Software
Houzz Logo Print
thegrimaldi

Need help finding someone who reclaims antique hardwood flooring

13 years ago
All - I am looking for someone who reclaims antique hardwood flooring, much of my upstairs and my kitchen has what we are told is the original flooring dating back to 1774. I fear that with my pets... certain charms of having antique floors in the house, could lead to their ruin!

The upstairs floor boards have boards that are around 13' long, about 1" thick, and varying widths - some up to 15"-16" (average around a foot wide). The kitchen boards are a little thicker but are only about 4-5" wide. Both are painted (buttermilk based paint - that was new to me!) but a lead test was done on both and came up negative (YAY!).

I was quoted 50 cents per sq. foot for them, and we would have to do the labor... I have been told by people that due to the width and age and great condition they are in, I should be getting quoted much higher... I am not great at finding the right people for this, so while I know its a shame to take them out (new floors that will be antique looking will replace them... it wont be cheap standard new floors!) any help would be great!

Comments (12)

  • 13 years ago
    There is only one reason anyone should consider removing such an intrinsically historic feature in and old house, and that is structural failure. Assuming your floor boards are sound, why would you even think of removing them? Have them refinished, or paint them, but don't remove them. They are part of the structural fabric of your building, not a "Skin" of flooring on a subfloor, as in modern homes.
    thegrimaldi thanked malhotte
  • 13 years ago
    Agreed with both above -- you already have antique floors, if you can find a way to refinish them, they'll hold up for another 250 years!
    thegrimaldi thanked kimdee24
  • PRO
    13 years ago
    I would never even consider removing those floors. It sounds like you are trying to cash in on them, which is strange unless you are in some sort of financial predicament. Please leave them in their original house if you can. I am cringing. :-/ Dont worry about pets. Kim is right they can last another 250 years, they are an inch thick.
    thegrimaldi thanked Oak & Broad
  • 13 years ago
    You can get milk paint remover...normal stripper won't touch it.
    There is likely no subfloor, either...so you'd have to replace that, too.

    I'd use them. If you really want new floors, lay them on top.
    thegrimaldi thanked zennifer
  • 13 years ago
    Taking them out is the surest way to "ruin" them, btw.
    thegrimaldi thanked zennifer
  • PRO
    13 years ago
    agreed!! I cant imagine the history behind those floors and who must have walked across them.
    thegrimaldi thanked Oak & Broad
  • 13 years ago
    Thank you all for that, it truly is what i would like to do... and has really pushed me to going that route - If i do that, I am probably going to have someone professionally refinish them. There are about 3 spots on the floor with full "holes" what have people seen done to fill that "void"?? I have heard of rope... I would love to hear some recommendations on that!
  • PRO
    13 years ago
    Any knots in your floors? If the holes are round, or roundish, one trick is to take a well dried branch off a tree, carve it to fit snugly. Glue it in with polyurethane glue (Gorilla Glue) saw of the excess and sand it in with the floors. No knots? A grain matched "dutchman" is made. Chiseling an angle at each end of the hole in the direction of the grain and making another piece of wood with very similar color and grain fit in, glue and face nail the double ended wedge in place. Sand and finish. first one, just about anyone can do. Second takes a trained hand and eye to do well. Best of luck!
  • 12 years ago
    last modified: 12 years ago
    Can I ask where you live?...just the state is close enough. I'm guessing East Coast, & likely Northeast. There are no doubt, many great restoration experts up there.

    Search for a local shop that specializes in historical house parts. They likely know of excellent floor restoration experts.

    Please don't hire the run of the mill floor guy. What you have there is a treasure & should be attended to in kind!

    Your floors are golden!
  • 12 years ago
    I love how old posts show up on the right & you're compelled to answer!

    Wonder how the floors look today.....
  • 12 years ago
    I think there's a key word search that pulls these old posts up, and people don't realize how old they are. I've seen some that are 2 years old........