Software
Houzz Logo Print
adinkins

Honed vs polished

13 years ago
Does a honed vs polished marble provide more protection?
Classical Kitchen · More Info

Comments (5)

  • PRO
    13 years ago
    Nope. There's no difference practically. It's an aesthetic choice.
  • 13 years ago
    Thank you! Is there any aesthetic issue with mixing stones? Granite perimeter and a marble island?
  • PRO
    13 years ago
    Not at all. I've seen that look done plenty, and it's dynamite. We've mixed leathered/ honed granite with a white granite:
    Leathered Antique Brown Granite and River Valley Granite in Vienna, VA · More Info


    And polished black granite with a white granite:
    Two Tone Kitchen: Antique Brown Granite & Millennium Cream Granite · More Info


    We've even mixed soapstone with a White Carrara Marble:
    Soapstone Counters with White Carrara Marble Full Backsplash · More Info


    And we've got two projects in the work that pair a black granite with a White Macaubas Quartzite (a natural stone that looks very similar to marble)

    And houzz is just covered with pictures of granite perimeter and marble islands
    Kitchen · More Info

    Princeton Restoration · More Info

    Lincoln Park Residence · More Info

    Westlake Residence · More Info
  • PRO
    13 years ago
    It is not a question of protection as much as it is one of ease of maintenance.

    Marble is a calcium based stone and will etch when exposed to acids. Remember in chemistry class when you added vinegar to the bicarb and had the "volcano" happen? Same thing happens when any acid hits a marble. The calcium reacts with the acid and dissolves. That is the cause of the "water rings" that people see when looking at a piece of polished marble in the reflection of the light.

    These are not stains, but rather areas where the top layer of the marble got "eaten off" by the acid. Unfortunately there is no sealer that will stop the etching from happening.

    The honed finish - while not preventing the damage, hides it way better than a polished surface would, making maintenance of your marble tops easier. Besides - honed marble is softer looking and visually more pleasing, in my opinion!
  • 12 years ago
    What is are the dimensions of the island top?