Software
Houzz Logo Print
hzdeleted_24200779

Does "slightly alcaline soil" mean "limestone soil"?

9 years ago

The soil in my garden is slightly alcaline. I purchased a rose from a French company (I'm in Italy) which is grafted onto Multiflora root-stock,and only just now noticed that on the nursery's site, they say it's adapted for "tout sol mais à éviter pour les sols calcaire" which I think translates as " any soil but avoid limestone soil" Is "slightly alcaline soil" the same thing as "limestone soil"? if so, is there anything I can do to change it to make the rose happy? I confess I am a bit puzzled by this, since I have a Multiflora rose growing quite happily in my garden,so I wonder if there might be a difference between the two things

Comments (9)

  • 9 years ago
    last modified: 9 years ago

    Is "slightly alcaline soil" the same thing as "limestone soil"?

    Not necessarily, but it is the most common circumstance. Alkaline (base) is higher pH (>7) mostly due to carbonates. The source of soil carbonate is most often calcium carbonate (limestone). Excess calcium, in and of itself, is almost never detrimental to plants, but in soils with high pH, some nutrients (iron, Mn, copper, Zinc etc.) will become less available to plants. Some plants can adjust to a point with root exudates and still access those nutrients, other plants can't. You might want to contact the company and inquire about the recommended pH. "Slightly alkaline" shouldn't be detrimental to the health of the plant, but may affect color of the blooms.

    User thanked User
  • 9 years ago

    Is there any way I could correct this?

  • 9 years ago

    Yes. See: http://forums2.gardenweb.com/discussions/4578077/ancaster-sulfur-spring?n=9 for acidifying materials. I'm not a flower gardener, so you'll want advice from someone experienced in how much and the manner of how to apply them to your soil.

    User thanked User
  • 9 years ago
    last modified: 9 years ago

    We have 'limestone soil' here in the Great Valley of E. Tennessee. However, the pH can range from neutral, to acidic, to slightly alkaline. I wouldn't 'correct' anything until you get a laboratory test to determine the actual pH level.

    The term you used is 'slightly alkaline', but to make corrections, it's good to have numbers which can be used to determine how much of an amendment is actually needed.

    User thanked rgreen48
  • 9 years ago

    'Sols calcaire' would be calcareous soils ie chalky. They have a high percentage of calcium carbonate. In some areas near where I live the soil is almost white. But people seem to be able to grow roses. I'd believe the evidence of your happy multiflora and not worry about it.

    User thanked floral_uk z.8/9 SW UK
  • 9 years ago

    There is a very knowledgeable and active Roses forum on Gardenweb and they would most likely be helpful. http://forums2.gardenweb.com/forums/roses

    User thanked theparsley
  • 9 years ago

    Thanks, all! Actually I post regularly on the Rose forum,and put this up on that forum, too. But I wanted to hear from you all here on the Soil forum as well.

    This is a confusing question for me, since reading over there,on a different thread, a very knowledgeable rosarian says that multiflora roses, in general, greatly prefer acidic soil,but as I mentioned before, I do have that species Multiflora that is fine, as well as several Hybrid Multifloras,all of which seem quite happy. Unfortuneately here in Italy getting one's soil tested professionally is a pretty complicated and spendy prospect. I base my opinion of my soil's PH on the following evidence, none of which is very scientific, I fear. 1) Years ago,on a visit to the USA, I bought a couple of home soil-testing kits at Home Depot. These gave the result of "neutral" for PH. 2) I did the "red cabbage test" for soil PH; result was "slightly alkaline". 3) Wild hellebores grow VERY enthusiastically in my garden, and they are natives, not introduced by me. According to Internet, these plants are native to "slightly alkaline "soil. 4) I don't have many problems with chlorosis,not even on several roses that are supposedly prone to this condition in "alkaline" soil. So, all circumstantial evidence, but still...

  • 9 years ago

    Well, roses do fine in my garden; I've even got a lot of wild ones growing in totally uncultivated places; these are native plants, so I guess i shouldn't be too worried. Thanks, all!

Sponsored
The Creative Kitchen Company
Average rating: 5 out of 5 stars52 Reviews
Columbus Area Kitchen Remodeling and Refacing Professional