good eye! at first i was unsure, but in only a couple seconds i saw the way it brought together the rather natural and roughness of your fireplace with the rest of your room.

next i vote we get new end table and lamp. but i vote yes.

I would say no it takes away from the fireplace you need something more light

I love it for the space

Seems a bit large. Maybe that's just the camera angle? Could you move the furniture further away to give it more breathing room. I think it is a fantastic piece!

Hmmm. It seems fine for the room--if you take everything else out. Except the dog--keep the adorable puppers.

Can you post a wider view of the room so we can see how it fits in as far as scale.

Not sure if it's the angle of the picture, but it looks like it's really tall and seems a bit overwhelming for the small space. I would consider another table with less visual weight (ie: glass table).

While I like mixing modern/contemporary with rustic, this table is too big a contrast. An iron base, with a round, even edged, darker stained top would still have the rustic vibe, without looking so out of place.

I think it is an awesome piece. If you love it, keep it.

No. Does not fit the rest of room. Buy a massive cabin on a lake in the mountains for this piece lol

It’s a beautiful piece but something is off with the size and the sheen. I would say something smaller. But maybe use it elsewhere?

Rug color on my screen doesn’t work in the room.

HI -- I think you have fallen to a trend . It is a very nice table but .... I think it is too big and lumpy and not fitting with your furniture . It might pass if it could be lowered but I vote a " no " .

I like the table, but don't think it works with your decor/room. It's a bit too chunky and doesn't look good with the rug.

Rug is too small, mantel is too high and needs to go full width, and table might work in a sunroom or basement rec room.

No, it hogs all the attention in your pretty room.

what does the pup think?

Thanks for your input as it was helpful in my decision. Was looking for a unique piece of furniture for there but agree that it is to big and chunky for the space. I may switch it out for a rustic console table instead and go with a round glass coffee table. Thanks for your help. Should have went with my gut instinct when it was placed in the room. Sometimes in the store it doesn't seem as large in size.