Software
Houzz Logo Print
leahdawnmarie

Quartz Grading

9 years ago
last modified: 9 years ago

Does anyone know how the grading works with quartz? Or more specifically, does anyone have any experience with Fir Stone?

We bought a new build and were promised "mid-grade" quartz in the contract, but after only 6 months of living in the home we are experiencing chipping. The three other homes that were built by the same contractor also have chips in their counters. They were purchased from Fir Stone but Fir Stone does not provide any product information on their website and they have not replied to my email asking them to provide details about the product.

Is there a universal grading system on quartz to know whether we got an inferior product to what we were promised or can they pretty much classify anything they want to as mid grade?

thanks in advance for any responses!

Comments (10)

  • PRO
    9 years ago

    I've never heard of a "mid grade quartz". Cambria charges a premium for its latest designs, but it's all the same stuff technically. Chipping is usually due to edge profile selection, not quartz quality.

    Leah thanked Joseph Corlett, LLC
  • 9 years ago

    The chips are not on the edge though...they are on the surface of the counter.

    From what I can tell, I'm 95% sure it is Chinese quartz. From what I understand, they do not use the same process as the other well known brands. Would the quality still be comparable?

  • 9 years ago

    Who can know? But it doesn't seem like it once again.

  • 9 years ago

    If it's only 6 months than your home should still be under warranty and it is up to the builder to make it right. If that means replacing the quartz with something not made by the Chinese, that's his problem

    Leah thanked cpartist
  • 9 years ago

    Unfortunately we've had a number of issues that the builders are reluctant to rectify. Part of the reason I'm asking is because it looks like we're going to have to resort to other measures to get things taken care of so that's why I'm curious about what it means by "standard mid-grade" in the contract and whether we have any recourse in that they installed an inferior product than what was promised.

  • 9 years ago

    I suspect that "standard mid-grade" refers to just the counters in general - not specifically the quartz.

    Leah thanked Chessie
  • 9 years ago

    Probably refers to the pricing structure. Not the quality level. Except he likely sold you the cheapest thing he could get his hands on rather than a medium priced product.

    Leah thanked User
  • 9 years ago

    The contract did specify standard mid-grade quartz, not standard mid-grade counters.

    If there's no real difference in quality when it comes to various makes of quartz, is it simply normal for them to chip then?

  • PRO
    9 years ago

    There is no grading system for quartz. Most companies follow a patented technology called Bretonstone yet they can add their own finesse and nuances to the final product. Of course once something becomes very successful, all sorts of knock offs arise trying to make a buck... sometimes they are a good company sometimes not so much. They will "copy" the popular colors of the big name brands and sell at a reduced price.... I always feel there is some compromise to that...I have never heard of Fir Stone and you really can't find anything online. Your recourse is only going to be through your builder.

    Now tops can chip - whether quartz or granite - sometimes it happens in the middle of the top but more often it is around the edges. You can usually call the fabricator and have them come out and repair these.

    I am sure your builder called it a mid range or standard quartz because there are different price groups with the brands and they also price out differently from one to the other - I have seen quartz pricing run from $75 sq ft to $130....

    I do hope you can get a result you will be happy with... Good luck!