Software
Houzz Logo Print
towandaaz

"Epsom Salts Cures Black Spot!?"

9 years ago

I was at Home Depot today and a customer mentioned as she was checking out that the rose she was purchasing has black spot. The clerk responded enthusiastically, "Use Epsom salts! That will cure it." In my head, I said "Whaaaa?"

Was this a case of someone who is mistaken or something I've not heard before? My understanding is that "Epsom" salts can help to produce new basal breaks. I don't use it because my roses are mostly in pots, and I don't want over salted soil.

I went out of my way in the parking lot to ask if the customer who had parked next to me if she had ever heard of that. She said no, that she'll treat it initially with a fungicide and she believes our dry climate will be fine for the rose after that initial treatment. I thought, "whew!!"

Comments (19)

  • 9 years ago

    Alas Epson salts won't even help with creating basal breaks. Basal beaks are governed by the hybridization of the rose. If a rose is prone to making lots of new canes, then you are in luck but if it's not then nothing with make new canes. It all boils down to the vigour of the rose plant which is due to hybridization.

    towandaaz thanked oldrosarian
  • 9 years ago

    I think alfalfa does help. I put down a bunch in late winter and I have lots of basal breaks.

    towandaaz thanked Buford_NE_GA_7A
  • 9 years ago

    That Epsom salts is some sort of magical garden elixir is a myth, passed on by word of mouth by well-meaning but ill-informed gardeners, and is proving to be one that is very persistent and reluctant to die a natural death!! ALL Epsom salts can do is offset a magnesium deficiency - it is magnesium sulphate and is a good source of Mg for this nutrient deficiency. But it doesn't improve seed germination, it doesn't make plants grow more vigorously, it doesn't control any insect or disease issues, it doesn't make plants more floriferous or drought tolerant or disease resistant or any of the other various supposed beneficial characteristics attributed to it. There is simply nothing in the material or how it works with plants that would achieve these alleged results!

    The Myth of Epsom Salts.

    There are a number of these myths out there that folks cling to like glue but that have no basis in reality. All they have to is anecdotal experience which may or may not be valid but cannot be documented. There is no scientific proof that epsom salts is anything more than a moderate source of Mg, should that be required. OTOH, triacontanol, a natural plant growth hormone, has been studied extensively and its beneficial effect on plant growth has been well documented scientifically.

    ps. any gardening advice or recommendations received from box store employees should be taken with a very large grain of salt!! Most don't know beans about the plants under their care nor are any very knowledgeable about horticulture.

    towandaaz thanked gardengal48 (PNW Z8/9)
  • 9 years ago
    last modified: 9 years ago

    I wish BUT Not true...lol

    towandaaz thanked jim1961 Central Pennsylvania Zone 6a
  • 9 years ago

    on another garden forum that I follow, Epsom salt's multiple cure anything & everything tips, has prompted many of its users to repeat a modified version of an old quote for skepticism....."take it with a grain of salt" has now become "take it with a dose of Epsom salts"

    towandaaz thanked wirosarian_z4b_WI
  • 9 years ago

    The only thing I use Epsom salt for is greening up leaves. I've always used alfalfa, but mostly as a source of organic nitrogen. I only started making tea this year. Wether it made a difference in basal breaks is unclear.

    towandaaz thanked Sarah z8
  • 9 years ago

    Gardengal, that's what I thought about what I thought was bad advice. Epsom salt for black spot? Good luck with THAT! Kinda sad especially since the clerk said it with such authority.

  • 9 years ago

    Alfalfa contains a chemical that stimulates the roots. This in turn will give you more growth. But the growth may just be in the formation of new laterals and increased length of original the basal canes. Alfalfa has been used in many types of plants and has always found to be a benefit to them. I use it on my iris when I plant them. I definitely see positive results.

  • 9 years ago

    Very interesting thread. I've noticed alfalfa mentioned in here quite a bit didn't know what it did exactly.

    I've been using Epsom salts guess it's not really necessary?

    I might try alfalfa.

  • 9 years ago

    Aw bummer about there not being a way to encourage new basal breaks :( I have a Twilight Zone that has only 1 cane, it is very healthy and I absolutely love the blooms but was really hoping there was going to be a way to encourage more canes.

  • 9 years ago

    Yes, alfalfa can help and be a benefit. You can buy alfalfa pellets in a feed store or garden store and sprinkle a cup around each bush once or twice a year. Spring is ideal. Some make a mix with water and water it in around each bush.

  • 5 years ago

    I bought a bare root rose from J&P. It did nothing for months. Finally, I called and was told to use Epson Salts in a gallon of water. Finally it did sprout and eventually produce lovely roses.

  • 5 years ago

    One thing I used epsom salt for that totally did work: an ingrown toenail! What, you didn't think you'd be hearing about toenails on this thread? It's about epsom salt, so you should have! I was recommended this cure by an older black lady at a hair salon--a very nice lady, if confused about why a white girl was there. And it worked! Soaking parts of your body in epsom salt seems to be a magical cure...too bad this is not the case for roses.

  • 5 years ago

    Epsom salts are great to soak my tired body in after digging holes and planting roses!

  • 5 years ago

    I give my roses a 2Tablespoon dose of Epsom salts every spring with their liquid Miracle Gro for an extra boost of magnesium. Unless the rose is magnesium deficient and that deficiency is causing it to be more prone to fungal infection, it won’t cure black spot. In general, the healthier the rose, the more disease resistant it will be within the bounds of its genetic susceptibilities to diseases.

  • 5 years ago

    https://www.gracerosefarm.com/blogs/news/dear-gracie-your-questions-my-answers


    Gracie from Grace Rose farm actually talks about using Epsom salt... I also saw a YouTube video with a head gardener in Europe that said they used Epsom salt for blackspot, unfortunately I don’t remember the name...

  • 5 years ago

    Oh wow she uses a 1/2 cup Magnesium-Sulfate for each rose! Roses do love Magnesium but I only give mine a 1/8 cup Spring and Fall so half what she is giving hers. She does not mention if it is only once a year, but seems like a lot so it’s probably just in the Spring.

  • 5 years ago

    The best thing you can do for your roses is get a soil test and amend accordingly.