Burnt orange might be nice.

or the same dark brown as the shutters?

I would suggest stain, in a deep mahogany.

Try blue.

Espresso bean stain or java bean stain you can use a gel stain for those doors but then you have to seal them with a clear coat or you can just paint them espresso

Hi Marissa Rocci-Armstrong,
Here are a few color suggestions you may consider. Hope they help! All the best!

Cerulean blue. It'll look lovely and bright, and not as overdone as the chocolate / teal color scheme.

I agree with a burnt orange or rust color. We stained our door but we had to scrape the spar varnish and reapply each year as we get so much sun it caused it to flake. Finally we painted it dark brown and it looks great. It is stained on the inside.

Burnt orange or gun metal blue/gray.