters can only filter so much. One of the problems with electrostatic filtration is that it relies on static electricity to operate. What I mean by this is that static electricity is powerful enough to filter small, lighter dust particles out of the air but what about larger dust and dirt particles? Or mold spores? Unfortunately, this is one of the areas that electrostatic filtration falls short in. An electrostatic air filter will never be able to filter as well as a high quality HEPA filter.


  • PRO
    10 years ago

    pmsmith,

    If you're taking shots and medication I think you would be better going for the ultimate in clean air. Those shots, medication likely have side effects to one degree or another. Not to mention costs more than just filtration devices alone.

    This filtration system sits in parallel to your HVAC system and operates independently. Also which is important is that it doesn't create any ozone which unfortunately is very common with upper end air cleaners.

    Because of how this system is tied into your HVAC system makes it very easy to remove it and take it with you should you decide to move from your current home.

    http://www.cleancomfort.com/assets/Brochures_SpecSheets/Filtration/CB-AMHP-250.pdf

  • 10 years ago

    Austin. The unit you linked to seems to have a UV germ killer stage. Wouldn't that be a source of ozone?

  • PRO
    10 years ago

    according to the specification sheet they say they use a non-ozone producing UV bulb.

    If that isn't true, imagine the possible lawsuits that could come from it? I can only go by what the manufacturer states as truth within the specification sheet. I know this leaves much to be desired in some cases.