Software
Houzz Logo Print
theodonnells

What to do with this fireplace

9 years ago
last modified: 9 years ago



This is my living room. I HATE the fireplace! Wanted to do a chalk paint finish on mantel. I would love to do Black with cream and gold tones to pick up the over head light in center of room but afraid it will be too dark and then what color to paint tile. Other option is chalk it in parchment and add in blacks, golds, and browns. Either way I am going to paint the tile. Would love suggestions on mantel and what color to paint tile. I have a very talented faux painter that can do anything. Sorry for the glare from light. Thanks

Here a better picture

Comments (11)

  • 9 years ago

    Your idea is not unheard of, but I'd go all black - a classic look - if you're certain you want to paint the FP. I'd replace the tile rather than paint it. Then you'd be able to hang that huge round mirror above it for a striking look. I think you've pointed out one of the main issues with your space; the overhead light. Ambient light (ceiling fixtures) are to help you see to get into the room in the dark without falling over something. Then you dim them down and turn on the task (table and floor lamps) and accent (art, uplights, piano lights,) to add personality to your room. TV above and clutter on the mantel (and all the flat surfaces in your room) is a major problem The space seems to have good bones and lots of natural light, but it is completely cluttered and over stuffed. With the big mirror over the mantle, move the chair so you can put a credenza and your TV there. Set the TV on a swivel base so it can be adjusted when there is glare from the windows. Move the chair so its occupant can enjoy TV, and put the small black chair over in the window. As for the abundance of framed photos, Houzzers usually advise they be relegated to more private spaces like hallways, bedrooms and dens or family rooms. A trio of one large pic standing behind two smaller pix can work layered on a table top or shelf, but not on every surface. Lots of potential here if you'll let us help you update the entire space to be smashing!


  • 9 years ago

    Unfortunately I have no place else to put that green chair. Its a strange room. I had the tv next to fireplace but the mantel is so tall it looked completely unbalanced. I need a tv in this room. Yes that mirror did hang over the fireplace in my old house. In this space it reflects on a window on opposite side of room with trees. Chandelier is on a dimmer already. Not as much natural light as you think. Northern exposure with a huge pine tree in the way. I like the cluttered look. All the stuff I love. I think painting this fireplace will bring things together or help me to make decisions about what to purge. Dont want to go to expense of retiling. Just not sure what color to paint tile. My painter can make it look like marble in any color or paint it solid. I like those old vintage mantels with character. Thanks for suggestions.

  • 9 years ago

    Instead of black, consider a very, very dark brown, with a lighter, rather smudgy marble effect on the tiles -- I think that kind of marble has a particularly Victorian look, which what your style suggests.

    In carrying that style off I do think you need to pay more attention to the shapes and positioning of your beloved clutter. For instance, I think you might move the picture on the left of the fireplace to join the group on the right, which could as a whole be moved to the right, just to allow a smidgeon of breathing space. Then put a second topiary tree on the mantelpiece on the left. The symmetry will help make it look more cohesive.


    http://www.galleriaofstone.net/category/natural-stone/marble/

    A great example of over-the-top Victoriana illustrates what I mean, I think.


  • 9 years ago

    I'm always second guessing myself -- I think I should have used a dark brown and toning marble with more red in it. The one I used is reading too dull for the floor. For technical reasons I can't do a quick colour change and I'm supposed to be working. But this is more fun.

  • 9 years ago

    I think 2nd pic is so interesting. I would love to sit and have a glass of wine in that room and just look around. I downsized and this is what I have left. Trying more eclectic. I usually just buy what I like and its fine. As far as nick nacks nothing is permanent. Just there till I finish. Like jewelry it is the finishing touch. Thats easy to fix. Thanks


  • 9 years ago

    Isn't it a stunner? The Victorians were great collectors of stuff.

  • 9 years ago

    Maybe a gold glaze over the white fireplace surround and paint the tile and hearth onyx.

  • 9 years ago

    Don’t you think that will be a big black hole. I want mantle to look vintage. Just can’t decide black or brown. If mantle dark, tile light or vice versa but in this room I think mantle should be the more focal point

  • 9 years ago
    last modified: 9 years ago

    Match mantel color to your mirror and use it over the mantel. It will reflect a view, which is a good thing. Clutter is fine; just pick a style and stick to it.

    Refined clutter

    Eclectic clutter

    Contemporary clutter

    Seasonal clutter

    Purposeful clutter

    theodonnells thanked decoenthusiaste
  • 9 years ago

    I've just invented a word. Let's here it for the clutterati!