Software
Houzz Logo Print
julie_anne_co

Gnats! Help!

8 years ago

I must have bought a plant that brought in gnats (perhaps fungus gnats). I have tried it all. Neem oil, an anti gnat concentrate that I've been watering with for months, yellow sticky traps, diatomaceous earth covering the entire surface of my plants... I'm well over $100 in effort. Though I must say these worked to about 90%. I was able to rid of most of them by re-potting the majorly infected plants and trashing the infected soil. But I still have them flying out of my plants. The main problem is having them flying around my house. They buzz in my ear at night and sometimes land on my plate. I can't handle it. I have about 30 plants in my small apartment. What do I do?? Is this just part of having a huge plant collection? Should I just keep at all of these methods and eventually it will solve it. It's been about 2 months now and I've been steady at remediation.

Comments (10)

  • 8 years ago

    Fungus gnats love wet and organic conditions. Is there a possibility that you are keeping your plants too wet? Or is there any standing water - like excess water in saucers? Do you pick up any fallen leaves and other plant debris? What kind of 'potting' medium do you use? Is it hot & humid where they are kept? Is there good air circulation?

  • 8 years ago

    Thanks for quick response. I'm in Colorado so it's super dry. I don't have standing water anywhere and I'm crazy about keeping the leaves clean. Perhaps I'm keeping them too wet and should wait a couple of weeks before watering again. Most of my plants get really unhappy if I don't water once a week. I think they dry out faster in this climate. I also keep the fan going at all times and open the door when it's nice out. May not have the best circulation other than that.

  • 8 years ago

    What's crazy is that they even made a home in one of my large cacti, which gets water maybe once a month!

  • 8 years ago

    All winter I use mosquito dunks in my watering can. When it crumbles away I add another quarter of a dunk, the circular kind. No fungus gnats.

  • 8 years ago
    last modified: 8 years ago

    Julie_anne

    Even if you water them seldom, very peaty soil could be staying wet. I don't know which plants you have, and what kind of soil you use, and many tropical need more frequent watering. How do you check if they need to be watered or not?

    Try checking deep in the container few days after watering. Use a bamboo skewer or chopstick, or sharpened wood dowel. Even pencil will do. Stick it at least 3/4 deep, trying to avoid roots. Leave for few minutes, then pull out. If it is dry and clean, plant may need watering soon. If it comes out damp/cold feeling when you touch top of your hand or a cheek, and may even have some particles sticking to it, there is still lots of moisture there.

    Soil is most often the culprit. It should be very well draining, made of few different ingredients. Many bagged soils are not very well draining. Adding coarse perlite or pumice and small bark may help. Make sure there are drainage holes in all containers.

    Any succulents (cacti are succulents too) need very good drainage. Many of succulent growers use gritty mix, containing very small amount of small bark and lots of inorganic substraes. Sometimes, these ingredients may not be easily found and ppl use 50/50 mix of Cactus & Succulent soil (or more of perlite; one can use pumice instead if available) and report good results.

    It isn't recommended to fight fungus gnats with many different chemicals, as some will not even work. Flies themselves do not live very long (just long enough to lay hundreds of eggs and annoy ppl! :) Their larvae, that is in the soil, needs to be destroyed and treatment repeated about every 5 days or so to eliminate future generations.

    Here - pls. click me is excellent thread explaining how water behaves in container soils. Maybe you'll be interested to read it.

    julie_anne_co thanked rina_Ontario,Canada 5a
  • 8 years ago

    They could be in your drains. Fungus gnats will breed in sink and shower drains. Try closing the drains until you need them. Then, when you open up the drain, do any gnats fly out?

    julie_anne_co thanked Lily Roberts
  • 8 years ago

    Thanks all. I will try these new things. Sounds like I might be over-watering and not creating enough drainage.

  • 8 years ago

    Using Mosquito dunks works very well. But in long run, make sure you water when needed and provide good drainage, because they will just appear again if they find what they like.

  • 8 years ago

    I have had problems with gnats and when I changed my plant's soil to faster draining it really helped. I still water with water that has the Mosquito bits or dunks in it every so often I had read that some city water can be treated with stuff that can "kill" or somehow change the active BT in the products. So I usually buy cheap distilled water (a gallon is 89 cents) for this. I also read that watering with dilute hydrogen peroxide can kill some of the nematodes. I did this when I had a bad infestation and it seemed to help. But I would say the best thing I did was get my plants into fast draining soil. Good luck, they are very frustrating.