Software
Houzz Logo Print
saltdesert

More ID please!

8 years ago

Aloha again!

im the rookie here and forgot to post my zone which is 10...I think? I'm from Oahu, HI.

I need help with more id please.

this first is interesting with the silver in middle. Not sure if these two are the same but were in same pot and I split them.

Is the next one Boncel??? I purchased this for $4.50 and it has 4 plants in them.

I too used to be a sans snob but I am so addicted right now, I can't help it. These plants are super cool and love the Hawaiian salt air and sun.

Comments (15)

  • 8 years ago
    last modified: 8 years ago

    I guess my post didn't come through. The silver one might be a Metallica or Silver Cloud, it doesn't look like a Moonshine or Silver Queen, definitely doesn't look like a Bantel's Sensation. That short one looks like a silver version of Loop's Pride?

  • 8 years ago

    Thanks Robdb8 for your input! Anyone else wanna confirm? The funny thing is that these two plants were smashed between a 1 gallon Futura Simplex and I pried them out and put them in their own pots. I'm waiting to see what their pups would look like!

  • 8 years ago

    You're welcome, sorry I couldn't ID any more for you... From all of the other ones I've seen, I do believe that is a Boncel.

  • 8 years ago

    No worries, at least you figured out the Gilt Edge for sure. I'm thankful for that....maybe others will chime in and help with the other ID. I'm gonna post more pics of unknown species and hope you can help later.. Thanks again robdb8.

  • 8 years ago

    Saltdesert, Love those first two. First one looks like my silver version of S. tri. futura 'Asahi' AKA 'Morgenstern's Futura Aurea'. If so, it will develop more yellow on the inside edges. If not, may be something new to us. Same with the other S. tri. futura that almost looks like a 'Eve'. They are new and very exciting. Keep me in mind if you want to trade pups in future. Pictures of the ones I mentioned.

    Those first two are most likely S. trifasciata due to the many leaves in each node.

    Boncel is the dwarf form of S. cylindrical which is what it looks like. Nice find.

  • 8 years ago

    Maybe this is the right one in the first picture... Singer's Silver

  • 8 years ago

    Stush thank you! Trading pups, I know, when I first saw the threads on trading, I immediately thought "those mainlanders make it sound so easy!" ...lol..

    Hawaii has strict agricultural rules. Have to look into it more. Plus, shipping is expensive to and from...anyway something to investigate.

    Robdb8, I think you may have hit the nail on the head! Stush,what do you think? I see a lot of similarities. Thanks guys lets see what the outcome is.

  • 8 years ago

    Saltdesert, I did get some sans from a friend in Hawaii and the post office tells me that priority mail cost the same across the street or to Hawaii. It's a 50/50 toss up as to it making it to Hawaii's customs. I know Hawaii, Calf. and Florida is very strict on some kinds of plants to be imported.

    If you can purchase them reasonable, I would gladly pay for cost to ship them.

    Robdb, You nailed it. First time I heard of this plant. Don't know where I can purchase one at. Is there a nursery near you that sells them?

  • 8 years ago
    last modified: 8 years ago

    No, I only know of one greenhouse nearby that sells sans year round. I would love one too actually... When it warms up a little I'm gonna venture out a little further out to see if any surrounding towns have them (Maybe not that specific variety but whatever I can get). I love Whitney and that one just ups it a little more.

  • 8 years ago

    I don't want any plants right now in winter. Come spring I might have a Whitney pup I can part with. Can't promise anything until I see what does what thru the winter.

  • 8 years ago
    last modified: 8 years ago

    That would be awesome Stush. My local greenhouse had some massive plants that he "needed to divide if they didn't sell". I couldn't turn down a plant that had half a dozen pups coming up, especially if it is indeed a Silver Hahnii Marginata. I know it's the wrong time of year to do anything with them but I'm aching to do something. Someone's going to have to verse me in how to ship plants so I can spread the wealth as well.

  • 8 years ago

    It's simple. Find a right sized box that's not too heavy. Wrap the plant in newspaper, place in box and put address on it. Go to the post office and tell them First Class Mail please (cheapest way). If over 13 oz. then it has to go Priority Mail which is twice as much. Priority Mail is a whole lot easier due to they supply the box and can pick-up at the house with shipping label done on the computer. Cost start around $8 up compared to First Class starting around $3 up.

    I lost my Silver Hahnii Marginata as well as my hahnii Silver Frost. I got to find out why? Keep getting crown rot. Most of the others are doing well. Rot comes from over watering and cold conditions. All my futura always do well for me. Hahnii sucks.

  • 8 years ago

    saltdesert, the sans in your second pic is definitely S. cylindrica v. cylindrica.

    The sans on the left in the first pic could be S. metallica Manolyn, I can't see the leaves well enough to confirm though. The small sans on the right is a Hahnii variety called Silver Frost. It is an unstable variety and can sometimes offset another unusual-looking variety, who's name escapes me right now.


    Leaf cuttings of cylindrica will propagate true, if your plant is Manolyn, leaf cuts will revert back to its base species metallica (old name was guineensis). Leaf cuts of Silver Frost will almost always revert to it's base variety, the regular green Hahnii.


    If you'd post a close-up of the left plant in first pic, we might be able to better identify it for sure.


    Russ

  • 8 years ago

    Russ, yes I had questions on the one you named cylindrica. I have other cylindrica that are large and they grow more upright. The one in the pix kinda fans out heavily, can you explain? It is also much more shorter than my other cylindrica. Thanks

    funny that you mentioned about the silver frost being unstable because those two plants were both in the same pot tucked between a larger Futura Simplex. I actually bought the Futura simplex amongst the dozen or so Futura simple because It was the only one with the silver sans mixed in. I’m wondering it there was some funky reversion going on in that pot. Some of the other simplex had some robusta reversion too. Really cool

Sponsored