Software
Houzz Logo Print
carriebor

Which Curtains (or neither?)

8 years ago

The bedroom, with existing sheers.


option 1:


And option 2:



Comments (101)

  • 8 years ago

    If I kept it, I would paint the base black.

    Carrie B thanked phuninthesun
  • 8 years ago

    You know, phuninthesun - one of the main reasons I bought it - and I searched for it online - was that I thought it was polished nickel - which is what the bed & the other lamp are...

  • 8 years ago

    Carrie, how is it for weight, would it be possible to knock it over accidentally while trying to turn it on or off? And do you feel you overpaid for what it is? I think if the answer is yes to either, I'd be tempted to return it and keep looking.

    Carrie B thanked beckysharp Reinstate SW Unconditionally
  • 8 years ago
    last modified: 8 years ago

    Carrie B I know, I was just commiserating with you. It is very disappointing when you order a product and it is not what you thought you were purchasing. The rest of the lamp looks nice!! That's why I suggested covering up the cheesy part! LOL! I hope I didn't upset you. :) I always have issues with square lamp shades. It bothers me when they move slightly and are not squared up with the space!! Weird, I know!

    Carrie B thanked phuninthesun
  • 8 years ago

    Sorry, but those two lamps don’t work at all together. Looks like lamps you were making do with. While the lamps don’t have to match, I’d at least have lamps with similar shaped shades. The square one looks modern and the other looks not at all modern.

    Carrie B thanked k9arlene
  • 8 years ago

    If you're disappointed return it if possible. One needs to love his lamps. Why to have something you dislike unless you've got no choice?

    A bad finish is something I've encountered with several products I was tempted to buy cheaper and new. A lamp is at least somewhat easy to return. If it's a big mirror for example then it's when one really gets stuck since the shipping is almost half of its price. It looks fab on pics..then it arrives-and looks like I sprayed it myself with my own hands(that are both left lol). It's maddenning, and that's one of the reasons that set me even more firmly on vintage, second hand route.

    Granted you can find a nice finish nowadays..but the price will be totally different.

    I wouldn't be worried about finishes being the same btw, but that depends on a personal preference of course. Some similarity in mood-yes. Balance (that can be created in several ways)-yes. Finish being the same as a bed-wouldn't try to match..I'd totally go with different material even, say, ceramics(even though they're breakable of course, and with nightstand lamps, would be a concern to clumsy me) or something.

    Carrie B thanked aprilneverends
  • 8 years ago

    Thank you, everyone! I returned the lamp. I bought it via Amazon ($80+) so it was easy to return at UPS. I knew that I just wouldn't be happy with the way it looked. So, still looking.

    In other news, from my original post here, the bird curtains arrived from Pier One. The yellow patterned curtains from Target also arrived, but those I'm definitely returning. I expect the cream twill curtains from JCPenney to arrive tomorrow.

    I put a set of the bird curtains up in one window, and I do like them. I'll wait for the JCPenney curtains to arrive & see if I like them at all, or better than the bird ones.

    Here are the bird curtains in my bedroom (the stuff on the left wall is still in process of being arranged, and artwork isn't up until I decide final furniture location.)

    Another thought that occurred to me is that if the JCPenney curtains are better, maybe the bird curtains could be good in the guest room. I do like the (new) yellow curtains in the guest room (and I've thrown away the receipt & paperwork) but would the bird ones be even better?

  • 8 years ago

    I love the bird curtains, where did you buy them?

    Carrie B thanked Sue Placial
  • 8 years ago

    Sue Placial - Pier1: Applique Bird Curtains

  • 8 years ago

    I love the bird curtains. They would look good in the guest room as well.

    Carrie B thanked phuninthesun
  • 8 years ago

    I like the birds

    (no big wonder here-I always like the birds)) but they really seem content in the room. and the room seems content with them too)

    Carrie B thanked aprilneverends
  • 8 years ago

    Thanks, folks. I'll do one more post tomorrow w/ the JCPenney curtains - assuming I don't know immediately that I either don't like them at all or that I like them even more than the bird curtains!

  • 8 years ago
    last modified: 8 years ago

    The JCPenney curtains are in!

    Here's a photo of the bedroom with the set of bird curtains on the left, and the Penney's on the right. What do you think?


    As much as I like the birds - and I do - you don't really see the actual birds very much when the curtains are hanging...

    ***

    And, while I've got you here... the guest bedroom. I used to have one each of the yellow panels on the windows, with a tie back pulling them back away from each other, like this:

    I just moved both to one window, and a sheer to the middle (the sheer that used to be in my bedroom.) What do you think? Should I go get two more of the yellow panels? Are the sheers nice there in the middle?

    The guest room is used frequently as I rent it out via Airbnb. Most of my guests are tourists or just need a place to sleep. When I don't have guests, I leave the door open and like some light to come in.

  • 8 years ago

    Still love the birds in your room. The sheers would give guests more privacy (if needed), but they are all to short for the guest bedroom.

    Carrie B thanked phuninthesun
  • 8 years ago
    last modified: 8 years ago

    Thanks, Phuninthesun. It the interest of economy, I'm just going with pre-made, and too-short be damned. I'm not paying to have them hemmed, and I don't have a sewing machine.

  • 8 years ago

    I actually like the color of the Penny curtains better with your room. The color is warmer.

    Both are fine, though.

    I've hemmed by hand, it is boring but not particularly hard.

    As far as the too-short goes, I think the too-shortness is less obvious with the tie-back.

    Carrie B thanked P Banos
  • 8 years ago

    I like the bird curtains, seems to fit your more bohemian style. In the guest room since the curtains are to short, I think they look best tied back. Maybe try one sheer and one curtain tied back?

    Carrie B thanked Kitch4me
  • 8 years ago

    Yes to the birds in the guest room, they'll be perfect there. This decorating process can be painful but the wonderful results you've achieved in your living room and kitchen are worth it!

    Carrie B thanked lisaam
  • 8 years ago

    Oy vey. :-) this is somewhat overwhelming... lisaam-you think the birds in the guestroom are better than the current yellows? If I go with the birds in guestroom - one or two panels per window?

  • 8 years ago

    Carrie B Which are your favorite?? LOL!! How about these curtains with cats on them?

    Carrie B thanked phuninthesun
  • 8 years ago
    I love the cream in your bedroom and try the birds in the guest room. They match the pretty spread.
    Carrie B thanked Stacey
  • 8 years ago

    phuninthesun - I want curtains with kittens! Truth is, while I think the bird ones are adorable, from further away, you really don't see the appliqued birds - you just see.... an odd pattern. So, I think I really do like the Penney ones better. I wish I were sure they were right, though. I've already returned several curtains...

    And, for the guest room, I might just stick with one tied back panel per window. It is a very old house, so not looking modern & fashionable is, in some ways, a plus. My home has a historic feel (and is about 200 years old.)

  • 8 years ago
    last modified: 8 years ago

    Then the Penneys curtains it is! If you like them, then they are right (and they do look nice). You have to look at them every day! Are you sue you don't want to at least try the birdy curtains in the guest room and show us?? Although, if they are short as well, then don't even show us. Thank you for volunteering to be tortured by strangers and have a wonderful evening!

    Carrie B thanked phuninthesun
  • 8 years ago

    phuninthesun - maybe tomorrow, I'll try the birds in the guest room - one or two panels per window? In a bit, I'm off for an Internet first meeting date. Wish me luck.

  • 8 years ago
    last modified: 8 years ago

    I agree Carrie. I think you should stick with the JC Penney curtains in your room and the yellow curtains in the guest room. I think they suit your room. And good luck on your date!

    Carrie B thanked katinparadise
  • 8 years ago

    Good luck and have fun : )

    Carrie B thanked beckysharp Reinstate SW Unconditionally
  • 8 years ago

    (with the date, not the curtains lol)

    Carrie B thanked beckysharp Reinstate SW Unconditionally
  • 8 years ago

    Internet Dating! Wow! Have fun!

    Carrie B thanked phuninthesun
  • 8 years ago
    Carrie, you go girl, you are awesome!
    Carrie B thanked Stacey
  • 8 years ago

    OK, first. Thank you all!

    I decided to go with the Penney's cream curtains.

    I also made the rods wider. In making the rods wider, the artwork that I had there no longer worked - it was too squished in between the inner panels. I switched out the artwork, and I still have more to hang - the current art-between-the-windows may change again, but I do think this is an improvement.

  • 8 years ago

    I love them! Very nice!

    Carrie B thanked amykath
  • 8 years ago

    Now just press or steam them and you are looking great. Glad you selected the solid color, they suit the room so well.

    Carrie B thanked P Banos
  • 8 years ago

    The extra width looks great, too.

    Carrie B thanked beckysharp Reinstate SW Unconditionally
  • 8 years ago

    Glad you widened them up. It makes the windows look larger and lets in more light. The length looks perfect as well. I hope your date was a success!

    Carrie B thanked katinparadise
  • 8 years ago

    Just a quick update:

    1. I ironed the curtains, and now all my friends & family want to know what you did to CarrieB & where you hid her body.

    2. I ordered another lamp, and I got it today. I think I like it. It is bulkier than the other lamp, but I don't think I mind. I don't want them to match. You think it's OK? (I have not yet removed the plastic from the shade.)

  • 8 years ago

    The curtains look really nice now!

    I think the mismatched lamps could be more mismatched - say stick with the same visual weight but different finishes. The original lamp goes well with the bedframe, the new one no so much...what about a glass candlestick lamp? Or even colored glass?



  • 8 years ago

    lol you're too funny Carrie!Your room has this sunny disposition..probably takes it from you

  • 8 years ago
    last modified: 8 years ago

    What do you all think of either a wood lamp either in wood color, or painted black? Or maybe ceramic. I don't think I like glass very much.

  • 8 years ago

    What are the finishes on both lamps?

  • 8 years ago

    The lamps (and my bed) are nickel.


  • 8 years ago

    Typically, when the end tables are different, the lamps would be the same. However, the finishes go together and I think the shape of the lamp and shade works.

  • 8 years ago

    Those curtains are the right ones for in there. They look very nice.

    Ah, I see that your bed is nickel now. I thought it was brass in the other photos!

  • 8 years ago
    last modified: 8 years ago

    Thanks, all. I'll give it another day or two before I decide. Truth is, I don't really *need* a lamp on the left side - oh, maybe I do for balance/aesthetics, but I live alone... with only periodic visitors to that other side of the bed.


  • 8 years ago

    The curtains look great! Maybe if you switch the lamps so the bulkier one is on the larger nightstand and the slimmer one is on the smaller.

  • 8 years ago

    Thanks katinparadise. I decided to return that lamp. I decided against switching it because then the shade heights would have been more different. The bulky lamp is sshorter, and was sitting on a taller nightstand. I don’t know if the different heights really matter though…


    And, now, just to throw a monkey wrench into things… A friend of mine who is an artist and a fabulous decorator suggested I go with something more contemporary just to emphasize my eclectic tastes.

  • 8 years ago

    I'm sure you'll know it when you see it. I love Target for lamps. They have some nice looking lamps for very reasonable prices. Easy returns as well as you know!

  • 8 years ago

    Carrie, do you like Etsy? Browse Etsy for lamps..(check your local CL as well if you're not averted to it-I know some people don't like it since can be not very safe. We used it A LOT without problems-but still had couple unpleasant situations. Not bad, just couple situations when half the house is furnished in CL stuff. But still worth mentioning. )..chances are you'll find very interesting lamps. Obviously it's pages upon pages of lights..but it's fun. And most likely will be something with character, priced right, if not made by a seller-you can always write a message try to see whether the price can be better. I don't dare to ask with handmade, I do ask all the time about vintage, and usually people will do a little discount. They'll answer all your questions, they'll pack it properly, they care about their feedback. EBay is another source obviously-Etsy is more personal though.

    99% of sellers will take returns-can be PITA of course, but gives some reassurance. Also lamps are easier than chandeliers for example.

    Estate sales can be good too. One of our nightstand lights is some big name brand, that costs hundreds-yet it was smth like 50 bucks I guess. Also I wouldn't check it out otherwise, I just wouldn't look for that type of a lamp, it's very traditional. Detailed traditional. But when I saw it up close I loved it.

    The light on the other nightstand(my side)-is totally different modest tole mcm-it's a task light that I can direct however I please, since I read in bed. I mean I read almost only in bed. It's a bit shorter-ok I put couple books under it so it's higher. This one, I found on Etsy.

    And these lamps of totally different pedigree work quite well together.

    I'd go with ceramic in a heatbeat-but I know myself..I can be clumsy, If you're not-then yes by all means check ceramics too. They can be super cool.

    Check these sites if you haven't yet-the richness of lights out there is overwhelming, in a good way. Even if you end up finding something new-will give you a lot of great ideas, and will be fun to look at. At most stores, one has smaller selection(and, usually, pays more)

    We covet what we see(c)-so I didn't even know that I love so many lights until I saw them..

  • 8 years ago

    Katinparadise - I've been to Target a bunch of times lately, and checked out their lamps the last couple times I was there. So far, nothing's grabbed me, but next time I'm nearby, I'll check them out again. This morning, I was in Home Goods & Home Depot, nothing appealed. The Lowe's down here has a not bad selection, so will look again, there, soon.

    Aprilneverends - I love Etsy, and have bought a bunch of stuff there. I've even bought lamps on Etsy. Now that I've ordered two lamps I thought I'd love Online, though, I'm thinking I really want to buy locally. Especially with return shipping costs... I will look at Etsy again, and I'll look at CL & Ebay as well. I bought my LR rug on Ebay, and am very happy with it.

  • 8 years ago

    Now that this conversation has evolved beyond curtains (thank you, all, I'm delighted with them!) I'm going to start a new thread about lighting. I'll link to this one.

  • 8 years ago

    Carrie, check Target online as well. They have a much bigger selection and you can still return at the store. Glad the curtains worked out well for you!