Software
Houzz Logo Print
poaky1

Sad performing Lady's Mantle

9 years ago

I have a dismal looking "Lady's Mantle" plant. It's in mostly shade, and I give lots of water, so I wonder why it's only got 3 leaves? It's dark or I'd go take a pic. What should I be giving it? In my yard in full sun, it would dry out quickly. It's in a raised bed filled with bagged soil, maybe I should add a bit of native soil?

Comments (20)

  • 9 years ago

    I can think of lots of things that are wrong just based on your description. Let's start with "bagged soil in a raised bed" You've been posting for a long time here....have you looked up the cultural requirements of lady's mantle?

  • 9 years ago
    last modified: 9 years ago

    How about a picture? My first thoughts are too dry and too dark. Otherwise it is unfussy and should grow in any soil. It doesn't need something out of a bag. Mine grows and self sows in stone paving and heaven knows what is under there. Probably clay, sand and mortar.

  • 9 years ago

    the easy answer is.. move it in fall .. no real diagnosis needed ...


    but talking about it.. leads us all to learning ...so 2 thumbs up ...


    ken

  • 9 years ago

    What Ken said! Try it in another spot. You never know what you're getting with bagged soil; the pH may be all wrong for alchemilla.

  • 9 years ago

    Okay, sorry for the late response, but, I thought alchemilla liked slightly alkaline soil full sun if it's moist. I haven't added anything like lime to the soil, but, the leaves present haven't turned chlorotic, they just are few. I actually have kept this 1 alive longer than any I have ever planted, so maybe just some fertilizer? Here's a pic of the LM and a pic of how big the bed is, just to show that it has a good bit of soil in it, and doesn't really dry out quickly, it's mulched, but, I know if the soil is poor it doesn't matter all that much.


    I am not sure where else to try it, I know it grows great in the UK's moist climate in full sun. My reg soil is neutral ph or close to it. Maybe the coconut coir mulch I've used to mulch it is too acidic? Maybe if I plant it in my native soil it will do better, but, this is my most successful planting of LM ever. All others have died, this one is in yr 2 in there. So they've all croaked before the next spring.

  • 9 years ago
    last modified: 9 years ago

    I will add a little bit of Lime, and fert, it can't hurt as long as I don't overdo it. It needs to be where I can water often. If no improvement I'll move it in fall.

  • 9 years ago

    How long has it been in the ground? Apart from being small it actually looks healthy. If it is new just give it more time to establish.

  • 9 years ago

    i think your trying to love it to death ...


    to change a rather benign pH ... being an exponential function ... you will need a lot more soil amendment than throwing a little in a hole ... or around a plant ...


    one key i spotted .. you said: this is my most successful planting of LM ever.


    ==>>> lol .. been there with various plants ... i usually ended up. giving up on a given group .. why beat your head on the barn door.. repeatedly ...


    one other option.. if you dont mind messing with pots.. is dig it up ... grow some roots.. and replant in mid fall ... but then again.. that would be loving it a bit much.. so what am i saying.. lol ..


    personally ..... its my opinion that mulch NEVER impacts soil chemistry substantially .. again.. its part of the exponential function.. besides the fact. ... that its a top dressing ... etc ... and unless its been there.. and replenished for decades ... what could really happen.. in plant time ... possible for sure.. but not probable.. imo ...


    ken



  • 9 years ago

    For me, dwarf lady's mantle has been a much easier plant. It grows and blooms and seeds around.

    And definitely stop messing around with the soil. The end result is a mishmash of additives/amendments where it is impossible to tell what is going on without a serious, seriously expensive, soil test.

  • 9 years ago

    I agree with gardengal -- here in MA in my gardens, lady's mantle has happily seeded itself and doesn't mind being in full sun for half-plus days. I never water it unless in dire weather (hot & dry). One area has nearly constant moisture (near vernal swamp) and the other is by the driveway where soil is less promising and things fend for themselves. Lady's mantle is, as gardengal says, pretty much iron-cast. My soil here in New England is basically acidic and I have never tried to change it. I don't even mulch the lady's mantle.

    You might do better if you move it to a bit more sun, On the other hand, if it is a young (replacement) plant, give it time to bulk up. Good luck -- it's such a pretty plant!

  • 9 years ago

    I am beginning to wonder if this is one of those plants where enough digging would produce the phrase 'prefers acidic soil'. One result of these wonderings was finding a pH map of Europe. It certainly wasn't what I expected. Apparently most European soil has a pH under 5.5, with the major exceptions being the Adriatic coast of Italy, the Mediterranean coast of Spain, and the western part of the Mediterranean coast of France.

  • 9 years ago

    Plant looks normal other than being small. How old is it?

  • 9 years ago

    Emboth and peren, the LM is in it's second year there, it had maybe 7 leaves before transplant last year. Mad gallica, some of the UK is alkaline, but, it may just be near the Dover coast, but perhaps Floral can tell more? I know Kent is likely not too alkaline, it's considered a big gardening area in the UK. The native fern Harts tongue fern likes limestone rich soil, so it must be present in a few areas. Plus I think some of the Uk has a base of limestone from shelled sea critters. I added some vegetable fert already, so not really high on nitrogen, 9-12-12. Ken, I'm just going to leave it, or move it to the front of the bed. The bed does get about 2 hours of sun at the end of the day, maybe even 3. Gardengal, I am not surprised that it likes the PNW, it is kinda like the Uk full sun isn't the same as full sun in some places, and also the same as New England (roxanna), so me looking at the cultural requirements (Marie Tulin) isn't the same for it's native conditions if I plant it here in Pa. We've had many days in the 90'sF in my yard, and bright sun, real full sun, not PNW and UK full sun. And, BTW, Mary Tulin, I've been on GW for years, but, on the tree forum mostly until recently. I know basically what LM needs, the bed is well drained, and other than sun requirements, and full sun in the Uk may be partial sun in my yard, I was asking opinions of someone who is growing it. What conditions is your LM thriving (or not) in?

  • 9 years ago

    Poaky1, I am in zone 9 , northern California. I have been growing LM for years. While it does not exhibit the abundance of plants in the UK or up in PNW it does very well here in morning sun/aft shade or all day bright shade.Not suitable for full sun all day here. We get no rain from May til Oct or Nov so it needs to be watered weekly for me. Our PH is reliably neutral and I don't use fertilizer. Keeping it well watered is my biggest challenge.


    Kathy in Napa

  • 9 years ago

    I'm growing lady's mantle in zone 5 WI, full sun. Mine started out as a tiny plant about the size of yours. It is huge after about 4-5years. I have drip irrigation, so it gets plenty of water, but it's in hard clay soil and receives very little fertilizer. It's been a care free plant for me.

  • 9 years ago

    Back to the beginning: raised bed (fast draining, usually) potting soil (also fast draining, loses nutrients that have to be replaced (usually by water soluable fertilizers) when many people have reported theirs flourishing in ordinary garden soil. Take the plant out of the raised bed and plant it in the garden. Mine bleached out in harsh afternoon sun,but Delphinium's did fine. Assess the exposures you have and place accordingly.

  • 9 years ago

    Thank you all who have answered, I think I may move it to the front of the bed, or just purchase another LM and plant it in more sun. I just may wait until I know that the bed is right to plant the LM in.

  • 9 years ago

    I'd be amazed if it prefers acidic soil. Mine grows, as I said above, in stone paving which is laid on mortar. It is also happy growing out of limestone dry stone walls providing there is ample moisture.

  • 9 years ago

    DElphinium, I've heard that clay soil is usually great at holding onto nutrients, but, I'm sure not all clay soil is the same, and I thought it liked well drained soil, (the LM) dodgerettedude, mine gets a bit of morning sun too, and when the sun is overhead it isn't in dark shade, but, I do have a fern (deer fern) a bit back from it that is doing good too, so it is in a good bit of shade. I am likely going to leave it where it is, and just purchase another LM. I think I payed about $10.00 tops for mine. I have another area I can plant it in. I may have to move my Solomons seal plant, which is getting too big for the area anyway. And yes Floral, I am pretty sure it is okay and may even prefer alkaline or neutral soil. I know you can't always believe what is said about plants preferences, they are usually good, but, sometimes not as specific as needed. Thanks all.

Sponsored
Peabody Landscape Group
Average rating: 3.5 out of 5 stars8 Reviews
Franklin County's Reliable Landscape Design & Contracting