Are you removing the shutters to paint them? If so, can they be stripped and stained to give a more natural wood look?
To be honest, I like the white door trim... I'd be tempted to keep it the same colour, except perhaps for a very light tone in the "fan" above the door, maybe coral or rose.

The trim is a yellowish color. The shutter r colonial blue.

Yes, I love that you fly our Flag. How about a BM Historic Navy blue for the shutters and white for the trim. God Bless America.

Can u do that with a tan and almost black green color? I can never get it so perfect

Thanks, grover, very, very traditional American. Your rendering is wonderful. It looks so Williamsburg or Beacon Hill.

And thanks Judy. I love the flag too ESP at night.

Tan is really hard.

Benjamin Moore colors Lancaster white trim and Essex green shutters, trust me you will love it.