Software
Houzz Logo Print
lenarufus

Planting in same place

9 years ago

Is it true that if you plant a rose where one has grown you need to replace all the soil? I've read this but would love to hear of experience in either replacing the soil, or not.

Comments (20)

  • 9 years ago

    Marolena, you have convinced me. I've been skeptical about the value of mycorrhizal fungi for various reasons. 1)read that they occur naturally anyway,so spending money for them would be foolish and expensive 2) since they are living things, how to know if the ones you are buying are valid and alive? One year I did buy them and tried to use them on my bare-root roses, but the plants didn't flourish....HOWEVER, I'd bought these plants in the autumn following one of the worst summers everin Europe. Here in Italy, the usual tremendous heat and drought, whilst in the Netherlands, the summer had been sunless and "cold" (the roses came from the Netherlands). Once planted out in my garden, things didn't go very well, either: drought in fall and winter, and then again a wretched hot, dry summer. So I seriously don't think it was a fair trial!

    From what I read, I get the impression that rose replant disease is actually a lot worse in the UK than it is in Italy,and in the USA they don't really have it. So, if you in the UK can testify to it's complete effectiveness when re-planting,I guess it's worth while that I give them another chance. Any tips on how to find "valid" ones, or is this an un-necessary worry?


  • 9 years ago

    I actually bought some of this and it's been sitting in the fridge for a while, I'll try it but will probably also replace some of the soil with a mix of bought rose mix and peat coir .. which will mean if it thrives I'll never know which to credit- very unscientific!

  • 9 years ago
    last modified: 9 years ago

    I just dig up the old rose with its root ball and a little of the surrounding soil , then add to the hole composted manure and Espoma rose tone ,and back fill with topsoil that has peat moss then plant the new rose and water it with 1 Tbs fish emulsion in a gallon of water .sometimes I add a cup of "Azomite " to the hole too . My roses flourish usually .

  • 9 years ago

    bart, I just use either David Austin's own brand or one called Rootgrow. It comes in a kind of powdery granular form and is just so easy to sprinkle, I'm happy to pay the extra now I know it works for me... I was sceptical previously as thought it a waste of money, now I consider it essential if you grow a number of roses and replace them regularly, as we tend to do on these forums, I think... I've also been told you can grab a handful of soil from around an Oak tree or somesuch and use that, it's supposed to work the same, but I prefer to sachet method, it's more convenient...

    I'm not sure it happens everywhere, I'm inclined to think it's to do with the rootstock used here, as I have replaced an 'own root' with a 'grafted' rose and that rose is not suffering. I have also replaced a 'grafted' with an 'own root', and that rose is not suffering either, so it does tend towards the rootstock for me, when grafted is replaced with another grafted of the same type...


  • 9 years ago

    Here's an interesting article on the subject..... http://www.rose.org/advances-in-understanding-rose-replant-disease/

  • 9 years ago

    I've just realised I might have thrown away some beneficial fungi - there was some Phallus impudicus, or stinkhorn growing at the base of a rose in the mulch ... but it was near the front door and really smelt bad so I removed it. I wonder if it is mycorrhizal?

  • 9 years ago
    last modified: 9 years ago

    I don't think stinkhorns are mycorrhizal, see link..... https://puyallup.wsu.edu/wp-content/uploads/sites/403/2015/03/mycorrhizae.pdf

  • 9 years ago

    Just curious marlorena, why didn't you like the Austin Wollerton hall?

  • 9 years ago

    It seems that while smelly, stinkhorns are beneficial to plants. Just as well as apparently it's impossible to get rid of them without using nasty chemicals

  • 9 years ago

    I have tried the David Austin brand of mycorrhizal fungi and it worked really well. I had no luck before planting another rose in this one area in the garden, but last year I tried this and it was amazing! I planted a ZD climber and it took off. I did sprinkle the fungi on the roots - there's a YouTube video showing exactly what to do. Give it try. It works!

  • 9 years ago

    When I moved into my house in 1995 there was a rosebush in the yard that was planted in the 1970's according to my neighbor. I removed it in 2006 and replanted up at my moms. I did NOT amend the soil at all just planted another rose in that spot and the new rose bush has grown & bloomed well just like the rose bush that was originally there...Maybe in depends on the situation...

  • 9 years ago
    last modified: 9 years ago

    Thank you for that link. wirosarian. I read everything I can find by Dr. Linda Chalker-Scott, but I had not seen this. According to her, and I believe her, I wasted $40 on 2 bags of mycorrhizal last season. I thought the mycorrhizal fungi was the reason my new roses did so well, growing at rates surpassing roses I had previously planted without mycorrhizal. However, after reading this, I feel sure it wasn't the purchased mycorrhizal, but rather because I had mulched my garden with arborist wood chips the preceding fall for the first time, which in turn, created the environment for mycorrhizal fungi to grow. I have a mountain of this mulch after having our property cleared of 40+ tall pines. The logs were hauled off, but the branches were chipped up and left for me to mulch with. I had read numerous times that wood chip mulch depletes the soil of nutrients, but after some research and finding the Back to Eden site, then finding Dr. Chalker-Scott's papers on arborist wood mulch, I had no fear that would be the case. Last spring, after the mulch had sat, undisturbed all winter, a white substance had developed though out the mulch. I didn't know what it was until I read the link wirosarian provided above, but somehow felt it had to be beneficial. I continue to read that wood chip mulch will deplete the soil of nutrients, but I don't believe that anymore. I'm happy I won't have to spend more money on bags of mycorrhizal fungi. For anyone interested, Dr. Chalker-Scott can be found on Face Book here She runs a tight ship with rules for answers to be research based and not anecdotal. Personally, I appreciate the anecdotal answers to my questions here on GW, but I suppose there is a place for both approaches.

  • 9 years ago

    Bart says

    From what I read, I get the impression that rose replant disease is actually a lot worse in the UK than it is in Italy,and in the USA they don't really have it.

    Maybe if true this accounts for the different experiences?


  • 9 years ago

    lenarufus...

    I had to get rid of 'WOH' due to some building work, it was in the way and I chose not to keep it, as I didn't like the way the flowers faded to a wishy washy buff colour. I think the rose would look better on a red brick wall, or any wall really, as it is at the property it's named after... I liked the scent though, very much what they call myrrh..

    I forgot to mention earlier another way of getting mycorrhizal fungi in your rose planting hole, which has recently been discovered and was put out here on a t.v. gardening programme last year. Chopped up roots of Plantago Major [the wild plantain found as a lawn weed]....

    I was delighted to hear about it as it confirmed something I was doing back in 1990 when I developed my first big rose garden. I had a large lawn and decided to carve out borders and reuse the turf which was unsprayed and full of weeds, plantains the lot.

    I put a slab of turf upside down in the planting hole, chopped it a little and put the bare root rose on top of that. I got a terrific result from all my roses, but didn't understand why. The lawn was full of plantains.. I made no other amendments or feeding in the hole itself..

    It should also be stated that if using M.Fungi you should't put phosphorus fertilizer with it, such as Bone Meal, as it has an adverse reaction to the fungi.. that's what I understand..



  • 9 years ago

    I've noticed white fungi growing under the eucalyptus mulch on the garden - we also used the woodchip from a tree the neighbours chopped down - maybe any organic matter works to add beneficial fungi. These 2 articles are interesting, they suggest that just adding organic material, not tilling and not using chemical fertilisers are good ways to add mycorrhizal fungi to the garden and make healthy soil

    http://www.motherearthnews.com/organic-gardening/creating-your-own-mycorrhiza-zbcz1403


    http://www.finegardening.com/mycorrhizae-help-feed-your-plants

  • 9 years ago

    Thank you, lenarufus, for the links. So interesting and helpful. When my husband was bringing wheelbarrows of mulch from the big pile at the back of the property for me to spread around my newly planted rose bed, I thanked him for finding all that stringy white material in the mulch. I didn't know what it was, but had a feeling it must be good. He said, oh, you want that? I was trying to avoid it, but it was hard because there's so much of it. There should be even more of it this year because it sat undisturbed over winter. I feel so dumb buying 2 bags of M. Fungi last year.

  • 9 years ago

    I'm still going to use some of the stuff I bought when I replace my rose as an insurance against rose replant disease .. every little bit helps hopefully!

  • 9 years ago

    Urgh...see, the arguments presented here are one reason why I never tried buying mycorrrhiza a second time,but when I read of Marlorena's experience, I think it really might be worth splurging. You see, I have at least 2 old rose plants that I'm going to probably get rid of next fall, and though I'll of course be adding a lot of organic matter, etc to the areas when I replant,I just can't help wondering if a little extra boost might come in handy. My soil is so impoverished and bad,and obviously organic matter is the way to go, but a bag of powdered fungi is so light and easy to carry about,and just throwing it in might help...

    Gotta start looking around for those wild plantains; I think they may grow here in Italy...

  • 9 years ago

    haha yes I did google plantains but there are none of those weeds growing around in our neighbourhood. But they must grow in Italy , I found this on the web

    Caption: Plantain. 16th century Italian illustration of a broadleaf or greater plantain (Plantago major), by Gherardo Cibo, 1568.

    It is meant to be similar to comfrey. I have a feeling that if you grew a patch of plantain, or comfrey, or some other green plant and dug it in, microbes and fungi would be encouraged, or in any case the soil would be better off.