Software
Houzz Logo Print
mjammjam

Bishop Kitchen Cabinets???

9 years ago

I originally planned a large kitchen reno with Omega cabinets. My new kitchen designer told me to use her local cabinet maker with great reputation, whose prices came in over 12K cheaper. So, my original cabinet maker said he'd match the price, but with Bishop brand cabinets. He said Blum hinge, blum side, 3/4" box plywood and solid wood dovetail drawer. He also said that the inset Bishop would be 3K more if I wanted to go that route. He also said that the St. Martin Cabinetry would also work for the same price but that the door style and color is limited. YAY or NAY to Bishop????




Comments (12)

  • PRO
    9 years ago

    Omega has been making good quality cabinets for decades. 12K is a big difference. I find it hard to believe that the quality is the same. You should also be aware that there has been a huge influx of RTA cabinetry flooding the market in recent years. Mostly from China. The dealers and distributors are often disguising the origins of these cabinets with American sounding names and clever word game. For instance they say locally made when they really mean assemble'd out of a crate from China by a low wage worker not a true cabinet maker.

    Even if the cabinets for 12K less are truly "Made In America" there will in my opinion be significant quality differences or you will be forced to make some other compromises.

  • 9 years ago
    last modified: 9 years ago

    I never heard of them, so I did a search. Don't know if you've seen [this thread[(https://www.houzz.com/discussions/jim-bishop-cabinets-looking-for-feedback-dsvw-vd~2702985)?

    I've read good things about Omega.

  • 9 years ago

    I've never heard of Bishop or Omega, but my experience with cabinets has been, you get what you pay for.

  • 9 years ago
    last modified: 9 years ago

    why don't you see what his cabinets actually look like? does he have any samples in his shop? and prior customers you could speak with or look at theirs? I don't understand if he's a cabinet maker but he's using Bishop?? you mean he's going to make them just like Bishop or he's buying Bishop?

  • 9 years ago
    Thanks all — my original guy is getting me a sample of the cabinet so I can see it. Honestly, I’m sure it’ll look the same to me as all of them. I just thought some designers here would know how the quality would be different in a way that I could see. The local guy has a huge factory that I’ve gone into. But I don’t have the knowledge to know what I’m looking for. I’m overwhelmed with projects in this new house. We are working on every room so I hired a designer to help me. She said she’s used the local guy for years without a problem. But she didn’t even seem to know where I would get inset cabinets if I wanted them.
  • 9 years ago

    Thank you DDS -- I'll ask him about those

  • 9 years ago
    last modified: 9 years ago

    Huge difference in quality between Omega and Bishop. You’re talking a nice entry level Mercedes vs a Fiat. There’s no way in hades that I’d ever choose Bishop over Omega. Or anything else mentioned either. The quality is vastly different. Omega is worth well more than 15K over cheepchinesecrapola. There is so much garbage in the market right now that it’s not funny. American made quality still exists, for now, if only people will just say no to import crapola. Omega is made in Iowa.

  • PRO
    9 years ago
    I've installed a few kitchens with Omega cabinets. The level of customer support has been great with Omega. Part of what is being paid for is support after the sale and long lasting quality.
  • 9 years ago

    And if you want to cut costs, ditch those curved muntin doors. Thats 4-5K of the price right there.

    But you are planning a LARGE upscale kitchen. It will have a large upscale price to go with it. At the level you are, that 15K should be maybe 12-15% of the overall project costs. Not inconsiderable, but not where you cut costs if you need to cut costs. Downgrade the appliances some. Choose a cheaper counter. A plainer cheaper backsplash. Bargain hunt lights. But your cabinets will be there for the next 30-40 years if you choose properly. If you don’t, then they won’t last until your refrigerator goes.

  • 9 years ago
    Thanks again — Sophie: house about Fieldstone inset cabinets. Those he just quoted me are about 10K more than my local guy who’s making the frameless.
  • 9 years ago

    Looks like we're going with Fieldstone Inset and not Bishop. They're more expensive, but I'm starting to like inset better and The name Fieldstone has better reviews. Thanks, guys!