The trim is actually a yellowish cream color. Isn't showing up well in the photos. So, you'd go with white for all the trim? Including bays, and gutters? Our next door neighbor has the same brick and that's what she did with her trim. We are trying to be a bit different.

I would say stick with white. Your house is traditional and if you go with a gray trim I an worried that your house is going to hide as a red and gray box. One minute and I can play with the colors for you.

Can I change my mind? Haha. Below I've added your house with the gray trim and gutters. Not too shabby!

Here is an up close example of a gray trim on brick house and I must say you have a good gut instinct with colors.

I would also paint the downspouts to blend with the brick since they're not something you want to highlight.

Thanks, Patrick! Would you suggest something other than white or gray? Haven't thought of anything on this end.

I honestly like the gray now, so that's my vote hunterau.

The shutters do not stand out in the current color. I'd use black or blackish green.

Patrick, you've been such a help, I thought I'd share an update. What's the thoughts? We went with the trim color, and yesterday, put one coat on the side of the home. So, these pictures only show it with the brick, and not the roof as well, sadly. However, what's your thoughts? Horrible lighting. Sorry.

Well thank you. And it looks good hunterau! Are your windows wood and will they be painted gray as well??

Yes, window's are wood and will be painted as well.

Will look great! Here is the option as emmarene suggested with darker shutters if you do want them to stand out.