Software
Houzz Logo Print
hzdeleted_35019729

Dunkirk, the film

9 years ago
last modified: 9 years ago

I'll try not to include spoilers! First, I've heard the criticisms: the characters aren't well-rounded, there are no people of color (ridiculous, there WERE nto peple of color at Dunkirk), at least one of the Spitfires is the wrong model for 1940, and so on. But these are minor cavils in the face of the film's story and Christopher Nolan's presentation

I'm old enough to have heard the Dunkirk story many times in my childhood and I was eager to see this film by Nolan with a soundtrack by Hans Zimmer and "starring" Kenneth Branagh, James D'Arcy, Mark Rylance, and a phalanx of young, relatively unknown British actors, especially Fionn Whiehead, whose name we learn is "Tommy" (how BRitish is that!) but to whom I refer as "he who will not be killed."

The film intertwines three stories: 1. The Mole (which is the pier from men embark) that recounts one week; 2. The Sea, which recounts one day; and 3. The Sky, which recounts one hour. Nolan shows these scenes sometimes more than once from different perspectives, as what a crash looks like from the sea and agaian as it looks like from a fellow pilot. One cannot take one's eyes off the screen for even a moment. I've seen the film twice and the second time around I picked up details I'd missed the frist time.

There's little dialogue--the script was probalby ten pages long--because the film is about the desparate struggle to get HOME in the face of terrible odds--continual attack, death, fire, pettiness, despair, hope. The film is not a hero story, though there are moments in individual heroism (oh Tom Hardy, you could have turned that plane around). These men are just ordinary soldiers in a tough situation, and simply trying to stay alive, get off that beach, and get HOME.

Tommy is at the center of the film as the young solider whose nearly every effort gets off the beach is thwarted. If he gets on a ship, it sinks or gets blown up, or he can't get on it at all. He represents in his person the nearly monumental task it was to get 300,000 off the Dunkrk beach.

I was most taken with Mark Rylance, who captained one of the small private boats that headed to Dunkrk to bring men back. Rylance is as good as he usually is. Talk about steady.

Lynn Wheeler already said thet neither her partner nor friends want to see this film, but I highly recommend it. Yes, it's loud and lots of men die, but that's the actual history of the story.and it can't be anything else. Nolan is no Spielerg, whose sentimentalization of war in Saving Private Ryan, literally angered me, Nolan tells it straight.

I'm going to England for a three week vacation at the end of August and this film will be in my mind.

Dunkirk trailer

Comments (22)

  • 9 years ago
    last modified: 9 years ago

    Thanks for that clarification, Lynn. I really did not know about the Indian soldiers who were present at Dunkirk. If you are ever able to visit the Museum of the American Revolution in Philadelphiia--and maybe you already know this--it's made clear the contirbutions of African Americans and native Americans to the revolution, a fact that is not often mentioned in the history books.

    At the same time, Nolan does show the biases of some soldiers. When Tommy shows up on the beach and joins a line of grenadiers waitng for evacuation, he's sent away because he's not a grenadier. He has no line to join and has to improvise but I thought that the point Nolan makes is that just because all soldiers are trying to get off that beach, old prejudices die hard. There are other instances of exclusion in the film that echo the scene I mentioned.

    ETA that there are "hidden figures' everywhere we look, including the story of Dunkirk.

  • 9 years ago
    last modified: 9 years ago

    Your last few sentences bring me back to The Pianist. Heroic survival and interesting German officer's help - Werner was singled out as especially talented. He's rescued more than once (can't remember how many times) and it seems that his talent gave him status with the Nazi's. In contrast to those "others" whose talents weren't known.

    I'm watching an HBO film "Into The Storm" about Churchill. The beginning focuses on Dunkirk. I always get emotional watching depictions of those allied soldiers getting rescued by ordinary people showing courage.

  • 9 years ago

    I just rewatched "Allied". Very frustrated at the inaccuracies. Brad Pitt's character would never have been told to kill his wife! She was needed alive for her information.

    This is why much of what Hollywood puts out doesn't interest me. If it's a historical film, I don't like that something false is inserted for the sake of drama. Wrecks the entire film imho.

  • 9 years ago

    pure, I didn't see Allied so I can't comment on what you found lacking in the film. I can only say that whenever I see a film that is "based on" a true story, it will never be absolutely factual in every single frame of the film. My brother, who is an historian, loves Revenant, a film I thought was good but did not love. He points out the historical inaccuracies that the film depicts, but also says that the film captures what, to him, is the mood and tenor of the time and he has rewatched it several times. It's always the "based on" that I know means that the film will be close to but never identical to what actually happened.

    However, Dunkirk, while partly done in tandem with Hollywood, is essentially a British film telling a British story. Clearly there are some inaccuracies, as Lynn makes clear, but I did not feel for a moment that I was being "hoodwinked" in any way. The film is not a victory story, it is a survival story and a tale that fulfills the basic story of Dunkirk.

    I saw a film today, Wind River, that announces itself as being "partly a true story." I know it's not identical to any actual event, but in making the case that while there are all kinds of statistics regarding the deaths of various ethnic groups, it is literally true that stateistics for the disappearance( deaths? rapes?) of Native American women are recorded NOWHERE, it certainly rang true to me.

  • 9 years ago

    DANG! I watched the wrong movie. I watched Operation Dunkirk. I don't recommend it. Allied soldiers finding and bringing a scientist out of Germany while the Dunkirk evac is going on. Too many long, slow, chase scenes. Take those out and the movie would be 30 minutes.

  • 9 years ago
    last modified: 9 years ago

    Oh my Pidge! That was tremendous. I was horrified when I realized what was about to happen in the worst part, even knowing the ending, was thrilled at the best part. War is he-l! So, so, so well done. I never give a ten when son and I talk after a movie. It's a ten. Did the whole deal, 70mm IMAX. Well worth every penny. Thank you for "convincing"me.

  • 9 years ago
    last modified: 9 years ago

    Pidge, do you agree with this part? Taken from Qnetwork.com review:

    • "And that’s where Dunkirk stumbles, albeit in a clearly intentional way. Nolan is so intent on ensuring that we experience what the characters are experiencing that he jettisons any need to make them actual characters beyond the barest of necessity. That is a crucial risk on his part, and to some extent I can’t help but be impressed by his willingness to forego something so elemental to the big-budget movie experience as character, which further proves his experimental bona fides and willingness to risk his stature as one of Hollywood’s leading
      filmmakers to follow his artistic instincts..."

    I'm not sure it needed "developed characters". We have our guide and experience what many felt. Does it need to be humanized to get the point across? I also think it might do all who suffered a disservice. It could be they went too far in detracting from the troops. Maybe. it was a story of hundreds of thousands, not individuals. Nor was it an individual victory. Or one distinct thing to mourn. I was really taken back by what happens to the lone hero at the end, floored (I gasped and grabbed son's arm). What he represents, you know many suffered. I'd put it out of my mind until the flare went off. In the midst of such a story of hope, it felt out of place, but it needed to be acknowledged; that those things did happen. That's just my take on it.

  • 9 years ago

    Good comment, rob. I was quite impressed with Nolan's refusal to create "round" characters and that Tommy was quite well-enough developed to make us follow him. We don't need to know who his mother is, or in what town or village he lived, whether he had a girlfriend or siblings, etc. All we needed to know was that the struggle he went through was one that was not only his, but also that of so many others. I thought that was entirely "humanizing." What Nolan does not want to risk is the kind of sentimentalism that marks some war films, like Saving Private Ryan. I'm not sure if I think the film was a story of hope as it was of the difficulty of survival--a lot of people died in the film, some in horrific ways and survival was not at all assured.

  • 9 years ago

    It'll be a while before I get to a theater to see Dunkirk, but I'm looking forward to it. Regarding character development: that's often the hook that draws me in to a story. I crave knowing more about the people and the back story. In this case, it seems very appropriate that one character somehow carries each soldiers' story. The action would be more than enough for plot. Are the characters also the sea, the weather, the extreme time urgency?

    I rewatched MBTS with an eye toward understanding rather than appreciating. One strong take-away was how good the sound track was. Evocative, it matched what was happening and heightened the drama. The cinematography was great. Cutaways, flashbacks, vistas of the sea and the New England homes were beautiful.

    I think my dislike for the strong silent type male prejudiced me against the main character and also his nephew. The chaos - bar fights, yelling matches - are of a family in crisis. But the brooding and close to being at a flash point throughout much of the film a was distraction/irritation for me. Although what they depicted was honest and easily believed. The one scene with Michelle Williams was too awkward. She could have shown us a strong woman who has carried on her life in spite of horrific tragedy - but she simpered and begged.

    Anyway, that's my very uneducated take. I did have a college course in Film, but I don't think I absorbed much. :))

  • 9 years ago

    TThe one scene with Michelle Williams was too awkward. She could have shown us a strong woman who has carried on her life in spite of horrific tragedy - but she simpered and begged.

    Wow,, how differently each viewer sees a scene. I thought the issue was that she never really got over loving Lee despite the heartbreak of the fire. A much earlier scene, where she is in bed sick, illustrated her love of him despite his failings. She remarried and had another baby in a vain attempt to recapture something she had lost, but it didn'r work. I'd never describe her as simpering but she certainly was begging. He's the one who knows that there is no returning even though the love between them just can't do the trick..

    Anyway, we can't write a film script to fulfill our agenda, so what she "could" have done is a moot point. Your response to her illustrates how much so many of us, including me, want a story to suit us instead of itself.

    I also thought that Lee was not a "strong silent male type." I think his suffering was so palpable that he had to leave town to even survive. The nephew was also suffering--the scene where he takes a package of frozen chicken out of the freezer and weeps because his father's dead body had to be put in a freezer until the ground was warm enough to dig a grave--that was tough.

    As for the fight scenes--Lee is an alcoholic in despair. He is not pretty in these scenes but they do reveal the near impossiblity he has in controlling his life.

    Thanks for taking the time to discuss this amazing film. I think you are right on about the sound track and the cinematography. You are anything but uneducated,pure.

  • 9 years ago
    last modified: 9 years ago

    Pure, now you're seeing why we were talking films in Hot Topics? We used to talk all the time. Pidge has the best takes and reviews...

  • 9 years ago

    Pure, the fire and the death of the children WAS the core of this film. There was a distinct sense of before and after that did not make sense until that scene was revealed well into the film. Then everything just snapped into place for me--why he had moved, why he didn't want to "father" his nephew (though he ended up doing exactly that. He's a deeply flawed man who is also capable of great love.

    A couple of people told me they thought the film was "just so sad." I thought it was "just so REAL."

    I really loved this film.

  • 9 years ago

    I thought the ending was satisfying. Pragmatic resolution for the nephew and the extra room where he hopefully will visit.

    I was confused when I watched the first time about how the fire fit into the plot. Not that much screen time was devoted to the before - happy and married with three children. I still don't remember learning that he was an alcoholic. I think that's why my impression was more than he was the silent dark type - when clearly he was very happy before the fire.

    I did really like the sound track and the cinematography. Thanks for clarifying!


  • 9 years ago

    Yes, he was very happy before the fire, but the first time we see him with his family is where he comes back from a day on the sea and recounts the astonishing numbers of beers he'd consumed during the day. And then the party before the fire when he was with his pals drinking and taking drugs, and his wife telling him to throw them out. And after they left he went out for more booze. I know there are lots of times when he's not drunk, and maybe it's just my definition of alcoholism.But to me he is a man for whom alcohol is poison.

    When he says at the end, to his nephew, "I just can't beat it" or words to that effect, my first thought was that he meant alcohol but I think it had a wider meaning. He just can't beat the memories of the havoc he caused either.

    Pure, I can't tell you how much I've liked this conversation about this movie. Please post about any movie you've seen and if I've seen it, let's talk about it.

  • 9 years ago

    Thank you Pidge!

    User thanked User
  • 9 years ago

    I'm watching the old 'Dunkirk' for the history. John Mills, Richard Attenborough.

  • 9 years ago

    A film I have not seen. Is it on Netflix?

  • 9 years ago

    It's on Amazon. I discontinued Netflix. Do you find movies you like there?

  • 9 years ago

    I like Netflix as much for TV series as movies, though I did rewatch Hot Fuzz the othernight with Simon Pegg. Still hilarious.

    I'll check Amazon fot the older dunkirk film.

  • 9 years ago

    I learned some interesting things from that film. About haw haw (?) the American propagandist who pushed the idea of a "phoney war". which may have led England to be less prepared for the nazi's. That Hitler did not give the okay for a full assault on Dunkirk, possibly believing the English had learned their lesson and wouldn't keep on fighting.

    Much of the footage was from newsreels. My strong impression was of how these men kept going even as they were being bombed on the beach, the rescue boats were being bombed; how the allied forces had only a month previous pushed the line into Belgium. It's very sad and also inspiring. The "little boats" that rescued soldiers because the Dunkirk beach was shallow and naval ships couldn't get in close enough.


  • 9 years ago

    I have read a lot of this information over time and much of it--not all--is included in the newer film which, as you say of the earlier film, is hearbeaking but also tertimony to the push for survival.

0
Sponsored
Peabody Landscape Group
Average rating: 3.5 out of 5 stars8 Reviews
Franklin County's Reliable Landscape Design & Contracting