Software
Houzz Logo Print
laslin

Popcorn ceilings:(

13 years ago
I live in a house built late 1979 I think. All of the rooms have popcorn ceilings. We have remodeled everything in this house through the years. I am getting ready to repaint the interior. Am I making a big mistake by not removing the popcorn? I just did not think I could deal with the mess so I was just going to have them reprinted. I would love some feedback from you folks that know! By the way, I will be living here until I die!!!

Comments (26)

  • 13 years ago
    Repainted.... Darn auto correct
  • PRO
    13 years ago
    last modified: 13 years ago
    If you painted them once already it's harder to remove it now unless you haven't the other thing is you might have asbestos in the popcorn ceiling
  • 13 years ago
    Rockin, you may have given me two reasons not to remove it! We have painted it before and I do not know about the asbestos ordeal. Lets see if I can get some more support for not removing..haha. Is there anyone out there that thinks popcorn "could" come back in style:-)
  • PRO
    13 years ago
    I am actually scraping ceilings today to rid the room we are repainting of popcorn. I have a 6 inch scraper and some warm water in a squirt bottle. It does not take long but sure makes a mess. The overall look though is well worth it. Didnt go all the way to the drywall when scraping so that I won't have to come back and texture.
  • 13 years ago
    CW Fenton, why would you not come back and retexture?
  • 13 years ago
    I scraped my popcorn ceilings about 3 weeks ago and it is an unholy mess! Scraping is the easy part though! The sanding and patch work is what causes the most mess! I didn't do the bedrooms or bathrooms but even those rooms are covered in dust! With that being said... It looks so much better! I had to hire someone to do the finishing work but now that it is done I am glad I did it!
  • 13 years ago
    I should also add that in time I will do the rest of my house but I will figure out a way to seal off the room to minimize the dust. Do the scraping yourself (saves money) but let a pro finish it. I can't imagine living with popcorn ceilings forever!
  • 13 years ago
    last modified: 13 years ago
    We live in a 70s house also and several years ago we removed the popcorn ceiling everywhere. HUGE mess but I'm so glad we did it. But, you will probably need to hire a good sheetrock person. After we scraped the popcorn (down to the sheetrock, you may see the sheetrock tape so you'll need to retexture and do a "spray and knockdown". Then, the sheetrock guy sanded (after it dried) and dust was everywhere! White dust the air vents for weeks! But, we lived through in and are very glad we did. It updates the home considerably. If you're goint to "die" there...I say do it. We are going to "die" here too so we thought we'd enjoy the home we will be in for a long time.
  • 13 years ago
    At Joice ..... Hmmmm that is a thought. Thank you all thus far.
  • PRO
    13 years ago
    Do 1/2 inch drywall 1/4 will show waves in it you need something that won't flex much over the bumpy ceiling
  • PRO
    13 years ago
    last modified: 13 years ago
    Just an FYI, if you install drywall over drywall and don't remove and reinstall the electrical boxes in the ceiling it is an electrical code violation as it relates to combustible material.
  • 13 years ago
    I have popcorn ceilings throughout the house I just bought and we are redrywalling because it's not as time consuming or as messy.
  • 13 years ago
    HI -- We are doing that in our house right now - biggest room yet to be done . If the ceilings have been painted then the only thing to be done is to re -drywall them . If they were painted then they would have been done in an oil base paint - water based would have been too wet and the stippling would have fallen off . We are using 3/8 inch drywall ,so it looks even. Our ceilings are standard 8 ft. If the ceilings were not painted then the stipple can be sprayed with warm water and scraped clean - messy job, but worth it. Yes the trend right now is to remove stipple , everyone is on the band wagon about it . If the stipple you have is in good shape , I really don't mind it . You could get someone in to do a knock-down finish over , that looks nice .Also recovering the ceiling with T&G wood then white washing or a light stain ,is also being done . Yes ,you will have to get an electrician in to adjust things etc. Good Luck with your project !
  • PRO
    13 years ago
    Popcorn ceiings can be sprayed with latex paint, it's the roller that makes the popcorn come off. Removing it is always the better choice. I don't see how drywall over drywall is any neater when you still have to tape, mud, and finish it.
  • PRO
    13 years ago
    I think after they are painted the popcorn is hard to remove I hope people are testing there ceilings for asbestos with all the dust created by this process
  • PRO
    13 years ago
    Or remodeling and removing drywall from a pre 1978 house before having it checked for lead based paint.
  • PRO
    13 years ago
    I just read a study that even though that asbestos pop corn texture had been band in 79 that it could of been installed through the 80's because the band didn't affect product that was already made and most of it was used instead of disposing of it .
  • 13 years ago
    In 1990 we had a plasterer and his son lay a thin coat over our popcorn ceilings because we were told concrete was part of the makeup. That and the fact that it was as all electric home with radiant heat in the ceiling kept us from removing the popcorn. It wasn't cheap but not exorbitant either. And of course the smooth ceiling that resulted made it worth every last nickel. This was in southern California, maybe it's not done anymore or done in other areas of the country. But the process was rather quick and painless. Just tossing it out as an idea. Good luck.
  • 13 years ago
    Thank you all so much for your comments. I am now leaning toward removal:-)
  • PRO
    13 years ago
    I try not apply too much pressure when scraping it off. There is absolutely no need to scrape down to clean drywall. Just knock off the popcorn, then scrape down to a desired stage of texture. This is the way I've done it for many years and it looks great with less effort and cost. Try not to get it too wet. That will help from scraping down to fresh drywall.
  • 13 years ago
    Great tip Cw Penton!
  • PRO
    13 years ago
    When you drywall over the popcorn ceiling, you will have to consider the height of the ceiling. Most so-called 8' ceilings are 94" or less, the dry walling makes it even lower. I am for removal.
  • PRO
    13 years ago
    last modified: 13 years ago
    Ellen and Darzy (for next time)..use zipwall available on Amazon.com. Norm..no need to lower boxes for 1/2" drywall...use a extension plaster ring...But putty coating by a pro is the thinnest and easiest way to smooth. Oh...and 1/4" drywall is actually stiffer than 1/2"...formulated to be rigid for just this situation.
  • PRO
    13 years ago
    last modified: 13 years ago
    Yeah mud rings would work, I normally don't drywall over drywall.
  • PRO
    13 years ago
    Norm, my experience has been drywall over bad plaster...why I recommend skim coating/putty coating to a flat drywall finish.