Software
Houzz Logo Print
jrbarnard

Sheetrock question?

10 years ago
last modified: 10 years ago

Can I ask a question about sheetrock? I think I know the answer, but there are people here that know more.

So, our house build.. issues.. heh...but I know what my NEXT battle may be.. and I want to know more so I can not fight that fight.

Our builder ordered a few pallets of sheetrock over a month or so ago. They put a couple pallets in the garage and a pallet in the front of the house.

Let me see if I have a picture of the house that has it there...

So, you can see the ones in both places. Now.. the shingles were not on the roof till last week. The rain kept that from being able to happen. It rained for days during the 3-4 weeks the sheetrock was there, enough that the piece in front of the garage stack is flat out demolished.

Now, we know we had rain IN the house and garage because it was pooled up there, so the sheetrock had to have gotten wet.

The sheetrock in front of the house looks covered (albeit it is not really even fully covered in THIS picture.. and it rained since then), but it rained hard for 3 days and when I got out there, it was 3/4 uncovered and then it rained for another day or two. No, I did not cover it because I figured it was gone by that time.

They came back out and re-covered it.

They stated they would "pick through it" when they hung it.

IMO.. that is bogus because it can LOOK solid till I try to hang a picture on it.

Thoughts?

Should I demand they replace it all since they should never have ordered it over a month and a half ago and let it sit?

Russ

Comments (39)

  • 10 years ago

    Very poor planning.

    The major problem with sheet rock that has gotten wet/moist is mold. The integrity of the gypsum is also affected, as you fear.

    I'd refuse the use of any in the pallet stored outside period. None at all.

    Would have to inspect that in the garage to see if it is affected.

    The builder is gonna balk at trashing the entire order. At about $7 a sheet(locally), that is a lot of money.

    Russ Barnard thanked User
  • 10 years ago

    I told them I have insurance for this and am happy to make a claim, if need be, but their bad planning should not equate to me eating the cost of a claim, imo.

    Thanks!


    R


  • PRO
    10 years ago

    Given that you have plenty on your plate with this builder already, I would be open to the idea of using what's there as long as it shows no moisture damage. The paper facing is the vulnerable part and just because some of the boards got damaged or ruined, doesn't mean you should throw away everything and start over.

    If a board shows no staining, it's probably fine. Even minor staining should be ok. The sheetrock contractor is unlikely to work with stuff that has been damaged and harder to finish. I would be more focused on getting the humidity down in the house at this stage in general.

    Russ Barnard thanked Springtime Builders
  • 10 years ago

    Spring - Yea, I am totally okay if they use "good stuff" hence why I was curious. If removing the top two or three sheets will get that done, and maybe a bottom 1 or 2, then by all means, they can do it.


    I just am now leery of some of it getting installed and then becoming MY problem later.. heh.


    I'll just ask them. no, I will just go out and make sure the few outside sheets get removed and then I will do a nail test on a few remaining ones to make sure they check out, but they should be fine.


    Thanks!


    R


  • 10 years ago
    last modified: 10 years ago

    Honestly Russ, with all the problems you've been having, I think in some ways you've been way too generous with them. They keep screwing up and you're the one who will have to live with it. If the boards aren't perfect, I would definitely make them get new ones. And honestly, you can go there, show them which ones not to use, but are you going to be standing over them to make sure they actually don't use those boards? Or are you going to just trust them, like with the other screw ups?

  • 10 years ago

    Yes, the sheetrock was ordered and delivered. Then a few days later, the shingles were delivered. Then the singles sat on the roof for 2 weeks and I was told they could not find a roofer that wanted to do that pitch roof, they can make more money on smaller roofs in a neighborhood build one after another.


    Then rain came and it was another week and a half of rain. then they got the shingles on, then more rain for another week or so.

    So


    delivered

    2 weeks sun

    1.5 weeks rain

    1 week more rain

    and still sitting there with day by day sunny/rainy off and on


  • 10 years ago

    I would be worried if they couldn't find a roofer. I hope you're getting lien releases from every single sub.

    Russ Barnard thanked cpartist
  • 10 years ago

    I personally would make them remove it and bring in all new. I have seen drywall that was in a shed but close to the door be affected just by humidity when I ran a lumber yard. I have delivered drywall that was a little bit damp and 12' or 16' boards are doing all they can do to remain in one pc. Up to you but from all you have brought up here he gets no pass were it me. Off the site 100% and fresh brought in, period. stop. His inability to find a sub is not your issue, and as mentioned above get lien releases as his "reasoning" for not being able to find a roofer in my opinion is garbage. They charge more for your type of roof and he either didn't want to pay them the upcharge, he couldn't pay them or he had not paid them previously.

    Russ Barnard thanked millworkman
  • 10 years ago

    I hear ya. Either way, the roof is now done and I have an inspector set up for the end inspection as well. I will look at the drywall later today and determine if it is bad or not. At the very least, the one outside goes away. The garage stuff, at least the top few sheets. Then we will check the rest.


    Thanks guys!


    R


  • 10 years ago

    And "goes away" means off the site before they start installing as you know dam well those sheets will end up on your walls.

    Russ Barnard thanked millworkman
  • 10 years ago

    Yup! Exactly!


    R


  • 10 years ago

    Actually if I were you, I'd mark each one that is ruined with black marker with the words Unusable.

  • 10 years ago

    I told them I have insurance for this and am happy to make a claim.

    I can't imagine that your insurance co would cover their error.


  • 10 years ago

    The reason you have a GC is so things are done in the correct order and supplies are delivered at the correct time. Someone dropped the ball big time and it's not your job to pay for their mistake.

  • 10 years ago

    "I told them I have insurance for this and am happy to make a claim."


    I can't imagine you would WANT your insurance to cover their negligence.

  • 10 years ago

    I would not allow them to be used either. I like CPs idea. Mark them unusable with a permanent marker. That might save someone else from getting them put in their build. Who does that!! Stacks Sheetrock out in the elements...

  • 10 years ago
    last modified: 10 years ago

    As Springtime Builders correctly notes , "[T]he sheetrock contractor is unlikely to work with stuff that has been damaged and harder to finish."

    Though with this so-called builder, it seems possible there may not be a contractor, just some guys who claim to "do drywall" that he picks up outside the Home Depot for a couple of days!

    ***

    The best "inspector" of any finished drywall job is the professional painter/contractor whose job it is to paint those walls. They've saved me grief more than a few times from my aging eyes!

  • 10 years ago

    Okay, so I broke off a LOT of the wet stuff. It seems a couple pieces made their way in. Also.. do I really, or should I really, care about the ones that have a stain on them but appear fine?

    The other two, I figured to tell them to get it cut out. Being as they installed them, they HAD to know they were bad...


    They should just need to cut around the bad area and replace that, so long as they cut out enough to hit places they can nail/screw to, imo.






  • 10 years ago

    Ummmm....I would not let that fly in my brand new many thousands of dollars house. You are paying them for a brand new house, not a house with used, water stained dry-wall. (I realize it's not exactly "used" but it sure didn't come from the store that way so,....)

    Russ Barnard thanked amylachney
  • 10 years ago

    You have been way too nice for the workmanship you are getting. They are giving you hack work for the thousands of dollars you are paying them. This is not acceptable

  • 10 years ago

    Agree with cpartist. Wet sheetrock, even dried out, is crumbly sheetrock.

  • 10 years ago

    I know, CP... Just trying to figure a way to address it without being "that guy".. I know, again, sometimes ya gotta be "that guy".. but it seems to happen so much, just sorta wears ya out.


    Gotta pick and choose the battles and I am like, "do I really expect them to pull all the nails and put in screws? If not, then why bitch about it?"


    R


  • 10 years ago

    "On a side note, it's a bit shocking the drywall crew would have used that damaged and stained drywall."


    Lol, that would be considered minor compared to many things I have seen. I am sure most people in the industry have seen worse, much worse.

    Russ Barnard thanked millworkman
  • 10 years ago

    I agree with cpartist, but I thought you were going to make them remove ALL that drywall from the site.

    Russ Barnard thanked millworkman
  • 10 years ago

    I broke all the wet stuff I could see....I missed a few pieces.


    To be fair, there is only a few spots and one section that used to be wet.


    I think the ones with the stains on the edges is still good, just annoying.


    I am only being picky because of all the little things adding up to "we do not care, just get it on the walls" mentality.


    The one wet/used to be wet area on the ceiling, yea, going to get them to replace that one.



    R


  • 10 years ago
    last modified: 10 years ago

    I'm confused as to why the drywall was delivered before the electrical/hvac/plumbing inspection was done (I'm assuming here) and the exterior completed. Was the contractor buying in bulk to coincide with another job?

  • 10 years ago

    Well, good question. Sorta went like this:


    One Friday the GC told us this:


    GC: I'll have the shingles for the roof delivered Monday and we will get that on, then we can start the floor. That will take about a week and then we can do the walls.


    Monday rolls around.. nothing.


    No shingles the entire week. END of that week, though, Sheetrock got delivered.

    NEXT Monday, Shingles got delivered.

    3-weeks later, no progress at all. (some light rain here and there, nothing major)

    Next week - rain for 2 weeks straight....heavy.

    2- day opening.. shingles went on.


    2 weeks of floors being jacked up and solutions etc..


    Sheetrock goes in.


    Bad management by the GC, imo..


    R




  • 10 years ago
    last modified: 10 years ago

    The two posted pics may be standard--even superiour--in US production drywall jobs, as millworkman suggests. They just depend on the tapers to fill with gobs of readymix. As a builder, I would have said remove and replace. When the sheet (second pic) was misaligned, instead of removing it, the rocker simply whacked it a couple of times with his hammer. "That'll fit that SOB board!" Smash! Whack! Smudge with the ever present thumb. See, it's all better?

  • 10 years ago

    in Pic #1 it sure looks like the side to side variation of that row of screws is wider than a 2x4/6/8....

  • 10 years ago

    Yea, I think I am too tired of nit-picking them that so long as they get rid of the "used to be wet" sheetrock... I'm just going to say "whatever"... at this point, I would rather they get it done and move on and "I" will worry about the nails.


    Pretty bad, huh? heh


    The builder is a good builder, they just don't have a good enough GC that goes out there and is a 'champion' for the customer.

    I think the GC not only should be out there coordinating, they should be out there verifying the work is quality, not just meets standards.


    So, live and learn I guess.


    R


  • 10 years ago

    in Pic #1 it sure looks like the side to side variation of that row of screws is wider than a 2x4/6/8

    I was referring to the gap at the right, where one board is evidently not secured to the framing. Or perhaps over-secured. Or the framing is off.

  • 10 years ago

    Oh, that will get covered up when they put the next part on, which will overlap that. imo, it should have been halfway on that stud, but hey.. what do I know, right? heh


    R


  • 10 years ago

    when they put the next part on

    Another layer of drywall? Paneling?

  • 10 years ago

    Oh no, I meant the roof is (forgive me if I get this term wrong) coffer-ed? They will cut that edge off, I am sure.. but.. the entire thing should have been secured to that rafter there, not "laying in the gutter"


    R