Software
Houzz Logo Print
kguancione

Knotty alder for front door?

9 years ago

I am putting in double front entry doors in our new house. I am considering knotty alder over mahogany because I love the look. Just wondering if anyone here in the south with high humidity has put one in. Everyone here has mahogany and they hold up well, but I wanted something different. This is a picture of our neighbor's knotty alder door and I think it's beautiful!


Comments (12)

  • PRO
    9 years ago
    last modified: 9 years ago

    Will your doors be under a porch out of the weather?

    Alder is not a good outdoor wood, but if protected and maintained should be OK.

  • 9 years ago
    They will go under a porch roof but will have the late afternoon sun also. ☹️
  • 9 years ago
    last modified: 9 years ago

    they should be fine WITH a good UV spar urethane varnish. look into Man o War, or Epiphanes spar varnish. It has to have the UV qualities to it or the wood will be toast in a few years.

  • PRO
    9 years ago

    Make sure the doors you choose are up to local code, please.

  • 9 years ago

    Wood exposed to sunlight will turn gray if not treated as Beth advised. The problem with spar varnishes is they only protect for a relatively short time(1-2 years) before needing maintenance.

    I included a link to a boating site which is testing many kinds/types of outdoor wood protection products. That info will apply to wood doors/patio furniture/etc.


    Wood finishes

  • 9 years ago

    That's an attractive door, but I agree with the concerns about weather. I have a lovely wooden front door now, and we have problems with it "swelling" slightly at times. I miss my metal front door from my old house.

  • PRO
    9 years ago

    "... Everyone here has mahogany and they hold up well, but I wanted something different..."

    Sometimes there's a good reason why everyone does something! Actually, a exterior finish painted wood door might hold up longer and perform better than a stained natural wood finish, even a marine finish. Just a thought!

  • 9 years ago

    painted doors protect just like a marine varnish would protect. if you want to paint, then obviously don't waste money on the alder wood.

    and it's true, the spar varnish does need reapplying. (although since yours will get no water, just the sun, it may go a bit longer). initially you would do 2-3 coats and then one coat every 1-2 years for upkeep. not a big deal.

    Even paint needs to be redone after a few years. Nothing lasts forever!

  • 9 years ago
    We have a mahogany door now. It has only been re-varnished once in the 9 years we've owned this house but it's on a covered porch and gets no sun. I was hoping to get a new look in the new house. Oh well....
  • 9 years ago

    We had a mahogany door on our old house in NC. It was under a covered porch. It faced east and the sun did a number on it. The sun would come in under the porch so half the door took a beating. We would reapply spar urethane every year but it eventually got to the point where we had to pay someone to come and strip the entire door, sidelights and transom and restain. It wasn't cheap. We are going with fiberglass door on our new house.

  • 9 years ago

    vinmarks, there are spar urethanes w/no UV properties. It sounds like that's what you used. If the spar does not say, "blocks UV rays", then it doesn't have it. That's why I mentioned Epiphanes or Cetol Marine or even Penofin marine. they all have the UV blockers.

    Karen Guancione thanked Beth H. :