Software
Houzz Logo Print
therustyone

Beneficial Nematodes?

9 years ago

In another gardening forum that I read periodically, a poster talked about using beneficial nematodes to get rid of fire ants. Said they eat ground dwelling insects. Does anyone here know anything about this? I'm wondering if they would eat cut ants. I asked about it on that forum, but the poster just said they didn't know anything about cut ants. So, I'm asking here, what do y'all know about beneficial nematodes? Are they choosy about their diet? Do they prey on all ground dwelling insects? In all my searches about controlling both fire ants and cut ants, I have never seen beneficial nematodes mentioned. Also, where would one get them? ? ?

I sure would appreciate any thoughts and/or information anyone here has on the subject!

Rusty

Comments (11)

  • 9 years ago

    For whatever reason, the link won't work for me. But I gather from the wording of it that the Beneficial Nematodes aren't an effective control for fire ants. Wish I knew if the article mentioned cut ants.

    I've Googled to find out how & where the BN can be purchased, and learned there are two types of them. One type is said to control ants, but it does not mention if that is all kinds of ants, or just certain varieties.

    I think I'm just getting more and more confused!

    Rusty

  • 9 years ago
    last modified: 9 years ago

    You might have to copy the link and paste it into your browser. See if this works better for you.

    http://tinyurl.com/hurynfa

    Now, this web page is an old one, but it's from an independent source. There are web pages that say that BN's kill fire ants, but those are pages by people who want to sell it to you. People who sell sledge hammers probably proudly claim that they kill fire ants, and they do!

    If you find a more recent report from an independent source about this I'd like to hear about it.

    Rusty thanked daninthedirt (USDA 9a, HZ9, CentTX, Sunset z30, Cfa)
  • 9 years ago

    You should be able to purchase BN at a good nursery. They keep them refrigerated. Both Calloway's and Redenta's here in DFW sell them. I sprayed them in summer 2015 to get rid of fleas and now a year later still no fleas. I don't have fire ants either, but that just may be because they haven't worked their way around to my yard yet.

    Rusty thanked lindabuchanan13
  • 9 years ago

    Both links get the same reaction, it says "waiting for. . . " and then the link. The little whatever you call it that goes round & round while a site is loading, is there, going round & round. But nothing ever loads. I even walked off & did some chores thinking maybe I was just too impatient, but it was still the same when I came back. I guess I'll just stick to the Amdro I've been using that lists 48 (I think) types of ants, and the DE.

    Thank y'all for trying to help, I appreciate it a lot!

    Rusty

  • 9 years ago
    last modified: 9 years ago

    Wow, that's weird. Here's the text. P.S. Amdro works great but it does expire. I had some on the shelf for a few years and it just stopped working completely.

    ---

    Beneficial Nematodes Not Effective for Fire Ant Control

    By: Robert A. Dunn, Department of Entomology and Nematology, University
    of Florida - IFAS

    Recent press releases have promoted products based on the insect-parasitic
    nematode, Steinernema carpocapsae, for control of imported fire ants.
    This species and related nematodes have been used very successfully to control
    many kinds of soft-bodied insects such as white grubs (larvae of various scarab
    beetles), some caterpillars, and the larvae of fungus gnats and other flies.
    However, they have not proven effective for actually reducing fire ant populations
    or fire ant colonies in the field.

    We are not aware of any credible scientific evidence that documents any nematode
    species to be efficient for controlling imported fire ant colonies. These nematodes
    are able to kill individual ants in the laboratory, but in field trials the
    ant colonies usually respond to nematodes by moving, sometimes splitting colonies
    in the process.

    Among problems in using nematodes to control fire ant colonies are:

    • Desiccation of the nematodes before they can penetrate deeply into the
      mound, especially if they are introduced when soil is hot and are not applied
      with large amounts of water.
    • Application of the nematodes with a large volume of water is likely to
      disturb the colony enough that it will move and perhaps split.
    • Imported fire ants can move much faster and farther than can the nematodes,
      so ants can easily escape them.

    The products that appear to be most effective in eliminating fire ants are
    those formulated as baits (small amount of pesticide in an attractive food)
    so the ants pick up the treated particles and carry them into the undisturbed
    nest. Unfortunately, many bait products are not legally registered for use
    in gardens. They may be used in adjacent lawns, but cannot be used within gardens
    that include food crops.

    Although beneficial nematodes might be used to get fire ants out of gardens
    by disturbing them, the same effect can be obtained at no extra cost by pouring
    hot water onto the mounds or by mechanical disturbance.

    Those who decide to apply beneficial nematodes to get fire ants out of their
    gardens should do so when conditions are most favorable for the largest percentage
    of the nematodes reaching the largest number of ants. Avoid applications when
    the soil is hot, to minimize death of nematodes by heat and desiccation, and
    to catch the greatest number of ants nearer the surface where the nematodes
    can reach them. Most fire ants are deep below ground during the hottest part
    of a summer day. Better times to apply the nematodes would be early in the
    morning or about 12 hours after a rainfall during the summer, or during the
    cooler weather of other seasons.

    At this time, no biological control agent identified by scientists to be
    effective against imported fire ants is available for sale to the public. However,
    a fungus found by University of Florida scientists to significantly reduce
    fire ant populations is now being prepared for commercial use and should be
    available to consumers sometime in 1998 or 1999. In the meantime, Floridians
    who wish to reduce fire ant problems will have to continue to rely on the practices
    and products that have been proven helpful, following label directions carefully
    to give them the best chance of success.

    Rusty thanked daninthedirt (USDA 9a, HZ9, CentTX, Sunset z30, Cfa)
  • 9 years ago
    last modified: 9 years ago

    Both links work for me. Copied and pasted -- this is what it says:

    "Beneficial Nematodes Not Effective for Fire Ant Control

    By: Robert A. Dunn, Department of Entomology and Nematology, University of Florida - IFAS

    Recent press releases have promoted products based on the insect-parasitic nematode, Steinernema carpocapsae, for control of imported fire ants. This species and related nematodes have been used very successfully to control many kinds of soft-bodied insects such as white grubs (larvae of various scarab beetles), some caterpillars, and the larvae of fungus gnats and other flies. However, they have not proven effective for actually reducing fire ant populations or fire ant colonies in the field.

    We are not aware of any credible scientific evidence that documents any nematode species to be efficient for controlling imported fire ant colonies. These nematodes are able to kill individual ants in the laboratory, but in field trials the ant colonies usually respond to nematodes by moving, sometimes splitting colonies in the process.

    Among problems in using nematodes to control fire ant colonies are:

    • Desiccation of the nematodes before they can penetrate deeply into the mound, especially if they are introduced when soil is hot and are not applied with large amounts of water.
    • Application of the nematodes with a large volume of water is likely to disturb the colony enough that it will move and perhaps split.
    • Imported fire ants can move much faster and farther than can the nematodes, so ants can easily escape them.

    The products that appear to be most effective in eliminating fire ants are those formulated as baits (small amount of pesticide in an attractive food) so the ants pick up the treated particles and carry them into the undisturbed nest. Unfortunately, many bait products are not legally registered for use in gardens. They may be used in adjacent lawns, but cannot be used within gardens that include food crops.

    Although beneficial nematodes might be used to get fire ants out of gardens by disturbing them, the same effect can be obtained at no extra cost by pouring hot water onto the mounds or by mechanical disturbance.

    Those who decide to apply beneficial nematodes to get fire ants out of their gardens should do so when conditions are most favorable for the largest percentage of the nematodes reaching the largest number of ants. Avoid applications when the soil is hot, to minimize death of nematodes by heat and desiccation, and to catch the greatest number of ants nearer the surface where the nematodes can reach them. Most fire ants are deep below ground during the hottest part of a summer day. Better times to apply the nematodes would be early in the morning or about 12 hours after a rainfall during the summer, or during the cooler weather of other seasons.

    At this time, no biological control agent identified by scientists to be effective against imported fire ants is available for sale to the public. However, a fungus found by University of Florida scientists to significantly reduce fire ant populations is now being prepared for commercial use and should be available to consumers sometime in 1998 or 1999. In the meantime, Floridians who wish to reduce fire ant problems will have to continue to rely on the practices and products that have been proven helpful, following label directions carefully to give them the best chance of success."

    Rusty thanked roselee z8b S.W. Texas
  • 2 years ago

    So the question now is what happened to that fungus from Florida due in 1999? I am desperate to find a way to kill fire ants, but am not finding a sure thing. I use Orthene and it works, but a part of the mound always seems to move a few feet away and come back.

  • 2 years ago

    Just FYI, standard practice is to sprinkle fire ant bait not just ON the mound, but around the periphery as well. That prevents the mound from just shifting sideways.

  • 2 years ago
    last modified: 2 years ago

    P.S. The fungus that was being investigated as a fire ant killer is Beauveria Bassania. Yes, you can buy it, but it ain't cheap. Just google it. Also, while it kills fire ants, it doesn't kill all fire ants. So while "organic" it just doesn't work that well. I used to use Amdro, but it expires rapidly. 3 months after opening. Look for products with bifenthrin. Works a charm, and granules are potent for several years.

Sponsored