Software
Houzz Logo Print
seanfduncan

Mushroom compost on roses

Hi everyone. I planted four roses this year using some spent mushroom compost as amendments to the soil. They all seemed to be sorouting over winter- suddenly, when spring arrived and I'm expecting them to take off, they all show similar signs of the buds drying out and dying back! I'm devastated! Anyone know why this might be happening? The others without the mushroom compost seem to be getting on fine.

Comments (25)

  • 9 years ago

    I've never used it myself, but I have seen it used as a mulch (mixed 3 parts to 1 of cow manure). The fellow who uses it as a mulch puts it 4" thick, and he has a wonderful rose garden. Maybe it's different if you plant the roses into it. It sounds like it's not retaining water? Sorry not be of help, but others with more experience will chime in soon, I'm sure. Trish

  • 9 years ago

    Thanks Trish- I'm wondering if something was wrong with my batch. My 'Sir Paul Smith' rose I can replace but the 'Guinee' and 'Souvenir de Dr Jemain' were really good quality bare root ones that I would struggle to replace now. They are all in pots but the 'Old Port is in the ground, mixed with regular soil....there is SOMETHING in there that has caused the same reaction in all of them.... Tomorrow I'll unearth the Paul Smith and see what's what. And to think, I'd even contact d the rose seller to complain! It's like there was Round up or something in there- all the growth has started to dry up and die back.

  • 9 years ago

    Where did you source the compost from? There have been issues here in the UK before regarding long acting herbicide contamination in mushroom compost. It's possible that they sprouted using the stored energy in the canes and then when they started uptake of nutrients through the roots...

  • 9 years ago

    Oregon State University posted a helpful article on mushroom compost. Carol

    http://extension.oregonstate.edu/gardening/node/33

  • 9 years ago

    No idea if there were issues before, FDUK. I bought the compost when I went horse riding last autumn but I forget the name of the place now. It was the first time that I'd tried or even seen it. The nursery owner said everyone raves about it.


    Thanks Carol- I'd just read that same article. I've seen anither article saying that it tends to be very alkaline and so acid-loving plants won't like it. Roses prefer a more acid soil but even so, this reaction is bizarre!

  • 9 years ago
    last modified: 9 years ago

    I used mushroom compost for the first time last year in my 2'x2' planting holes in a ratio of about 1 pt. mushroom compost to 3 or 4 pt. regular compost, a little of my horrible soil, and varying amounts of Rose Tone, and had better growth than ever before. I was planning to use it again this year, but after reading that link (thanks, portlandmysteryrose) I am rethinking that. Sean, I'm so sorry about your roses. That's terrible!

  • 9 years ago

    I think it's good, in moderation. I had heard about it's alkaline properties. If you already have alkaline soil, it could make it worse.


  • 9 years ago

    Herbicide damage is one guess, the compost containing root eating beetle larvae (grubs) is another. Have you uprooted one of the affected plants to look at its roots and what's in the soil?

    I generally avoid using organic amendmens like manure etc in pots.

  • 9 years ago

    I'm unearthing it today Nik. Ther I was, thinking I'd given them such a rich mix to get going because other than the'Sir Paul Smith' and 'Old Port', I'd read that the other two (especially Guinee) need extra TLC. I've read that Guinee especially, can be fussy and get off to a slow start- is that anyone else's experience? Just having breakfast here- I can hardly wait to conduct what may be a rose autopsy as soon as I'm done. :(

  • 9 years ago

    My...... GOD! :o0 I am shocked! NOT A SINGLE ONE OF THE ROSES GREW ANY ROOTS AT ALL!!!! :( Thank God I didn't buy too much of that stuff! I think it was manure, passed off/mixed up as compost or if it was the real stuff, either way it must be contaminated. One year at the allotment we had some manure delivered- it killed everything! We later discovered it was the herbicide used to kill the broad-leaved weeds but not the fine-leaved grass that had been eaten by the cattle and was STILL present in the manure! Just goes to show how bad these chemicals are. I washed all the roots- they're not dead. They've all been soaking in buckets of clean water since. I'm going to repot them in plain compost, with my prayers and hope for the best! I managed to acquire the last Guinee at a plant nursery! No Souvenir du Dr Jemain though- I hope it pulls through, as it's the least worse for wear. The Sir Paul Smith is the worst of the lot but let's see- roses are tougher than we might think! Pics below.

    Souvenir du Dr Jemain

    SdDJ roots:

    Sir Paul Smith:

    SPS roots:


    Old Port:

    OP roots


    Guinee roots

  • 9 years ago

    Just look at the fussy Empereur du Maroc, by comparisson- planted at the same time but without that cursed 'compost'! Well in leaf and even flower buds.

  • 9 years ago

    I had a similar experience with roses I planted in too much peat moss. I dug them up, soaked them in water and replanted them without peat moss - my soil is already on the acid side - and they bounced back quickly. I trust yours will do the same. Wishing you success.

    With your documented notes and photos, would you perhaps have any recourse with the mushroom compost company? If Strawchicago is reading, I think she would know how to test their product for contaminates at little or no cost using basic household ingredients.

  • 9 years ago
    last modified: 9 years ago

    If they are alive, I would venture the guess that it isn't herbicide damage. Maybe the stuff was too strong and you used too much of it. I never add any amendments or fert when I initially plant bare roots in pots. I just use bagged neutral pH peat based potting 'soil'.

  • 9 years ago

    We share mishaps of one sort or another...

    I think those might be alright.... I haven't used mushroom compost for many a year and then only as a mulch... what I use for pots is a 50/50 mix John Innes no. 3 and Levington's multi purpose [ or some other brand]... with added horticultural grit/gravel for drainage... mix in some granular fertilizer on top after planting... I think this is what's generally recommended here...

  • 9 years ago

    Thank you all for your kind cmments. ...perhaps the mixture was too strong but I still find the compost somewhat suspect. When I unpotted them today, the smell was very unpleasant. I'm getting rid of the 1/3 bag left.


    I will update you on my progress- I hope they pull through.

  • 9 years ago

    If the unpleasant smell was that of rotten eggs, which means H2S was present, that would be an indication of anaerobic conditions which in turn would mean that the mix was too dense with little or no oxygen in the soil solution retaining too much water.

  • 9 years ago

    Oh oh, all my new roses are planted on a mound of mushroom compost . Maybe I should replant

  • 9 years ago

    No-no Kristine! Please check to see if there are signs of growth. I definitely got a bad batch. Nik's words are resonnating- when I bought the bags last year, they were sealed airtight, and cable-tied in strong, black plastic bags. The mix was already quite heavy, I recall when carrying them to my car. They remained there all autumn and winter until this year. When I unearthed the Guinee, there was indeed an unmistakeable rotten egg whiff of hydrogen sulphide and something septic. It was quite wet in the pot and not pleasant.

    Please everyone- don't be put off mushroom compost. I think this stuff was just not a good mix, badly packaged and stored. The comments here have been very helpful.

  • 9 years ago

    I'm so sorry to hear about your experience, but glad that you solved the mystery! Sending good wishes for your roses :)

  • 9 years ago

    Looks like I better replant asap thank you souch for the heads up

  • 9 years ago

    I replanted one of my new roses. I read the ingredients and no lime. Just mushroom, Cow and chicken manure

  • 9 years ago

    Well...update:

    The Souvenir du Dr Jamain looks to be on the mend and has sprouted a few shoots!

    The Old Port is gaining ground:

    The Guinee has also bounced back with one shoot so far (no pic) but.... sadly, the Sir Paul Smith doesn't look like it will make it- in fact, I think it has already departed these lands to the Great Garden in the Sky:

    I did manage to source another Sir Paul Smith and another Guinee, so fingers crossed, I will have only lost one rose. To be honest, I wasn't very happy with the specimens received from that vendor to begin with. All in all, valuable lessons learned.

  • 9 years ago

    Never a dull moment in the rose garden! There's always something new to learn. So glad it wasn't a total loss for you. Your roses do look like they're bouncing back nicely.

  • 9 years ago

    Got talked into mushroom compost by the nursery manager after they flat ran out of both their regular compost. My soil is neutral, so the last thing I want is something alkaline. I plan to test it before I put it down.

    I used most of it for topdressing in another garden with acid soil and those roses are doing very well. It was a very light topdressing as I didn't trust the product (!) and the roses were newly planted own-roots. Cross fingers.

    The last two bags will be used to prep an 8 by 10 foot bed for William R Smith which won't be planted until Sept/October. I'd take it back but after days of rain I doubt I could lift the bags and they are STINKY!

Sponsored
Mary Shipley Interiors
Average rating: 4.8 out of 5 stars34 Reviews
Columbus OH Premier Interior Designer 10x Best of Houzz