Software
Houzz Logo Print
cheryl_hewitt80

Herringbone Pattern BS: use handmade tile or modular tile?

10 years ago
last modified: 10 years ago

We are considering a vertical herringbone pattern for our backsplash. From Fireclay's site I found this inspiration picture.

Design Trends: 7 Ways to Use Herringbone in your Kitchen

5.) Vertical Herringbone Tile Layout

Tired of the traditional herringbone layout? Flip it! By laying your herringbone tile backsplash in a vertical arrangement you create an effortless contemporary aesthetic. Try the layout in a 2 x 6 or 2 x 8 size to elongate the pattern, making it feel even more contemporary. A vertical herringbone is the easiest way to add a fresh design element to your kitchen that doesn't feel overdone.

..................

I'd like to use this 2"x6" tile: https://www.fireclaytile.com/tile/colors/detail/white-wash/ 

This size tile is part of the Foundation Collection and is $15/sq. ft.

Grout lines:

https://www.fireclaytile.com/blog/full/tile-school-grout-lines-and-tile-patterns/

"Below is an installation of 2x6 tiles set in a herringbone pattern. If you look closely you can see that the grout line varies between roughly a 3/16 and 1/8 grout line to adjust to the tile size. The 3/16 grout line is by no means thick and leaves a perfect amount of room for the natural variation of the size of the tiles. This is also an example of a very clean, well done installation. When looking for a tile installer, be sure to ask if they have experience with installing handmade tile to ensure you're happy with the final result."

Questions:

  • Is a hand cut tile the best choice for a contemporary design? It would require wider grout lines, however it would be white on white.
  • Is going with Fireclay overkill for this look? Would a cheaper tile give the same effect? Additionally, would an installer have an easier time with a modular tile?

TIA

Comments (16)

  • 10 years ago

    Handmade tile is a fine choice for any design, traditional or contemporary. It may require slightly larger grout lines - what were you planning to use?

    I don't think Fireclay is overkill, I think a lot of other tiles are. You can absolutely get a similar look with cheaper tile (one of the things I love about tile) but handmade tile is incredibly pretty. Machine made tile is not the same, but can also be very nice. You need an experienced installer for handmade tile, and it may take longer to install.

    Good luck!

    Cheryl Hewitt thanked eam44
  • 10 years ago

    eam44, I honestly don't know what size grout line I want. I do know that I want the overall appearance of the vertical herringbone in the picture above. To my eye, the grout looks fine in both pictures and I'd be more than happy with it if I could get the same results.

    Should I ask my GC if his tiler is up to the task of setting handmade tile? Would he answer me honestly? I suspect I'll get the answer I want regardless of whether or not his tiler is skilled enough for this job.

  • 10 years ago
    last modified: 10 years ago

    Cheryl, I could be wrong, but to my eye, the grout lines in the top photo look tighter. It's hard to tell, especially given the fact that the white grout lines in the top also 'disappear' since they're the same as the tile. We have handmade tile, set with 3/16 grout, and I just think ours looks more like the second photo than the first. Our handmade tile is 2 x 6 and fairly uniform.

    I'm s big fan of handmade tile (DD is a potter, duh!) but honestly, if you're really after that top look, I'd save the money and look for a nice non-handmade tile.

  • 10 years ago

    Well, how much do you trust your GC? :-).

    You can look for machine made tile that you like. Daltile subway tile "Rittenhouse" is sold at Home Depot and Lowes. Check out their colors if you like. It's hard to get excited about them when you've seen Fireclay tile, but when it comes to ease of installation, you could probably DIY this, so whoever your GC hires, you'll have no worries.

  • 10 years ago

    Well, if you get Fireclay, you MUST get a glorious color, not just white!

  • 10 years ago
    last modified: 10 years ago

    If you go to 1x6 Fireclay they come shipped Sheeted with clear face tape. Diy. They will meet your layout details. Bicolor vertical could look nice with two whites.

  • 10 years ago

    "Well, if you get Fireclay, you MUST get a glorious color, not just white!"

    Fori, using tile from their Foundation Collection limits the optional colors. Plus we have blue granite on the islands. I think I have to walk away from colored tile. Sad, huh?

  • 10 years ago
    last modified: 10 years ago

    Which blue granite did you choose, and what are the peripheral counters? The Foundations line is limited, but you might be able to choose something other than White Wash. I'd love to see an image of the granite and tile together. Have you actually ordered samples of the Fireclay tile? French Linen is a beautiful grey that can coordinate well with some blues.

  • 10 years ago

    The granite on the islands is Blue Ray. It's a dyed granite. (They're giving us a huge deal on this.)

    Perimeter granite is American Black.

    Caramel stained cherry cabinets.

    Our range hood is brushed stainless steel with antiqued copper bands and lip simular to the picture below, except our copper is a matte finish.


  • 10 years ago

    Tusk or Gardenia might be options. What do you think?

  • 10 years ago
    last modified: 10 years ago

    They're both beautiful glazes, although I'm partial to Gardenia. There is a great benefit in waiting till your counters are installed before you choose bs tile. Seeing your tile samples in your space, in your light against your materials changes everything. You might decide White Wash is it for you, or you might love Moonshine.

    I'm not trying to get you to spend more money, but have you considered the glazed thin brick? At $18/sf it's barely more expensive, and there are some seriously beautiful glazes here too.

    You can use the herringbone layout with these tiles as well. Below are Cotton and Supernova.


  • 10 years ago

    The price isn't that much more. Hmm. Definitely worth looking into. My problem with waiting is that I want the backsplash to go to the ceiling behind the range hood. I'm assuming the tile goes up first before the range hood is installed. Yes?

  • 10 years ago
    last modified: 10 years ago

    This is such a cop-out answer, but maybe. Different vent hoods are mounted in different ways. Yours might need the mechanical and support pieces in place before the tiling, and the deco pieces after. Check with your GC. I get that the 3-5 week lead time can be a pain.

  • 10 years ago

    I think I should ask the Vent-a-hood rep. From what we've heard via the appliance store she knows all things Vent-a-hood. :)