Help! I can't decide what shingle color to pick. I also need to pick a new stain for my deck that will compliment. We picked cedar hoping for a natural looking stain on our cedar wood deck the last time and it looks orange. I hate it. We have cream colored stucco in the back and cream brick w/ white shutters in the front. Cream colored garage door. That tiny dark brown wood piece on the left side of the stucco pic will need to be stained too. You'll notice the bottom of the deck is red. I'd wish for it to be stained the same color as the rest of the deck but I don't know that it would be possible to remove it. It may just need to be painted something a little more pleasant.

Any suggestions are appreciated. Thanking you in advance!