Software
Houzz Logo Print
teamwang2009

New front door ideas, please!!!

8 years ago
My wife and I have been going back and forth with front door ideas for a year and we can’t seem to decide which direction to go. We seem to be back at square one! Our cape cod was built in 1938 and has the original 4-panel lite wood front entry door and a 1-panel half lite wood storm door, both painted in Sherwin Williams black-green to match our shutters.

As a south facing house with no overhang, the front door gets +12 hours of sunlight in the summer and is prone to warpage due to the excessive heat trapped between the storm door and front entry door. The glass from the storm door also creates a “magnifying glass” like effect and intensifies the suns rays adding extra heat and warpage to the front entry door. The warpage causes misalignment of the deadbolt lock so we constantly struggle to lock the door in the warmer months. The heat also causes the paint to bubble up and peel.

Instead of regularly repainting both doors we have decided to replace the doors. Here’s where it gets tough!

1) Should the replacement door be fiberglass and is fiberglass less susceptible to warpage?

2) From a design standpoint, should we go with a 1-panel half or three quarter lite, or even full lite with some sort of decorative glass inlay with privacy features, or do we go with what a lot of people seem to getting in our neighborhood, which is a 6-lite craftsman style door?

3) What color should it be? We are torn between staying with the black-green to match the shutters and going with a red door (Benjamin Moore Caliente is a possibility). We are thinking the red may help with our warpage issue by not absorbing the sun’s rays and heating up as much as the black-green currently does.

4) Do we need a storm door? Without the storm door the front entry door will be completely open to the elements without an overhang, but the door will stay cooler in the summer months without one unless we get a half glass/half screen door to help ventilate some of the heat out of the door in the warmer months. Would this type of storm door detract from the aesthetics of the front door?

5) Lastly, what is your opinion on hardware finishes - brushed nickel, brass, or burnished bronze?

Thanks in advance for your opinions, we really could use your help!

Comments (4)