Software
Houzz Logo Print
kate_kislova

How do we fix our soil?

9 years ago

The question is for home organic garden. We had soil testing done for the following 4 items:

N - Nitrogen - came back as "deficient"

P - Phosphorus - came back as border line "optimum"/"excess"

K - Potassium - came back as "marginal", close to "optimum"

S - Sulfur - came back as "Optimum"


Our main issue is that our root veggies would not form roots. Greens, such as Kale, Chard, etc grow. The greens of the root veggies also grow, but the actual veggies don't form. How do we fix the soil issue above? What can we do now before we can start growing in the spring?


TIA

Comments (19)

  • 9 years ago

    Nitrogen is commonly deficient in soil tests because it moves with water. So, you add it as needed.


    Before any comment can be made about what's going wrong, we need to know what you do, and when you plant what.

    Please start by explaining how you prepare the ground before you plant


  • 9 years ago

    You're going to find out a lot of things, chiefly that everyone has an opinion and thinks you should hear their's. and for all the lip service given to soils, just about no one really understands it.

    My best piece of advice is to find an agronomist locally. So you want to do organic and the advice an agronomist is likely to give isn't carefully filtered to give you only what you want to hear...at some point, fertilizer is fertilizer, just different forms. Pounds of Phosphorous (per acre or 100 square feet) are pounds of phosphorous (per given area)...and it just takes a little math to determine application rates and frequencies...drats...that's not very organic is it?

    So you want to garden organically. So you got a soil test done. Yippee. Do I sound less than enthused?

    So what kind of soil do you have? How much sun do you get? What was your weather like? watering frequency? thinning?

    Getting back to the soil...pH? How does broccoli grow? there's actually a very specific reason I'm asking about broccoli.

    There may be one of many factors at play, or many factors that are partially in play. This is where you learn, where everyone learns...you do it, you run into a problem, you learn what caused it and how to solve it. Think you've learned everything? wait for next season.

  • 9 years ago

    How much organic matter is in that soil. Optimum is 6 to 8 percent.

    Perhaps these simple soil tests might be of some help.

    1) Soil test for organic
    material. From that soil sample put enough of the rest to make a 4 inch level in
    a clear 1 quart jar, with a tight fitting lid. Fill that jar with water and
    replace the lid, tightly. Shake the jar vigorously and then let it stand for 24
    hours. Your soil will settle out according to soil particle size and weight.
    For example, a good loam will have about 1-3/4 inch (about 45%) of sand on the
    bottom. about 1 inch (about 25%) of silt next, about 1 inch (25%) of clay above
    that, and about 1/4 inch (about 5%) of organic matter on the top.

    2) Drainage. Dig a hole
    1 foot square and 1 foot deep and fill that with water. After that water drains
    away refill the hole with more water and time how long it takes that to drain
    away. Anything less than 2 hours and your soil drains’ too quickly and needs
    more organic matter to slow that drainage down. Anything over 6 hours and the
    soil drains too slowly and needs lots of organic matter to speed it up.

    3) Tilth. Take a handful
    of your slightly damp soil and squeeze it tightly. When the pressure is
    released the soil should hold together in that clump, but when poked with a
    finger that clump should fall apart.

    4) Smell. What does your
    soil smell like? A pleasant, rich earthy odor? Putrid, offensive, repugnant
    odor? The more organic matter in your soil the more active the soil bacteria
    will be and the nicer your soil will smell, to a point. Too much organic matter
    can be bad as well.

    5) Life. How many
    earthworms per shovel full were there? 5 or more indicates a pretty healthy soil. Fewer than 5,
    according to the Natural Resources Conservation Service, indicates a soil that
    is not healthy.

    kimmq is kimmsr

  • 9 years ago

    Root vegetables need a loose, deep and light, almost sandy soil to form properly. They also do not care for a very acidic soil, preferring a pH in the 6.0-6.5 range. Generally, if the greens develop well but the roots do not, the plants may be crowded or were not thinned correctly when seedlings..

    I'm not sure how much 'fixing' your soil requires. It is very easy to get too caught up in the details of soil analysis and not see the forest for the trees :-) Confirm your soil pH is in the correct range (given high S levels, perhaps excessively acidic, in which case you may need to lime), till the area where root crops will be planted to loosen and break up the soil; add some coarse sand if necessary.

    N levels will almost always show as 'deficient' - N is a very mobile nutrient and will change with the time of year (even the time of day in summer), amount of sunlight and the amount of rainfall or irrigation received. It is also the nutrient that is consumed/taken up by plants in the highest quantity - adding/replacing N in a veggie garden is pretty much SOP.

    Typically the recommendation would be to add organic matter in the form of compost of composted manures but doing so in your case would add to already high or optimum levels of P and K so you might just want to stick to a fert or organic supplement that provides N but not so much of anything else........alfalfa meal, feather meal, blood meal, bat guano. I'd add these soon, as they need time to break down and be converted to plant accessible forms by the soil biology. Faster additions during the growing season can be addressed with fish emulsion.

  • 9 years ago

    ^^^ what garden gal said.

    Root vegetables only form good roots if the soil conditions are excellent for them: light, well drained and reliably watered. And not crowded.

    ******************

    How do we fix the soil issue above?

    You need to tell us how it got that way. What have you been doing in this "organic" garden bed? What kind of soil do you have, what amendments have you added, what kind of watering and tilling have you been doing?

    What can we do now before we can start growing in the spring?

    That depends on your answer to my first question.

  • 9 years ago

    Root veggies need loose soil. If you have a potato fork. loosen the soil more deeply before tilling.

  • 9 years ago

    Lots of tops and no tubers sounds like too much nitrogen and not enough P, which is exactly the opposite of what the test is showing. So it's either soil texture (or one of the other issues already mentioned), or there's something wrong with the soil test. I assume you took a good composite sample from several places in the bed and from the entire depth rather than just the top inch or two. It can make a difference.

  • 9 years ago
    last modified: 9 years ago

    Thanks everyone! Let me try to answer all of your questions and maybe someone can point me in the right direction.

    I'm fairly new to gardening... Actually let me rephrase it, I've gardened for several years, in several countries, with zero problems. Hence, I don't have any experience gardening in soil that has issues. I would put the seeds, weed, water and stuff would grow.

    This soil was purchased from a soil place recommended by a gardening store. We build a small garden in our backyard (raised beds and all). It has enough sunlight, things were done properly. The soil was organic and we paid A LOT. We started gardening only to find out that root veggies DO NOT form. I ripped everything out, and replanted all, and made sure it was in the right "distance", had enough space, no crowding, enough water at the right time, etc. Still no luck. Thinking it was a bad year, I tried the same the following summer, same problem. Total it's been two summers now. We are coming up for a third summer and would really love to see some veggies!

    I asked here before and was recommended to test the soil and we did... so I came back with the soil test results. Not sure what's wrong with the soil. I mean obv something is wrong, because levels are not optimum. When I say "how do we fix it", I mean it... How do we get root veggies to grow? What do I do to bring the soil up to a desired "optimum" level?

    We did not plant brocolli (someone asked). Things we tried to grow: beets (4 types), carrots (4 types), tomatoes (3 types), cucumbers (2 types), radishes (4 types), spinach, dill, kale, chard, beans, peas, parsley, cilantro, basil. All greens grew. None of the root veggies (beets, carrots, radishes) did. Tomatoes and cukes also grew.

  • 9 years ago

    If everything other than root veggies did well - or at least OK - then the soil in the raised beds is probably too heavy for the root crops. By too heavy I mean likely has too much organic matter like compost or composted manures, which absorb and retain water and increase in weight. Adding coarse sand to the areas where you intend to grow the root veg - and you'll need a good amount - should help.

    As noted by several previous comments, root vegetables need a light, loose soil to form the roots properly. Adding a decent amount of sand will help a lot to create a lighter, more finely textured medium. Cultivate the area very well after adding the sand and before planting to encourage a very uniform distribution and to break up any larger peds.

    If nutrient levels are off (and if things are doing well, the probably aren't) then your soil test should have given you recommendations to supplement. Did it?

    Nutrient levels are different from soil texture and they get adjusted differently. Either or both could be the problem but I would lean to the soil texture being primarily responsible.

  • 9 years ago

    As noted, there is some contradiction here. Root veggies won't grow roots if the nitrogen is high. But your test came back saying it was low. So I have to suspect your soil texture wasn't good. A soil composition test, as described above, would be smart to do. Nutrient tests are a really small part of the picture. Was the soil heavily amended? Has it been cultivated and used for many years? Were the plants properly thinned? Unthinned root crops will have nice foliage, but no roots.

  • 9 years ago

    Raised beds, in particular new raised beds, can present challenges. you're not actually growing in soil, and sometimes the results can be...scattershot and frustrating. what did you direct seed and what was transplants?

  • 9 years ago

    All soil is organic. People that market soil as organic are engaging in hyperbole, and they often charge more for what they sell for no reason other than that.

    Were I to visit your garden to assist you I would take a handful of soil, look at it, feel it, and smell it and then do the simple soil tests outlined above to get an idea what you had. I would also have a good reliable soil test done since I would want to know the soils pH, most all plants prefer growing in soils with a pH in the 6.0 to 7.0 range where most all soil nutrients are most readily available, and the balance of nutrients in that soil.

    A good soil for growing plants in is something like about 45 percent sand, 25, percent silt, 25 percent clay, and 5 percent organic matter.

    kimmq is kimmsr

  • 9 years ago
    last modified: 9 years ago

    Root vegetables are tricky. You didn't say what state you live or at least what latitude . It is actually matter because of a day's longevity. For radishes , it is extremely matter. They will form root while day length is no more than certain hours, after that radish thinks it is time to bloom and sent all their strength to make seeds. Some gardeners believe that You could try to cover radishes from day light every evening 1- 2-3 hours before dark to trick their biological clock when it is time to form their roots but they don't want to.

    I have same problem with root veggies, never got radish or carrot or beet appropriate size. But have success with black radish (aka spanish radish) and golden turnip. I plant them in August while it is warm but days get shorter and shorter.

    Potato produce without problem, but it is not depend to day length that much.

  • 9 years ago

    Soil may be sold as 'organic' meaning it has compost mixed in, sometimes called 'garden mix' or 'super soil'. I suppose they could be calling it Organic as in no chemicals. In any case, I too wonder what the organic matter content is. Can you post a closeup picture of the soil? Dig up a shovel full so it's not just the surface showing.

  • 9 years ago

    Let's be clear. "Organic" has two independent meanings. One is that it is composed of a lot of hydrocarbons. Another is that it hasn't been touched by anything "unnatural". Never quite clear to me what is meant by "unnatural", though I think it relates to manufactured chemicals. I suspect your soil was marketed as the latter. The duplicity of that word leads to a lot of confusion.

  • 9 years ago

    That's why I like to capitalize the 'chemical free' type, it's all very confusing.

  • 9 years ago

    " I suppose they could be calling it Organic as in no chemicals" Since water is a chemical how do you have a soil that is "chemical free" that would still grow plants that need water to grow?

    kimmq is kimmsr

  • 9 years ago

    Are you really explaining this to an environmental chemist? <eyeroll> You know what I meant.

  • 9 years ago
    last modified: 9 years ago

    Katie (the OP)... I really don't think thinning has much to do with root formation, only final size. I just recently ran an experiment here (for a totally different purpose) and planted nearly a dozen radishes in a single 12 oz plastic Dixie Cup (indoors under lights). They all germinated in two days an grew for 4 weeks (we just harvested them last week... mmmm, they were good). The roots all began to swell right up in two weeks and by the end of the fourth week wound up looking like dinner rolls packed into a baking pan, all bucked-up against one another and even popping out from between each other. Also I don't believe the issue is soil composition as I've grown root vegetables in heavy soil (referring to clay-ish and not nutrient density) and the roots still form... they tend to push up more out of the soil, tend towards misshapen and not get as large but they still form. So with those possibilities out of the way, that just leaves mineral deficiency or an imbalance or excess nitrogen... And the biggest clue here is that your greens (tops) grow just fine... so this tells me its not a mineral deficiency. The only thing left on the table that makes any sense is excess nitrogen levels. You don't state how you went about taking your samples or when, nor who did your testing (ex. was this a DIY kit? I'm wondering because most labs also do pH and organic matter). The nitrogen content in soil is so fleeting that if you didn't take your soil samples during the warm growing season, then the results you got likely may not really be relevant... this would be very likely if you were using fertilizer salts but also if you were growing organically as microbial activity is directly related to soil temps and moisture. I do know excess nitrogen will cause many root vegetables to push top growth rather than root formation (from first-hand experiences) and you did state how well your greens did so... What did you use for fertilizer during the growing season or how did you prepare your beds before you planted? These can all be clues to explain your lack of root formation and thus evolve into a solution. An example would be for instance say: if you mixed in (high-nitrogen) bat guano prior to planting and later side-dressed with blood meal and watered throughout the growing season with fish emulsion then the accessible nitrogen level could have been very high for the growing season but dropped off by fall with the cooling soil temps, if that's when you took your soil samples. I'm just throwing this out as an example but the only way for what you've described to be possible (based upon my own experiences anyway) seems to be an excess of nitrogen occurred during the growing season.