Software
Houzz Logo Print
bethdeg

Fireplace-what should I do?

8 years ago
Should I paint the mantle black?
Or
Should I paint brick, Benjamin Moore ,dune white and replace mantle? Should I use a primer to paint the brick?
Or
Should I demolish it and build something new?

Suggestions, please!

Comments (36)

  • 8 years ago

    I am not a pro, but I think if you had chosen a wall color that was just a bit lighter it would have gone better with the fireplace. The art you've chosen is very interesting but it looks a little wide for your mantle. Wonder how it would look in the portrait orientation. I would be very hesitant to paint brick. If you really want it painted, please consult with a pro. It would be worth the money to have someone else do it properly.

  • 8 years ago

    The fireplace is workable but it is hard to make suggestions without knowing the style of the rest of the room. Is there a specific reason why you painted the fireplace wall so dark?

  • 8 years ago
    It's just a quick fix. I hate the brick. I don't care if it's damaged. I will do a better reno later. The picture is going.
    Here is a picture of my living room
  • 8 years ago

    I would try white washing it first to tone it down. Perhaps choose a white with a hint of grey. To me, fully painted brick often looks flat and has an odd texture.



  • 8 years ago
    What about this?Fireplace on left, not shelves.
  • 8 years ago

    I think a black mantel would just get lost against the wall, possibly to the point of near-invisibility. Maybe white, or a different stain, but not black.

  • 8 years ago
    last modified: 8 years ago

    You will not get the look in that photo from painting brick. You photo is chiseled stone, possibly marble, that has a lot of texture. When you paint brick, you lose texture. Whitewashing will leave more of the character of the brick

    Your wall color does have a big impact on the look of the brick. I finally committed to whitewashing my brick FP, but painted the walls and ceiling first. When I changed the wall color, all the sudden the brick FP stopped fighting the room.

    For me, the room is a bit dark for your furnishings -- there is little contrast between the walls and the sofa. What is there gets lost in the shadows once you move away from the window. It looks so heavy (dark floor, dark walls, dark sofa) -- painting the FP white will not lighten the room. Are you planning on changing the off-white curtains and the trim color in the hall?

    I would start by attaching some molding to the mantle to give it a depth at least equal to the baseboards -- you can go straight and boxy or with some detail to it, but the mantel needs more depth and you have room to drop it down a few inches. Then paint the mantel white to match the baseboards. The step back and re-evaluate.

  • 8 years ago

    Coming back to add that I see that same brick outside the window. That was my issue too -- brick matched the outside of the house, but I wasn't loving it inside. Seemed like two different animals. Until I repainted my FR.

    Do you hate the exterior brick? Hate your house? Probably not. I love my red brick outside but it was driving my nuts inside -- until I changed the paint color. I had no hesitation changing the tile around my sister's FP -- it was a cheap ceramic that matched nothing other than the faux marble we were replaced with wood -- but in my house the brick also matched the exterior brick and painting it seemed less right. You will have that same issue -- painted brick inside and natural brick on the other side of the window. Once you paint it, it is very hard to go back -- and hard to not damage your wood floors. Paint can be a quick fix, but quick fixes sometimes lead to bigger problems and more expensive fixes.

  • 8 years ago
    The brick outside is not the same as fireplace brick.
  • 8 years ago
    What about one of these?
  • 8 years ago

    As I mentioned up thread, I am generally not a fan of painted brick but I think the painted brick will look fine with the decor in the rest of your room. I would gel stain the mantle the same color as the floor.

    I like the idea of white washing because it is a less dramatic change and you can always paint over it if you don't like it. Once you paint, you'll never be able to recover the texture and the variations of color in the brick.

  • 8 years ago

    Your mantel is a bit small; any chance of adding more trim around it as in the After of what d_gw posted above? Personally I much prefer that whitewashed look than paint completely obliterating the brick.

    Any chance of painting that wall the color that is on the sofa wall, where what we see of your furniture is dark also? Do you have two lighter walls now and two of the dark color?

  • 8 years ago

    I have no problem with painted or stained brick--we painted our brick fp incl the brick wall surrounding it (the entire wall, floor to ceiling, is brick), and we painted it all black. I think your fp brick, and mantel would look fabulous if you painted them black, to match your wall. Very dramatic.

    We primed the brick with grey tinted primer, and used a huge fluffy, thick roller to roll the paint on the surface, and a brush to help cover all the joints.

  • 8 years ago
    Thanks for your answer catmom. Will you post a picture, please?
  • 8 years ago
    I primed the brick. I think it looks better already!
  • 8 years ago
    What do you think of this?
  • 8 years ago

    I like it just primed! Beth, are you asking about the tan sofa?

  • 8 years ago
    Not showing the sofa. Just the painted fireplace in that gorgeous room as an example of how great painted brick can look.
    What do you think of the black tile on the hearth?
  • 8 years ago

    Bethdeg, here you go! :)

    Before:

    After:




  • 8 years ago
    Wow!! That is stunning and very gutsy! What finish is your paint?
  • 8 years ago
    I like your mantle as well? What are its dimensions?
  • 8 years ago

    We used BM Aura paint in matte finish (color is: Black). Had originally thought to stain the brick black, but I think I got sidetracked, and ended up going with paint. DH thinks the painted texture looks like leather, and very Tim Burtonesque! We both love how it came out.

    I'll have to measure the mantel for you. It's just a metal cover that sits over the original brick mantel, so the size was dictated by that. Our FP guys, who are also our AC guys, fabricated it for us (they fabricate metal ductwork for AC so it was easy for them, though this was their first mantel cover!). After they were sure of the size/fit (I think they made a trial one, and then made measurement adjustments/tweaks when they did the real one), they took the finished cover back to the shop one last time (all in the same day), and sprayed it the same black as the FP frame.

    DH built a temp wood frame around the brick mantel so our tile guys could mud over the brick (cement, thinset???), and the metal mantel cover was slid over it when it had dried.

  • 8 years ago

    It looks very nice!

  • 8 years ago
    Thanks cat- mom. I had already bought the paint when you posted the picture of your amazing dramatic black wall. I thought I would try this and if I didn't like I would switch to black.
    I did use the same type of paint. BM aura with a matte finish. It is lovely. I would highly recommend the product for walls and fireplaces!
  • 8 years ago

    Very nice!!! Great work!

  • 8 years ago

    Looks fantastic! Love your yellow pillow, btw.

  • 8 years ago
    last modified: 8 years ago

    bethdeg, we had a very similar thought with regards to painting the brick. If we didn't like how it turned out, we figured we'd eventually cover the brick entirely ("plastering" or sheet-rocking over it). But painting it was the cheapest and quickest option to try first.

    Your room looks great--I like your decorating style!

  • 8 years ago

    I like it painted with the minimal mantel better than I thought I would. It all ties together now. I remember the wall of black painted brick from earlier too -- thought it was gutsy and stunning. I don't know that I will ever paint brick though.

  • 8 years ago
    Look at my fireplace before and after. Dreary and country to modern and bright. Nothing to fear aboutpainting brick! It's easy and transformative.
  • 8 years ago

    It isn't fear so much as the fact that I had it drilled into me that you don't paint brick unless it is cheap, inferior quality brick and you need to cover it. In the right place, I might, and I thought about it here, but finally decided it wasn't right for the house and the answer turned out to be a better paint color.

  • 8 years ago

    Looks great bethdeg! Excellent job!

  • 8 years ago
    I held off painting the brick for that reason too for 10 years in this house.
  • 8 years ago

    Wow! And I like your mantel decor.

  • 8 years ago
    Very sharp!
  • 8 years ago
    Thank you.
Sponsored
Custom Home Works
Average rating: 4.6 out of 5 stars10 Reviews
Franklin County's Award-Winning Design, Build and Remodeling Expert