Software
Houzz Logo Print
msteddycat

question regarding programing a 48,000 grain 5600SXT softener

9 years ago

I purchased from a local dealer a 48,000 5600SXT softener supposedly filled with 1.5 cubic feet of purolite 100 resin. I just checked the BLFC sticker and it says .25 and I checked the salt and it says.75lb When the installer put in the capacity he put that it was 24,000 grain capacity. He put the hardness at 20 which included a calculation for the iron and he put it to regenerate every 7 days or 1000 gallons.Right now there are just 2 people living in the house but I wanted the tank to accommodate the size of the house- 4 bedrooms, 3 baths - I want to make sure that I got what I paid for and to make sure that the system is set correctly. I am using Diamond Crystal iron salts. I would appreciate any thoughts..Ms. Teddy

Comments (11)

  • 9 years ago

    We can't answer if you got 1.5 cf of purolite 100 resin.

    There is a legit reason to dial down the grain capacity - to reduce the salt usage.

    One of the big issues regarding "is it set up right?" will be the amount of Iron in the water and other specifics of the water test results.

    Post those and look for a response from AliceInWonderland. She/he is the go-to person for water treatment on here

  • 9 years ago
    last modified: 9 years ago

    We can tell if your softener is the right size for 1.5 cf of resin. Measuring the circumference and the height of the tank will provide enough information

    At minimum, we need to know your water hardness and iron analysis to ensure the softener is programmed correctly.

    Two thinks concern me:

    1. 24K grain capacity. He programmed it this way for one of three reasons. 1) Your softener is smaller than it should be. 2) Your softener is the correct size but programmed to only use 3 lb of salt/cf resin during regeneration, which is way too low with iron in the water. 3) He does not actually understand how to program the controller properly and thinks he needs to reduce capacity in order to regenerate more frequently - this is, sadly, a common problem.
    2. With iron-laden waters, regen should be every four days to mitigate resin fouling.

    I can be more specific after you provide analysis and tank size.

  • 9 years ago

    I checked the size of the water softener and it is 56" including a 6"base and is 34" wide. It is a private well and the latest water test 1/24/17 by a professional laboratory has Magnesium as 1.7 mg/l;iron 0.3mg/l and hardiness 7.4GPG.

    Te technician programmed it as 24,000 grain capacity, to regenerate every 7 days or 1000 gallons and he put in 20G of hardness. I purchased the morton rust out salt. My concern is that I do not understand why he would program a 48,000 grain capacity softener as a 24,000 grain softener. Right know there are only 2 people living in the house but the house has 4 bedrooms and 3 full baths and I wanted a softener to accommodate a larger family. I also do not understand the relationship, if any, between the brine line sticker and the salt sticker and the size of the resin tank. I appreciate any help you can provide. Ms. teddy

  • 9 years ago

    I have no idea what you are measuring that is 34" wide. A 56" tall tank, however, would typically have a 10" diameter and be the correct size for 1.5 cf resin. However, if you meant 34" circumference, that would be ~7" diameter, which would be too small to hold 1.5 cf of resin.

    While we talk about resin capacity in terms of how it arrives from the manufacturer, usable resin capacity depends upon salt dosage. Lower salt dosage = lower resin capacity. It would take obscene quantities of salt to maintain resin at the capacity at which it was manufactured. That, along with some capacity down-rating that is required depending upon water chemistry is why a 48K softener won't be programmed with 48K capacity. However, like I said previously, either your softener is smaller than you wanted or your softener guy just doesn't know how to correctly program it. Either/both are problematic.

    So, help me understand exactly what you measured, and we'll go from there.

    Also, are you certain that 1.7 mg/L was magnesium and not manganese. This will make a HUGE difference. In case your analysis is written as chemical symbols, Magnesium is Mg, manganese is Mn.

    In the mean time, set the day override to 4 days. The rest we can deal with after I have the requested information, but the day override is important with iron-laden water.

  • 9 years ago

    I was measuring the circumference of the tank which was 33 -34 so the diameter would be 11 . I checked the 2 most recent reports that I had from Kar laboratories 1/24/17 magnesium was 1.7 mg/l and on 4/16/16 magnesium was 1.6 mg/l I also checked a report done by the town on 02/08/14 which had magnesium at 1 mg/l The technician came back yesterday and he changed the capacity in the programming 20,000 grains, the regeneration to occur at 6 days or 900 gallons. My understanding was that you would program a softener at 30% less tts stated capacity depending on water conditions and usage. However, I did not understand why he would program the softener at 50% of its capacity. thanks for your help and sorry about the confusion re the diameter of the tank. I have 1.5 cubic foot Acid reducer tank and the two are the same height and diameter.

  • 9 years ago
    last modified: 9 years ago

    Oh, for pity's sake - you're correct about the diameter. Bonehead error on my part. So, your tank is the correct size. That's good. Your water guy, however, to be blunt, has no clue how to program a softener.

    You program a softener to the correct capacity based on the amount of salt you use to regen, which would be 30% less at a salt dose of 7 lb/cf resin . Your guy is changing the capacity and hardness to try to change when the softener regenerates. That us just plain wrong as it prevents the softener from properly controlling itself.

    At 7.4 gpg hardness plus 0.3 mg/L iron, you have an equivalent hardness of 9.0. Set hardness at 9. With a BLFC of 0.25, you need to use at least 8 lb salt per cf of resin in order to adequately remove the iron from the resin. Set brine fill time to 16 to accomplish this. You softener capacity at that brine rate is 36K. Set capacity to 36,000. With iron in your water, time is your enemy. Ferrous (dissolved, clear-water), reverts to ferric (particulate) iron quickly and will foul resin from the inside out. To mitigate this, you need to regen more frequently. Set day override to 4 days. Setting up the softener this way, as opposed to the way it is currently programmed, will keep your resin cleaner while, at the same time, allowing it to run more water between regens during times when you use much more water.

    If you choose to leave it like it is, we'll see you back here in a year or two when your softener isn't functioning as well as it should and you have iron stains on your fixtures.

    Alternately, you could install dedicated iron removal and program your softener for hardness only. In that case, you would drop your salt usage from 90 to 10 lb per month and regen every ~18 days or 3000 gallons.

  • 9 years ago

    Thanks for your help, I still have a few questions. I thought that you said the magnesium would affect the programming but I don't see it mentioned. The hardness right now is set at 20 grains as the amount of iron can be variable. I purchased the large system because of the size of the house. Right now there is only myself and sometimes my son and the water usage varies between 60 and 120 gallons a day. Generally, we would need I think 24000 grains a day X 7 =16,8000 per week. Could you program the softener as a 24,000 grain softener and then change the programming when increased capacity was needed? Or, if you do that does the resin not get rinsed properly or the iron build up too much. What is the relationship between the brine fill time and the amount of salt used, When we had the 1st regeneration there was salt in the water lines of the house and the technician had me change the programming in the regeneration cycle, I set it to B1 =10; BD =60, B2 =10 RR =12 BF =10. Specifically, he asked me to change RR form 10 to 12 and the BF from 12 to 10. I changed the DO from 6 to 5. The reason I didn't get a iron system is because we do not have sufficient water pressure to backwash the systems adequately. Ms. Teddy.

  • 9 years ago

    The hardness number includes magnesium. It's nice to know what the magnesium is, specifically, because if the ratio of magnesium to calcium is too high it can cause other problems, but adding it to the hardness would be adding it twice.

    If iron varies, what is the maximum? It would need to be 2.5 ppm for a hardness setting of 20 to be necessary.

    Softener capacity should be programmed to be what it actually is! This is determined by salt usage and resin specifications, NOT water usage. With 8 lb salt per cf resin (12 lb salt per regen since you have 1.5 cf of resin, your capacity is 36,000 - this comes directly from the resin manufacturer's specifications.

    When the softener enters the brine draw portion of the regen cycle, it draws out whatever water is in the brine tank. The brine fill then fills the brine tank with the correct amount of water for regen. Each gallon of water will dissolve 3 lb of salt. Set your brine fill to 16 (16 min * 0.25 gpm * 3 lb salt/gal = 12 lb salt. ). This is what you need to get the correct amount of salt through your resin. At a brine fill setting of 10, you aren't using enough salt to adequately remove the iron.


  • 9 years ago

    Thanks for all your help. The water person has been in business for a long time and had good reviews. I told him the system that I wanted and he agreed .I have the distinct sense that while he purchased a 1.5 cubic foot softener he filled it with 1 cubic foot of resin and I am not sure that he used the purolite resin that I requested. The fact that he set the softener capacity to 24,000 grains and then changed it to 20,000 grains would make sense if it only had 1 cubic foot of resin it it. and he changed the BF from 12 to 10 which would be consistent with 8lbs of resin/cubic foot. I am going to see what the next regeneration is like - we had excess salt tin the water lines. I am wondering though if he put a cubic foot of reisin in a larger tank if that presents an issue with programming it. Right now based on my water usage 120gallons a day or less x 10 grains of hardness I would need a softener that would give me 1200 grains/day x 7 =8400 grains/week so that a 1 cubic ft softener would be adequate for the present situation. My other thought is that I could program the softener as you suggested and see what happens. If there is a problem it might indicate that he did not use 1.5 cubic ft of resin. I really appreciate all your help. Ms. Teddy

  • 9 years ago

    If you have a tank that is tan fiberglass, you can find out easily. When the room is fairly dark, take a bright flashlight and place it on the side of the softener. You will see immediately where the resin level is. The tank should be ~2/3 full, with resin ~27-33" deep. If there is only 1 cf of resin in it, the resin bed will be only 18-22" deep.

  • 9 years ago

    Unforturnately, it is black. I am going to try it at night and see if I can see anything. Thanks for the suggestion. Ms.Teddy