Software
Houzz Logo Print
chaparralgirl

Compost Tea, or Swamp Water...?

9 years ago
last modified: 9 years ago

My husband and I have, for the past 2 years, kept a large Rubbermaid bin just outside our back door, and when we had kitchen scraps or yard clippings, we would dump them in the bin. There was no lid, and no holes drilled anywhere to allow for airflow or drainage. As you can imagine, when it rained, the bin took on water. It's been 2 years, as I've stated, and the bin was positively bulging with decomposing/decomposed material sitting in black-colored water. We finally decided it was time to empty it. (This wasn't any method of composting we'd read/learned about, it was just somewhere to put the scraps instead of in the garbage. A half-hearted attempt at reducing our impact on the landfill, I guess.)


We have an actual commercially-made compost bin down in the yard (the cone-shaped kind), which is where we should've been dumping our scraps and clippings. (Dumping the kitchen scraps in the Rubbermaid bin was always way easier than walking down into the yard, especially when it was raining or if it was winter.) We pulled the Rubbermaid bin out from its corner and started shoveling material into a wheelbarrow to haul it down to the composter; that's when we actually discovered just how much water was in that thing. As I mentioned, the water was black; it also had a slight smell, although nothing overpowering (I was expecting it to be awful, but it really was only slight). The material on top was undecomposed, the material halfway down was partially decomposed, and the material down at the bottom of this mess was fully decomposed, like black sludge. We ended up using several buckets to drain as much of the water off as possible so we could get to the solid material. Needless to say, we ended up making a bit of a mess. In the end, we got most of the solid material down to (and into) the actual compost bin in the yard, and the rest of it I spread over a fallow portion of my garden bed (which I then tilled into the soil and will let sit until next spring). Some of the water I used to water some of my plants (rather hoping that it won't kill them, but hey, it's fall anyway, they're going to die soon once the cold weather sets in); the excess water my husband dumped out on the lawn (which has been mostly baked anyway).


My question is this: would that black water actually be beneficial to my plants, or harmful? I've read a few threads on compost tea vs. leachate, and aerobic vs. anaerobic decomposition, and I think I'm starting to get a better understanding of what is what, but I wanted to get some opinions. If I understand things correctly, the black-colored water displaced oxygen in much of the material, leading to anaerobic decomposition (and thus the slight smell), which produces certain chemicals that are known to be harmful to plants. I guess where I'm unsure is that some of the material actually had live earthworms in it, and I would've thought the water would've drowned them. (As an aside, I didn't deliberately put the earthworms in there, they must've been stowaways when I dumped dead potted plants into the bin.) Which makes me think that there was, in fact, aerobic decomposition going on; which makes me wonder if the black-colored water could be considered something like compost tea...?


Anyway, all is said and done already - the Rubbermaid bin is empty, and my husband doesn't want to use it anymore (primarily because emptying it was a real pain in the butt); the solid material has been transferred to the actual compost bin; and the black-colored water has been used up (if the plants I watered with it die, that's my bad). I just wanted to get some thoughts.

Comments (3)

Sponsored
Custom Home Works
Average rating: 4.6 out of 5 stars10 Reviews
Franklin County's Award-Winning Design, Build and Remodeling Expert