Software
Houzz Logo Print
kris_dow

Does this house have an architectural style?

8 years ago

I think it looks like someone just decided they wanted a unique roof, but I’m not an architectural history expert. :) (Poor photo quality because I found it online, sorry.)



Comments (15)

  • 8 years ago
    Flat roof is not unheard of
  • 8 years ago

    A pro may correct me, but it looks like a Mansard roof

  • 8 years ago

    @JudyG - a really half-hearted attempt, it looks like. I may be asking for curb appeal help in the future. (Not mine atm. We’re considering it.)

  • PRO
    8 years ago

    Definitely has possibilities…right now it is too dark and heavy looking. I have seen a house like this all white and it is stunning.

    KD thanked JudyG Designs
  • 8 years ago
    last modified: 8 years ago

    Mid Century French Mansard. A lot of Mid Century homes only had nods to Modern architecture. The “Mediterranean” look, and the “Tudor” look and the “French” look all had interesting leaded glass, usually in modern window forms. Lots of black iron, and unusually detailed doors, and Moroccan or rubble stone terra cotta tiles were part of the trend. Many of those same elements are hot once again.

    Remove the gawdawful shutters and put on an architectural shingle and a few other tweaks and it would be great.

    KD thanked User
  • 8 years ago
    last modified: 8 years ago

    I believe it was built in the 70s, so it’s not technically MCM, I think? What kind of architectural shingle would you be thinking of?

    The deck in front is gone, but I do think it needs to be replaced, it gives more outdoor space to use. I was thinking something less rustic/backyard deck looking though. (Yes, I know that will be expensive. The way property values in the area are going, it’d be worth it.)

    I’m not sure about painting the brick white. Painting brick seems to be adding work on upkeep?

  • 8 years ago

    I'm with Sophie - Mid Century French Mansard. It also feels a little English Cottage with the deck, planters, and massive evergreen shrubs.

    KD thanked Godswood
  • 8 years ago
    last modified: 8 years ago

    Yes. That’s a Thing. Not at all uncommon. Tons of apartment buildings and taco huts used the style. Many of the ones in residential architecture were Colonial styled by the mid 70’s and had the hideous Early American reproduction furniture in them.

    KD thanked User
  • PRO
    8 years ago
    The “Mansard Roof” originated in France I believe as early as 1550 as part of the Louvre. Some say it helped avoid window taxes. Some say it got around restricted heights of buildings. In any case, except on some specially designed buildings, for residential use, it is not appealing to most.
    KD thanked Flo Mangan
  • 8 years ago

    JudyG - I always think of MCM as ~50s early 60s only, for some reason. We looked at a house recently that basically hadn’t had much decoration changed since it was built in the 50s. It had the big glass tiles in kitchen and all bathrooms, too. So that’s where my mind goes when I think MCM.

    (We were so bummed when we realized we just couldn’t make the space in the house work for us, it would’ve been a fun project, especially since it appeared to have been kept up well and updated where necessary for safety, like the wiring and furnace.)

  • 8 years ago

    Hm. I think it looks better when the windows in the roof have trim around them, but I don’t see how you’d do that there, the way the roof wraps around. I wonder if being recessed blocks some light into the house, too. (It’s north-facing.) That’s something to consider that I probably would’ve missed if I hadn’t asked here about the style, thanks!

    (The house does look less squat in person - it’s on/in a hill so the driveway is sloped up from the street fairly steeply, so if you’re on the sidewalk it looks taller, which changes perception of proportions.)

  • PRO
    8 years ago
    last modified: 8 years ago

    The particular house you feature above, has been in houzz dilemmas for 4 years. If you are not the original OP, you may want to read them.

    As for the time period, 1933-1965, is designated for the particular design, but not referred as MCM until the 50’s.



  • 8 years ago
    last modified: 8 years ago

    There is a difference between Mid Century interpretations of some traditionalists designs, and Mid Century Modern. Just because something originates in the Mid Century time frame does not mean that the Modern appellation applies to it. You can see the Modernist influences at work there, but in no way is that MCM.

    I do think the Modern could be accented, and it would benefit the appeal. But I like Mansard roofed dwellings, both authentic French inspired and the more severe stripped interpretations that were built in the late mid century. 65-78 is the time frame for most of them. Some are a hot mess. Some are so severe and minimalist in their interpretations that it’s easy to amp up the Modern aspects and make something handsome from their bones.

    Black iron, red metal windows, and the most important selection of all, a great either faux cedar shake or faux slate roofing material. Even a great ribbed metal could add texture and linearity that would accent Modern and benefit the home.

    KD thanked User
  • 8 years ago

    I don’t mind the mansard roof as long as it doesn’t look like a Radio Shack from the 70s.

    I really like slate so that is an interesting idea for the shingles, and I never would’ve considered colored windows. But I can see how that would add some interest to the windows and some color to the house without the shutters. I was thinking if we replaced the porch/front deck we’d do something with maybe black metal railings? Not wood.