Software
Houzz Logo Print
coriannh0uzzviolatedmyprivacy

OT - Weed Torch?

Who has a weed torch and loves it? Who doesn't like theirs? Can anyone talk me into or out of getting and using one?

The record rain this past year has made hand pulling weeds on a sloped area where I have river rock almost impossible without falling over and breaking my ankles. The tap roots are all SOOO strong! Is it crazy to use a weed torch in an area with river rock? I'm imagining VERY hot rocks... like hot coals.... and unfortunately burning all the little wormies and other good bugs in there.... but at least getting rid of the weeds without hand pulling, falling over and rolling down the rocky slope.

Any advice on weed torches? This is an area not really close to any roses and has nothing to do with roses I'm afraid.

Comments (41)

  • 9 years ago

    YIKES! I know you're still gettin' rain up there ... but down here, weeds and grasses are already browning off -- and we're already hearing high-fire-danger warnings. The very idea gives me palpitations!


    Cori Ann - H0uzz violated my privacy thanked jerijen
  • 9 years ago

    If you want to use vinegar that way, household vinegar (10%) isn't going to do what you need. (I've tried.)
    But you can buy 30% vinegar at "farm stores" -- and that, apparently, WILL function as a good weed-killer.

    But note . . . I was also cautioned that when spraying it, you should wear a mask.

    Cori Ann - H0uzz violated my privacy thanked jerijen
  • 9 years ago

    I've never used one but certainly sounds like your situation could use one!

  • 9 years ago

    My experience is that the torch mainly works for small and immature weeds. If there are big tap roots the weeds tend to grow back. They can burn up seeds, which could be useful.

    Cori Ann - H0uzz violated my privacy thanked belmont8
  • 9 years ago

    From much experience pulling tapweed type plants, if you leave any root there, it just resprouts, so I think i would agree with Belmont; only burning the tops off might not be much use...

    Might be very satisfying though!

    Cori Ann - H0uzz violated my privacy thanked Curdle 10a (Australia)
  • 9 years ago

    My husband has one and loves it. He uses a small cart to pull around the propane tank. He says that it really controls the weeds.

    Cori Ann - H0uzz violated my privacy thanked Cathy Kaufell
  • 9 years ago

    I would probabaly have my hubby use it instead of me too. It scares me a little... giving me heart plantations like it does Jeri!

  • 9 years ago

    I'm afraid in our situation it would set the whole hillside on fire. My husband uses a weed whacker, but this year for the first time (must be due to lots of rain) all the areas he cut came back up again.

  • 9 years ago

    Yeah -- Clay also uses a weed-whacker. There's no hope of ELIMINATING weeds here. Heck, most of our "grass" could be classed as weeds.

  • 9 years ago

    Have you tried one of those weed pulling tools designed for stuff with tap roots? Here's an old thread... there may be newer, improved versions since then:

    http://forums.gardenweb.com/discussions/1530489/tool-for-weeding-out-dandelions

    Cori Ann - H0uzz violated my privacy thanked User
  • 9 years ago

    If any one is considering something like vmrs thread, the weed hound really is excellent . Sold at lowes. We have the sharp prickly kind everywhere and I go around with that tool and bucket and pull out so many effortless . They are so armed with prickles and the tool keeps you from touching them. It's been a godsend!

    I'm guessing Cori Ann has a lot more going on with the rocks though!

    Cori Ann - H0uzz violated my privacy thanked Lilyfinch z9a Murrieta Ca
  • 9 years ago

    Lilyfinch, the river rocks may be a deal-buster; I guess it depends how close the rocks are to each other? Rocky terrain isn't a problem I've ever had to deal with here. We do have plenty of dandelions and prickly thistles, though, so a weed hound or something similar may be in our future.

    Thanks,

    Virginia

  • 9 years ago

    I am thinking of getting one for weeds in my dry river bed too. I have used one in my dad's garden in Vegas. Not sure how long lasting it was but it was easy to use though not as fast as you would think.

    Cori Ann - H0uzz violated my privacy thanked totoro z7b Md
  • 9 years ago

    Yeah it's the rocks and the slope that make me want to try it. In my other dry river bed I actually don't mind pulling the weeds because it's not as sloped... so I'm able to get a good footing. On this sloped area though, it's really hard to feel stable enough to pull weeds without the rocks rolling out from under me or without me rolling down the hill. The weed hound looks great for lawns or garden beds, but not for river rock. I don't know... I'm still undecided on the weed torch. I guess this is one of the main drawbacks to all of the rain!

  • 9 years ago

    :-( Ok now I have a new problem in the same river rock slope. Can anyone offer advice? Some blackberries are coming back. The area was bulldozed. But you know blackberries. Now my initial issue with the weeds seems minuscule.

    Should I just use round up? Awwww GAWD I really don't want to, but is that what I should do? Maybe get the weed torch and have my hubby try it first? The thing is, my yard is a wildlife habitat for bees. Not in this actual area, but about 20 yards away I have several plants specifically for bees. I don't have a lot of experience with round up because I try to be all organic, herbicide and pesticide free. Won't it harm the bees, even if they are 20 yards away? Or is the risk small? Maybe in the early morning before they're out?

    If it was just this along the rocky slope I would do it by hand...

    Even this I would do by hand...

    This... I would begrudgingly try to do it by hand and probably twist my ankle...

    But this and this.... ahhhhh! And it just keeps getting worse down the slope since that's where all the damn rain water went. What do I do?

  • 9 years ago
    last modified: 9 years ago

    Cori Ann, you have more experience with rocky terrain and California rain patterns, but aren't you about to have more dry weather starting soon? If the rain will be ongoing, the weed problem will be also, but if the rains will soon be gone, I would wait before spraying anything that might harm your food plants, your roses, the bees, etc.

    Some hand-pulling is probably warranted, anyway, but please don't go twisting your ankle... And the weed torch may also be worh a try if you aren't posing a fire danger.

    Good luck,

    Virginia

  • 9 years ago

    Surprisingly enough we are supposedly going to have more rain next weekend. Lately it's been a very dry heat though. I just don't know what to do. Blackberries will take over in a heartbeat. Dry heat doesn't faze them at all. :-(

  • 9 years ago

    You can use Round Up, the torch, and/or boiling water to kill the weeds and then use Preen to prevent germination of new weeds. Preen lasts about 3 months. You will still get a few weeds but not many. You know the drawbacks to using Round Up or the torch. The drawback to the boiling water is that it is tedious to keep boiling water and it usually requires more than one application. If blackberries are that formidable, wait until the cane is about 12-18" high, fill a bottle 1/2 to 3/4 full of Round Up and insert the cane. Be sure that the bottle is dug into the soil deeply enough that it wont tip over. Leave it for a week or two. This even takes out young trees that have gotten away from us.

    Cath

    Cori Ann - H0uzz violated my privacy thanked cathz6
  • 9 years ago

    Thanks so much Cath. I would just solarize it...but we have trees not too far away and I am not so sure if they're roots are in this area or how deep they are and I don't want to kill them. Interesting about boiling water! The blackberries are like a bad horror movie to a gardener in this area. :-/

  • 9 years ago

    Please,don't cave in and use herbicides,Cori Ann!!!!!!! I have blackberries all over the place, and know how difficult they are. If by "solarizing" you mean covering the area with plastic and letting the sun cook the weeds I don't see why that would harm the trees. I think the idea of solarization (if that is indeed the correct term for what I'm talking about) is that it cooks the upper part of the plant, and keeps it cooked, so eventually the roots just die. It takes time, but won't poison the earth.

    Actually, if it was me, I'd do either that or else use heavy black plastic to cover the area (I have done that and it really does work).It has to stay covered a year or better yet, two. In the meantime I'd be thinking of something to plant up on that slope; a thick, dense, ever-green groundcover that would end the weed problem for good.

    Cori Ann - H0uzz violated my privacy thanked User
  • 9 years ago

    Bart, yes you have the right idea about solarization. Here, solarization takes just about 6 weeks since it gets so hot. It can heat up about 18 inches of soil though, so it may cook the tree roots in that area. I may just decide that's the way to go anyway. We are looking into the weed torch still too.

    I have decided I'm definitely not going to use herbicides. Our neighbor's bee hive is so healthy they just naturally split into another yesterday. It was amazing to watch. My neighbor ran over to tell me yesterday morning and we just stared at the swarm for a really long time! I like to think my habitat for bees is helping the health of that hive, (or those hives now) and any other hives in the area. I feel responsible to keep it that way.

  • 9 years ago

    I just saw your post too Rosefolly. Darn. I guess Round Up isn't totally off the table for me yet then. I will try everything I can first though. But yes, blackberries.... ahhhhhhhh!!!!!!!!

  • 9 years ago

    Stand by your guns, Cori Ann!!! You don't need herbicides. A large section of the top of the slope that is now my garden was formerly covered with mature blackberries; it was an impenatrable wood of them (I don't know the exact measurements, but you must calculate that my garden is so big that you have to think in terms of many meters at a time. Area in question must be at least ten meters by eight,and in reality it's probably double that; if you want, I'll try to measure). I cut them to the ground and then covered the area with a sheet of thick black plastic. It was ugly to look at, sure, but after 2 years or so, when I took it of, I had a clean slate. The blackberries have not returned,certainly not en masse,and by now I can barely remember them.

    If you turn to herbicides,it'll be too much like developing a drug habit. You poison the weeds you have now with this dangerous, carcenogenic Round-Up crap (yeah, you're scared of twisting your ankle on that slope when weeding,and rightly so; imagine how fun will it be staggering around up there with poison in your hand). They seem to die off; then, up you go again with a new poison (Preen) (how long does the Round-Up linger in the soil? what chemical reaction will be created by pouring this Preen on top of the soil already poisoned by Round-Up ?) The effect of the Preen only lasts three months, according to an earlier post on this thread. Then, what do you do? The situation is still what it was before. It's probable that new blackberries will emerge. So there you are, back at square one, buying more "Round-Up" and "Preen",enriching the manufacturers of these poisons, poisoning your own soil, yourself, and the groundwater...is that where you want to go?


    Cori Ann - H0uzz violated my privacy thanked User
  • 9 years ago

    Forgot to add-my oaks did not suffer in the least from the black plastic treatment.

  • 9 years ago

    Cori Ann, just saw the post re the hive splitting!!! Ahhhhh amazing, now you really can't use herbicides! :) The bees just put on a big show to convince you not to! ;)

    Cori Ann - H0uzz violated my privacy thanked Anna-Lyssa Zone9
  • 9 years ago

    Used correctly, as in mixed to label directions with spot application on the weeds, glyphosate is perfect for your situation! There's nothing in the photos you shared that shows me any danger to bees, because there aren't any flowers yet. A quick spritz on the weed, let the chemical do its thing, and the weed is history. It doesn't harm your soil, and won't harm you if used properly. That's how I handle poison ivy here, as I am VERY allergic.

    Preen may not be the tool for preventing new weeds, because it is best when applied then covered with something like mulch.

    Cori Ann - H0uzz violated my privacy thanked hartwoodroses
  • 9 years ago
    last modified: 9 years ago

    I am waiting for rain to pass, and then to use RU for a stoned area, the weeds grow so fast with a lot of rain, the next dry day here will be next Tue.

  • 9 years ago

    Yes, the rain has been good for the bees here too. It was even on the news a few nights ago that new swarms are being seen all over the place. Lots for them to eat. Luckily, everyone around here thinks this is a very good thing.

    I use Preen religiously every time I weed a bed. I do not put mulch on top of it (I mostly put it on top of newly mulched beds). I just water it in, per the instructions. In the past few weeks, I would say it has prevented the weeds from germinating on those beds at least 95%.

    Jackie


    Cori Ann - H0uzz violated my privacy thanked jacqueline9CA
  • 9 years ago

    Yes, Jackie is right. The Preen must be on top, not under mulch to work. Preen is not a herbicide. It is a germicide. It prevents weeds from germinating and emerging from the soil. It acts as a barrier.

    I have used black plastic as a weed barrier kept in place for a few years. It killed every living organism under it. It was more thorough and devastating to soil fertility than any herbicide I have used. Solarization, however, only lasts a few weeks and works well for many weeds. Established blackberries or small trees may be another matter.

    Cath

    Cori Ann - H0uzz violated my privacy thanked cathz6
  • 9 years ago

    Black plastic does not penetrate into the ground water, as herbicides do.

  • 9 years ago

    Cori Ann,

    Whatever you decide, you may want to embed some large stones or pavers into the slope for secure footing.

    Cath

    Cori Ann - H0uzz violated my privacy thanked cathz6
  • 8 years ago
    last modified: 8 years ago

    So....Hoping someone here may help me with this again this year. The weed torch worked great for the weeds and those nasty blackberries. The blackberries are gone!!!!

    Anyone thinking of getting one, definitely worth it if you have someone who can use it properly and it’s allowed. Not sure honestly if it’s really allowed here... it probably should not be in all honesty, but we’re semi rural so ??? My friendly neighbors haven’t complained and commented it’s a good idea, so we have the OK from them.

    But my one awful neighbor continues to spread their weed lawn over to these rocks by allowing their weed lawn to get knee high and go to seed. Grrrrrr.

    Has anyone used liquid corn-gluten as a pre-emergent weed control with success? The liquid versions have a tiny bit of nitrogen so maybe it would also help lightly fertilize the Crape Myrtle trees in the area?

    I want another option besides the weed torch... it’s scary!!!

    Im also going to try a hedge of germander to see if that can stop some of their weed seeds from coming over.

    Unless there’s a different hedge recommendation I should consider? Thank you!!!!

  • 8 years ago

    After talking to my good neighbors, who also have a problem with this awful neighbor, I decided on oleander instead of germander. I am not a fan of oleander, but agree it’s a good idea for a “weed-seed-wind-break” in this particular spot because the awful neighbor also has tons of gophers and does nothing to control them. They basically have a gopher and weed habitat. Grrrrr.

    The gophers don’t touch the oleander in other yards around me and I’m just not sure if they will eat the germander, but figure they might. Hopefully the oleander will be enough to help the spread of their awful weed seeds into my yard. Grrrrr.

    Hubby is going to use the weed torch a few more times in the winter/spring. Then we will see if I need to think about pre-emergent or if what were already doing is good enough for the season.

    I really detest this neighbor.

  • 8 years ago

    I have the same problem Cori Ann...I am in a semi rural area and I live next door to someone who almost never mows their 1 acre of grass. Like you , I have a lot of gravel areas and the torch works pretty well if you keep up with it often.

    I have found that torching and then putting down a fresh layer of gravel has helped...you've got to make sure the gravel stays thick.

    But...the most effective thing was hiring a weekly mow and blow service to keep up on the weeding on a weekly schedule. That's the only way I've been able to keep tabs on it. I'm also organic and don't spray roundup.

  • 8 years ago
    last modified: 8 years ago

    That’s good to know. Thanks Rosylady. I’m so sorry you have the same annoying problem, but it’s nice to know I’m not alone.

    I may have to get some gravel delivered after weed torching if what were doing doesn’t work. I figure I may give it another year, or at least another season, before we invest in the gravel.

    Its large river rock now, so the gravel would have to just go on top, then we would have to rake it into the crevasses. Not sure how that would look, but if it works I’m all for it.

    So annoying. If I hired a now/blow service to mow their yard it would solve the problem.

  • 8 years ago

    Can you spray vinegar weekly, easier than using fire.

  • 8 years ago
    last modified: 8 years ago

    Thanks for the idea Summers. I’m not so sure vinegar would be easier actually. Fire is pretty easy, and it stays only where you aim it when used properly. The vinegar may get to the roots of other plants and trees I actually want there too, since it is a slope.

    The weed torch is great. It just scares me.

    The corn gluten pre-emergent is still a possible option I guess. More gravel too.

  • 8 years ago

    The oleander hedge idea seems good to me as well; physical barriers are always good. If you adapt various strategies together: hedge,torching/mulching... Perhaps it's like integrated pest management : several strategies together wind up being more effective than relying only on one method of control. Rosylady, I am grateful to you for refusing to use that abominable "Round-Up". I've read that that c++p has gotten into groundwater by now...

    Cori Ann - H0uzz violated my privacy thanked User
  • 8 years ago

    Btw, I though of another plus to having a hedge: it would help screen out the view of the disliked neighbours yard,hopefully help you to ignore them better, which would be good for the spirit. I know; I've had awful experiences with neighbours far worse than your, since they actively tried damaging us,on purpose, and there was no way to screen them out at all, and it was sooooooooo bad and hard on my karma. I am so glad we moved.

    Cori Ann - H0uzz violated my privacy thanked User