Software
Houzz Logo Print
marchelladair

Paint cabinets or leave them

8 years ago

I am so tired of these orange cabinets. They are maple custom built but I swear they are getting oranger everyday. They are only 7 years old and in fantastic shape. I would love to replace the granite but that isn't a option right now. (still working on my hubby)The paint color is BM old salem grey. Any ideas what I could do to make it not so warm. I am changing the pendent lights above the bar to larger ones. Maybe a gel stain or paint them whit. Thought about changing the paint color first. Any suggestions.



Comments (42)

  • 8 years ago

    They are very pretty but I have not had to live with them for 7 years. And I like orange woodwork. :)

    You should probably change the wall color first because it's easier, but you don't have a lot of wall showing.

    What about adding a nice backsplash to brighten things up?

  • 8 years ago

    These are awesome cabinets, please don’t paint them. Can u change out the hood and Mayb (if you want)have the cabinets sanded and stained a different colour.

  • 8 years ago
    last modified: 8 years ago

    Wow - what a beautiful kitchen. I'm sorry you aren't satisfied with it. If you wait just a bit longer all the white and gray will no longer be popular, wood will be back and you may then be happy.

  • PRO
    8 years ago
    last modified: 8 years ago

    I would not paint the cabinets. They are beautiful as wood. They match the accent colors in the masonry on your fireplace. I would start with changing the paint or adding a tile backsplash (remove the granite backsplash if you do). The current paint color seems to have a green undertone which clashes a bit with your cabinets. Try something more cream or golden.

  • 8 years ago
    last modified: 8 years ago

    "If you wait just a bit longer all the white and gray will no longer be popular, wood will be back and you may then be happy."

    LOL. I must have missed the part in the OP where she said she was trying to follow some home decorator trend.


    OP, I think your cabinets are really pretty, I do. But man, that is an AWFUL lot of wood. I would also be over having so much of that look in the kitchen. Still, not sure I would want to paint it. I do think I would have to get rid of that massive hood - I think it contributes to the oppressive "woodiness". Also, consider painting the island. And definitely a light backsplash.

  • 8 years ago

    I would change your hood (yes, I know it's custom but it's quite heavy) to the same color combo as your stacked stone on your FP has. It shows your cabinet color with a light gray? I love Modern Masters metallic paint, this pic shows "warm silver" (I painted my exterior doors with their "old english" paint 10 years ago and they are still perfect). Maybe a 2 tone hood to bring in the white from your window casing and lighten it up? And a back splash same color as your casing. Cheap changes :)

    If you experiment on changing your cabinet color, try on the inside of the door first...I've redone my cabinets 5 times ;)

  • PRO
    8 years ago
    last modified: 8 years ago

    Agree replace hood over the stove to SS.

    Would hang a huge (relatively), light colored light fixture over the island, to draw some attention away from all the wood cabinets.

    Changing the countertop on the island to something lighter, might also brighten up the kitchen.

    Would not paint them.

  • 8 years ago

    Thanks for all the advice. It never dawned on me how huge the stove hood was. Thats a lot of orange. I think painting it would be helpful to. I am going to go and look for a different one and I am thinking about losing the 3 cabinets above the sink. its amazing what others can come up with.

  • PRO
    8 years ago

    On this kitchen I would not paint. The cabinets are in great shape.

    I would remove wood hood, valance over window, new backsplash (without the 4" of granite) and floor...you'd be surprised at the look you will attain from just that.

    Whichever way you go show us your re-do when you are done.

    marchelladair thanked Filipe Custom Woodwork
  • 8 years ago
    I too hate orange wood. These don't look too orangey to me, but I'm not staring at them every day. To me, its not the color or tone it's just that there is so much of it. I would paint the wall a color that would tone down the brassiness. Also, can you add some under cabinet lighting. Changing the tone of light bulbs can make a room look cooler instead of warmer. Changing out the hood like others said, will break up the wood. You could also change the top cabinets to glass doors and put colorful plates there.

    The cabinets have great integrity, really beautiful pieces of wood. If you are dead against the color then have them stained. It will give you the tone you want but still show the beauty of the wood.
    marchelladair thanked User
  • 8 years ago

    Like others have said, get rid of the wood hood and replace it with something a little more streamlined. Get rid of the wood valance over the window and if you can, get rid of the cabinets over the window too. Use the removed molding along to top to make new molding strips to go on the sides of the cabinets. That would eliminate the large span of wood along that wall. You may want to make the window taller to let in more light. Add a great pendant light over the sink. Depends on your budget and how handy you are or if you have a carpenter you can trust to do the work. If you can, add glass to the upper cabinets on each side of the sink.

    marchelladair thanked annac54
  • 8 years ago

    I would paint them white in a heartbeat. It will brighten up your whole kitchen

  • 8 years ago

    So many range hoods to chose from. I can also carry the tile up the wall after removing the wooden one. Any ideas. I am thinking 36 inch one.

    https://www.houzz.com/ideabooks/99248265/list/up-to-75-off-range-hoods


  • 8 years ago

    Consider changing the glass and then put in lighting behind the glass to brighten it up. Consider 2 tone before painting them all. Consider a different counter top. There r many here with great Photoshop skills to help envision options. Good luck.

  • 8 years ago
    Ok. Hubby has agreed to let me change my granite out. I am going really light. Moving the 3 cabinets above the sink a a new range hood. Is there anyone on here that could give me a vision of this with photo shop. I have to get it right this time. Also a light color back splash behind my stove. I would so appreciate any help
  • 8 years ago
    last modified: 8 years ago

    It looks like your walls are green which will make the orange stand out, I'd repaint those first. Also removing a few uppers above the sink and changing to a stainless hood would make a big difference. Usually I am team paint the cabinets but yours are just too nice to paint IMO!!

  • PRO
    8 years ago

    I'm in the minority, but I would paint the cabinets. Decide on your countertops first, and then your cabinet color. We're not talking about painting 18th antique wood here! THey're kitchen cabinets! And there are a LOT of them.

    The hood does not bother me - wouldn't necessarily have chosen it, but it's not that heavy looking.

    Now to be a "downer": you're going to spend a lot of money getting a good paint job and replacing the countertops and hood, and you're still not going to have any drawers, which anyone with them will tell you is transforming. I'd look into the cost of replacing the cabinets - you may be able to sell them as is on Craig's list.

    marchelladair thanked Anglophilia
  • 8 years ago
    If I painted them I would do it myself. I have painted 3 kitchens before and several bathrooms and was very pleased. I have plenty of drawers I don't need anymore. I have 12 and my dining room is open to this and I have drawers there to. If I would take the junk out of them I wouldn't need that many. Lol. I am still thinking about painting but I am not going to rush to this decision yet.
  • 8 years ago

    I like you kitchen cabinets. If it were my space I would keep the wood as is. I would save up to change the perimeter counters to a white or creamy white granite or marble. I would keep the island top black . I would see about installing above cab lighting. I would paint the walls a new color and maybe even change the backsplash. I might also see about installing lighting in the stacked toppers. Maybe put plain glass to make the light shine.






  • 8 years ago

    My opinion? Paint them! I think they would look great painted. I think you could change out the hood, but I think if you paint the cabinets, that will kind of go away. I agree with taking off the valance.

  • 8 years ago
    last modified: 8 years ago

    Consider just painting the uppers.

    marchelladair thanked eam44
  • 8 years ago

    I would not paint the hood - the size is one reason it is so overpowering. Replace it. That link you posted has several that look like they would be a great improvement.

  • PRO
    8 years ago

    If you can paint them yourself, you will save a TON of money, as you well know. We did ours...twice over the years. We used oil based high gloss enamel and it wore like iron.

  • 8 years ago

    The hood looks okay to me. I would remove all the wall cabinets on the sink window and install a much wider window. Or take out 1/2 of them. The room seems dark and not because of the cabinets. All your lights are not on. The wood color of your cabs is very nice.

  • 8 years ago
    last modified: 8 years ago

    What about painting the island to break it up? Maybe switch out a few doors for glass doors? I think taking out all the wood over the sink/window area would help.

  • 8 years ago

    Remove top-most uppers; switch out wooden hood for a SS one; remove the valance over the window; switch out uppers for white

    (no change to your counters - I just didn't have a granite-esque counter option so I just made them all black)


    marchelladair thanked damiarain
  • 8 years ago

    In your last photo in the OP, it looks like the wood cabinets look fantastic with the stone on the wall in the next room - really picks up the same tan/brown color. And the colors in the 2 countertop colors are also in the stone wall. (I guess I'm just saying when you are in those rooms, I bet your cabinets look great; a cohesive look between the 2 rooms.)

  • 8 years ago

    Thanks so much for all the comments and photo everyone has posted. So many great ideas.

  • 8 years ago
    Here is a few more photos from inside the living room. My whole house is painted and decorated in warm colors. That's why I feel limited on what to do.
  • 8 years ago

    I would not feel limited at all. (You have a beautiful home, by the way. :-) ). You even already have white trim out there. I see nothing there that dictates keeping the kitchen as it is. You could absolutely have a much lighter and brighter kitchen if that is what you want.

  • 8 years ago

    Very nice, but very dark space. I would not paint them, but I would change out the hood to a sleek stainless one, add light countertops & light backsplash.

  • 8 years ago
    As little as there is the green Old Salem gray paint is contributing a lot of the icky contrast. I put my fingers over the green in your photo and it looks way better. Good suggestions, swap the hood, new backsplash or paint it out off white if that’s your trim colour. Add some glass to some uppers, bigger sconce lighting. Paint as a last resort.
  • 8 years ago

    I am going to change that color out this weekend. You are right. It really looks terrible with the cabinets.

  • 8 years ago

    We'd love to see another photo added to your comment next week! Is there just the one post? Have you thought about painting it your trim color?

  • 8 years ago
    I will post photos after I paint it. I already took the wood off of the cabinets above the sink.
  • 8 years ago

    I think your hood is awesome. It's an artistic focal point. Please don't stick an ordinary old chimney hood in there and lose all the uniqueness of your kitchen. Your kitchen has a pub look to it so don't fight it.

    Removing the valance helped a lot. Get larger sconces with a wow factor.

  • PRO
    8 years ago

    I would paint the island and the hood. Take out the 4" granite splash and get a creamy light tile, switch out the lights and see what you're working with after that. I think you'd be surprised how much just a couple small things will change everything.

  • 8 years ago

    As someone who also has a "warm" color scheme and a kitchen I want to lighten up, I can relate to your dilemma. I don't usually like oak cabinets very much but I really like yours. I totally agree with Mayflowers about your hood. As Astonia suggested, before considering replacing it try the wall paint suggestions and a tile backsplash. You might be able to find a remnant for the island for a reasonable amount. I once had a kitchen with a similar layout, we opted to do a window wall with no uppers where your sink is. I also really like your fireplace. Good luck I look forward to seeing pictures after the paint.

  • 8 years ago

    How about just changing the island counter to a white quartz? That black top sucks up a lot of light. You could see how it looks by simply wrapping a white table cloth or paper on it, lol. You could also consider painting just the island white.

    You should also put on some more lights, lol, or add some more if needed. Lighter paint color, as you are doing will help.

    I think you will regret it if you paint all that beautiful wood.

  • 8 years ago
    I didn't get to paint this weekend I hope to one evening after work. Grandkids ballgames are setting me back. I am not complaining at all though.
  • 8 years ago

    I’d like to clarify that when I painted our range hood with a sample pot of paint, it was a one pint sample from Ace Hardeware, which might be bigger than what other stores sell.