Software
Houzz Logo Print
gary_cotterill

Pruning floribundas and grandifloras

Should I cut out the brown canes (leaving the green canes)?

Comments (7)

  • 9 years ago

    Good advice, as always from Seil.

  • 9 years ago

    Ditto for me, Gary. Seil's method of determining live growth is right on.

    Your heading subject, "Pruning floribundas and grandifloras," indicates a possible pruning question specific to these two classes of roses, in contrast to how hybrid teas are pruned. Am I right? If yes, ask away.

  • 9 years ago
    last modified: 9 years ago

    I was wondering if my roses would be more "vigorous" growing from (newer) green canes than from the (older) brown canes.

    A responder to my more-general post:

    http://forums2.gardenweb.com/discussions/4304011/pruning-roses

    asked what types of roses I had.

  • 9 years ago
    last modified: 9 years ago

    A rose bush growing a robust current year's basal cane [generally a rich green...the greenest cane(s), on any given rose bush], is always a blessed event, gardening wise. The more new basal canes produced in a year the better as long as they are husky ones. One or two new basal canes a year is average, good progress development. Three or more new basals a year is robust growth, often charasteristic of a young bush.

    As a bush ages it produces fewer basals a year, even skipping a year by producing no new basals that year, only new lateral growth that year. Each variety of rose has a different basal cane production pattern. Some varieties are stingy with fresh basal production, especially roses that have narrow, tight crowns. These kinds of crowns are hard for basal canes to break through the dense wood of the crown in order to erupt and grow. Other varieties produce fresh basals liberally, especially varieties that have wide, open crowns. Wide, open crowns have more less dense places for fresh basals to emerge, the woody crown is not so thick and dense, but spread out, so the emerging canes don't have to fight so hard to break through.

    I believe own root roses have crowns that make it much easier for fresh basal canes to break forth. Grafted roses can produce crowns that are tightly packed and not spread out, making it more difficult for basals to emerge. I also believe own root roses have a longer life span, due in part to their broader crowns.

    Producing new basal canes is how a rose bush keeps growing, since annual ring production such as how trees and most shrubs grow is not exactly how roses grow.

    Roses grow from a woody crown that sends up basal canes that last a short number of years then become unproductive, and are replaced with new basal canes. A basal cane has a productive life of about 4 years. After that it produces weaker and weaker lateral growth and is replaced by the rose bush with a new basal cane. Basal canes increase in diameter every year they are in their most productive, early years, but they will eventually start declining in vigor and must be replaced with fresh, new, green basal canes.

    Only remove basal canes that are losing productivity as old age takes its toll on them. This state can be easily determined by looking at the laterals it produces. If the laterals are thin and spindly, it's time for removal. Depending on the age, vigor, and size of the bush, removing the oldest, unproductive basal cane every year or two will keep the bush in tip top productivity. It's a judgement call that has to be made, bush by bush, and basal cane by basal cane.

    I hope this helps you.

  • 9 years ago

    I wasn't referring to brown canes that are dead.

    Would roses grow more vigorously from young green canes instead of from older brown canes?

  • 9 years ago
    last modified: 9 years ago

    Not necessarily....Young green BASAL canes are always given poriority, as long as they are healthy and thick. Young green lateral growth is usually pruned out. It, being thinner than basal growth, does not have the vigor or strength to support next year's growth that will be produced in it.

    Lateral young green growth is the higher up growth that branches out from basal growth. The husky, thick growth that originates from the rose's crown is called basal growth or basal canes. Lateral green growth is generally pruned out in spring, even if it is rich green. Only basal canes are husky enough, having the widest growth, diameter wise, to produce the best, most flower producing new lateral growth next year.

    It's like in plumbing. A 1/2" water line does not feed a 1" line. A 1/2" diameter rose stem will only produce offshoot stems smaller than 1/2" diameter, not equal to, and certainly not greater than 1/2"_diameter.

    New basal growth is rich green in its first year. It becomes browner/grayer, and more "barky," every year thereafter. As long as the color changing basal canes are producing strong, thick new green, well flowering lateral growth from them, they are retained.

    When at the end of a growing season an old basal cane is showing declining vigor: weak new green lateral growth throwing smaller and fewer flowers that it produced that year, it is time to remove that basal cane down to the crown. It's productive life is over. Basal canes start to decline after about three years. So a fresh, vigorous, green basal cane from this year, 2016, should be good until 2020.

    In my cold climate where roses do not get as large as they do in yours, floribundas and grandifloras are not pruned as hard as yours are there. Some healthy, vigorous lateral growth from last year may not be pruned off here. It depends on many factors: bush age, general vigor, and winter damage, to name major factors. If you left some of last year's laterals on your bushes they would very soon get too large and twiggy, with smaller diametered, weaker laterals with smaller, and weaker stemmed fewer flowers.

    In conclusion, the DIAMETER of the growth coupled with its degree of green color (indicating its age), and the evidence of vigorous growth it has produced so far, and the reasonably predictable likelihood that it will do the same next year, is the determining factor on whether to retain or remove it. This is the primary factory that determines if growth is retained or pruned off.