Software
Houzz Logo Print
northlandyogi_mi5a

A not so kid-friendly stylish couch-- keep or return?

13 years ago
I bought this highback tuffted linen loveseat for the entryway and have been thinking of putting wallpaper and light fixtures on the wall behind it. But I'm now having a little buyer's regret. I surely love the style, but I do have very small children(boys). I worry it would get easily stained and might not survive for a few months. Maybe spraying it with scotch guard will help? I'm really torn between returning it or keeping it. What would you do?

Comments (32)

  • PRO
    13 years ago
    It's totally glam and I say KEEP IT! Love the idea of lighting and wallcovering, maybe some window treatments for the window next to it. Scotch guard should help protect it from the kiddos! Great selection
  • 13 years ago
    Scotch guard it and then get a large king sized pillow case in the same color and tuck in to the back as a kiddie slip cover.....barely noticeable day by day and quickly hidden when visitors come to call! Kids will grow and get less messy and you'll still have a beautiful coach!
  • 13 years ago
    I agree with Studio M and skksk...KEEP IT! I just bought 2 sofas similar to yours in style and colour and we love it. Everyone kept on telling us we were brave to buy that colour as it will get ruined but we added large decorative pillows. Therefore, unless your kids are jumping on the chair with a large cup of chocolate milk - you'll be just fine! Enjoy your gorgeous loveseat!
  • 13 years ago
    I agree that a slipcover is a great way to go. You can change it easily (seasonally or at your whim) and whip it off when company comes. If you're handy with a sewing machine, most of the pattern companies have instructions for simple slipcovers. This looks like it might not fit into the standard purchased slipcover choices.
  • 13 years ago
    Keep it, spray it, and go find some darling outdoor fabric in a dark tone and take it to an upholsterer and have them make you a slipcover. You can keep the slip on most of the time, and take it off for company dinner nights.
  • 13 years ago
    vote keep it!
  • 13 years ago
    Scotch guard does not work. But I like your bold chice. Maybe leather would have been a better choice. Or black. With a silver and black metallic wallpaper behind it. Do it up glam.
  • 13 years ago
    last modified: 13 years ago
    If you are going to worry about it or stress over it, then take it back and get something more kid friendly for a few more years.

    It is really pretty though, so if you can make it work without yelling at the kids everytime they get within 4 foot of it, thn by all means keep it!
  • 13 years ago
    Add silver metallic satin panel to window pull to the side, ( away) from sofa. Hold back with some crystal beads. Paint walls a silver gray. paint trim incl door high gloss white.
  • 13 years ago
    This would have a lifetime of 20 minutes with small kids I know. YMMV.
  • 13 years ago
    last modified: 13 years ago
    I would return it. Looks like a very nice piece, but I think it is wrong for the space. Who will sit there? Kinda lonely. I prefer the old mirror/chest/lamp trio in an entry.
    Streeterville Residence · More Info
  • 13 years ago
    I say keep it! Actually I am looking for the same exact piece, where did you find it????
  • 13 years ago
    Thank you all very much for your super quick responses and wonderful comments! This is my very first time post on Houzz and didn't know what to expect. All of your comments help!

    After reading all your comments, this is what I'm going to do: spray it with scotchguard, find a fancy looking fabric to make a slipcover; a silver grey metalic wallpaper and crystcal accented light fixture; change the closet doors to white; and add metalic satin panel for the window. For our living room, I'll try to find some leather sofa that's similar style. After I'm done with the entryway, I'll surely post pictures!
  • 13 years ago
    To Masjoon1: I bought it in a local store, but you can google
    Vincent Beige Linen Modern Loveseat Bench". I noticed overstock has it and a matching chair.
    http://www.overstock.com/Home-Garden/Vincent-Beige-Linen-Modern-Loveseat-Bench/6758121/product.html?cid=202290&kid=9553000357392&track=pspla&ef_id=UWWxIwAAAER42BaH:20130515110912:s
  • 13 years ago
    To Masjoon1: The loveseat is stylish, but I'd like to warn you that the linen fabric is pretty thin and stain will really show.
  • 13 years ago
    Unless its something very interesting out that window, I bet the kids will never decide to sit there on their own. But I wonder what the sun will do to the fabric after a few months. What do you think about a small leather bench with no back, you could still add wallpaper and lighting and it may not look as cramped; they have the ones with the top that opens for storage for hats, gloves, shoes, etc.
  • PRO
    13 years ago
    Beautiful chair! But wrong for this spot. Keep it and put it in another room where you can enjoy it. It you have to slip cover the chair, it isn't woth keeping. If you do keep it, I highly recommend a professional treatment that will protect much better than what you can purchase retail. Professional designers specify draperies and upholstery to be treated all the time.

    For this space, you do need a small table or console as a landing spot for keys and mail. The wall paper is a great idea. Since it is a small space you can splurge on a higher end wallpaper reflective of your style.

    Have fun!
  • 13 years ago
    I agree with Teresa M.Morgan. Beautiful chair but wrong spot.And if you slip cover that chair that is not going to be the same chair anymore. It will become Ikea looking piece.
  • 13 years ago
    very pretty piece. nothing about it seems very welcoming or tempting to kids. slipcover is a good idea. i'd also just tell them it's not ot be touched. you could even run a piece of painters tape across the front as a reminder to stay off. it can instantly be pulled off when the doorbell rings.
  • 13 years ago
    If kids are going to sit on it while putting shoes on I envision a row of dirty scuff marks along the front. I have two boys and am holding off on dainty, light colored seating until they can be trusted not to ruin it.
  • 13 years ago
    Can I ask, why keep it if you're going to cover it?
  • 13 years ago
    Absolutely gorgeous! Keep it!
  • 13 years ago
    Bench with drawers in a medium or dark wood tone. Fancy wallpaper above where a seated adult would hit his head on the wall. You can put wood cubbies there if this is the main entrance for kids to come in. Put the lovely bench in the adults' room.
  • 13 years ago
    To Noelelain: Yes that's a question I'm asking myself too. So I orginaly was only thinking of using scotch guard, then begin to like many ppl's suggestion of slipcover too, especially if I can find a fancy nice pattern fabric to make the cover, and put it on and off while the kids are little. Then if the couch can survive a few years, I'll take down the cover.
  • 13 years ago
    Based on your and other's comments, you need to ask yourself: 1. Do you LOVE this piece? 2. Even with a slipcover, will it hold up (springs, etc) until the day you can use it uncovered 3. If you do love it, is there another place you can use it until the kids are older? 4. Do any of the suggestions for a bench with cubbies strike you as possibilities? 5. Does it really look good in that location or are you just too in love with it to consider the piece with a critical eye?
  • 13 years ago
    Even with a slipcover, if it gets used, abused and abandoned by your kids and their devilish little buddies over the next few years, it's going to look pretty knackered by the time it - and you - are ready to enjoy each other.

    I say return it, and get an Ikea Ektorp or similar (Craigslist!) that can get beaten up now and you won't cry over it. Then, when you're ready in a few years for a grown-up settee, there'll still be plenty available!

    I picked up a very good Ethan Allan settee freebie a year ago - the family had bought it, as you did, 10 years ago, thinking it would stand the test of time and children, and they could still enjoy it, but no, the fabric is wrecked. I plan to reupholster it, so no worries for me, but unless you're prepared to do that, I'd not be keeping it, myself.
  • 13 years ago
    Oh, yeah, and there's a reason they're called SLIP covers - unless it fits really tightly, with velcro, chances are it'll slip all over the place. And, the button back showing through can look pretty weird.....just my 10c!
  • 13 years ago
    I'm on a roll here - I'd get a carpenter friend to make a built-in banquette with a foam mattress-type pad. Lots of throw cushions, and you'll have a cosy reading nook with ample storage underneath.
  • 13 years ago
    What about a built-in tufted leather bench with similar lines? Even light colored leather will hold up much better than what you chose. You could have a lift-up top for storage and then have legs on the bottom or storage underneath. Attractive and sturdy baskets could be stowed underneath for gloves, shoes, etc.
  • 13 years ago
    oh just checked back in on this. i take back what i said after seeing you want it for kids putting on shoes etc.
    i'd go for a simple bench with a cushion. it doesn't have to be buit in. have trays underneath for shoes. pegs above for jackets and backpacks. style it for the active family you have rather than the magazine dream shot.
    chances are your tastes and style will have changed by the time the kids are old enough to leave the tufted piece uncovered.
    i don't have kids but my dogs and cats have ruined enough things to seriously influence my buying decisions.
  • PRO
    13 years ago
    Wayzata Home · More Info