Software
Houzz Logo Print
ncfaz

Engineered Floor Experts Needed

8 years ago

We are looking to replace our poor condition site-finished hardwood floors in a large open area. Our designer has recommended we replace with an engineered hardwood product for multiple reasons (our previous floor gapped horribly- possibly a humidity issue/possibly installation; we're living here and I'm pregnant so we don't want fumes/dust; the colors we want are easier to get in pre-finished; and the factory-applied finish is supposedly harder).


I have looked at every engineered product in our town, and it has been extremely difficult to find the color, finish, and width we like in a single product. Price is not an issue. We'll pay whatever for the right look. Now that I have narrowed it down to a few options, I am finding that the ones we like are very thin veneers. The color we like best is only a 1.2mm veneer, and our second choice is 2mm veneer. Both are light/natural leaning colors with an ultra matte, UV aluminum oxide finish.


From what I've read online, 2mm should be the absolute minimum of veneer thickness for a quality floor. When I ask the floor salespeople about this issue-- and I'm shopping at both wholesale and retail places (our contractor has his own installer)-- they are telling me that the veneer thickness doesn't really matter because we're not going to need or want to refinish these floors. They claim the factory UV aluminum oxide finish is so hard and strong, as long as we aren't blatantly negligent, there is no reason for it to scratch up. I do tend to agree we wouldn't WANT to refinish any floor due to the mess, but I don't want to buy a poor quality product.


Any thoughts here? If none of these engineered products work, we have no choice but to do site-finished solids to get the look we want, but I know from experience that finish can't possibly be any better.

Comments (18)

  • 8 years ago

    I’m no flooring expert by far, but have done a lot of research in my quest for flooring. There are a couple companies that make a thick veneer engineered product. Uptown floors is one of them. They have a 5mm wear layer and offer both prefinished and unfinished I think. I have very limited experience dealing with them, but remember they were one of the few places I looked into. I did talk to one of their salesmen on the phone, he was very nice, not pushy at all, and seemed to be knowledgeable about wood flooring in general.

    If cost is not a factor, I would go with the thicker wear layer. That way you never have to worry about not being able to refinish them. The thicker wear layer allows you to refinish as many times as a solid hardwood.

    There are a few companies that offer the same, google “thick wear layer engineered hardwood”. Good luck!!

    C F thanked swhughes23
  • PRO
    8 years ago
    last modified: 8 years ago

    swhughes:

    That was me you spoke to. Also me in the video above. Uptown is a very small company and I'm the only 'salesman', but dislike the title. I've handled practically every facet of hardwood flooring going back to the early 90's. Or a time when there were only a half dozen prefinished manufacturers. Yes, you could count them on ten fingers.

    I'll be frank. Although I do offer a higher quality engineered, it is accurate many do not need a thick wear layer engineered. However, I find the majority of my customers are looking for higher quality and resist buying the 2-3 mm stuff because they're actually priced the same or higher. Reason? High retail markup.

    "They claim the factory UV aluminum oxide finish is so hard and strong..." Don't let these comments fool you. Anything will scratch. It's a wood floor.

    Ken Fisher

    Custom color matching can be an option.

    C F thanked Uptown Floors
  • 8 years ago

    Thanks all! To Aayers and Uptown, the "look" we are liking best is the Shaw Floors Gramercy Park in Vanderbilt. Our biggest problem has been we don't want to go wider than 5" planks, we don't want a rustic finish with lots of knots, and we like the matte look. Do either of you have anything similar? Of course when I google Shaw, I get lots of negative reviews, probably due in part to the size of the company and range of products.


  • 8 years ago

    Thanks, Oana! None of the stores in town carry these brands. It's looking like I'll either need to specially order a different brand or roll the dice with one in town...

  • 8 years ago

    What about Du Chateau?

  • 8 years ago

    DuChateau is oiled I think.

  • 8 years ago

    CF, I feel your pain. I have not been able to find even ONE brand that I like, carried locally. It looks like I will be ordering mine online.

  • 8 years ago

    I think www.hoskinghardwood.com lets you order samples too, both for owens and lauzon. And Mirage lets you order samples from their website: https://www.miragefloors.com/ENG/samples/

  • 8 years ago

    Mirage -$20 for five samples I think. Craft floors - 4 samples free. Nygree Floors - 2or 3 free I think.

  • PRO
    8 years ago
    last modified: 8 years ago

    "we don't want a rustic finish with lots of knots, and we like the matte look"

    Have that. Harder to find these days with the rage for character type hardwoods.

    3 to 8 1/4" width, you choose. Choose the sheen level too.

    3 1/4" White Oak

    4 & 7 1/4" random - kind of different

    Stair treads and any other mill work too. This one is shown in character.



    C F thanked Uptown Floors
  • 8 years ago

    "Have that. Harder to find these days with the rage for character type hardwoods."

    I am the same. I can't understand why anyone wants open knots and such in their floor. :-( It really has made finding a floor quite difficult when you also factor in the desire for something on the lighter side. I looked at your selections (and I do see a few that I might like) and your engineered prices are higher than the solids...I have not seen that before. Is that where pricing is headed now?

  • 8 years ago

    Chess, we have the rustic-style site-finished hardwood right now, and the knots seem so gross to me. Stuff gets in them and you know it's never coming out... I do like how well the "character" hides scratches and dirt though!

  • PRO
    8 years ago

    There is unfinished engineered flooring available. You can have it site-finished with polyurethane or oil in matte. Unfinished flooring allows more customization in finishing compared to prefinished flooring.

  • PRO
    8 years ago

    "engineered prices are higher than the solids...I have not seen that before. Is that where pricing is headed now?"

    • Likely because you haven't seen a 3/4" engineered hardwood and it's not mass produced. Most of what's out there is 3/8" to 1/2 inch overall thickness creating a lower cost to produce.

    • G&S mentioned unfinished as an option for some.

  • 8 years ago

    Ah...didn’t think about the total width. Good point!

  • 8 years ago
    last modified: 8 years ago

    Good quality engineered has always been more expensive than solid. It has more man hours in production. And it’s a much better product. Just because something is solid doesn’t make the quality at all good. That’s the wood snobbery and prejudice bit that uneducated consumers eat up from hacks trying to sell them garbage that isn’t suited to their site conditions.

    You need to be shopping at the stores where your professional installers shop. They don’t go to Homey Despot. Find s great installer and have him send you to where he shops. He will want to purchase the floors in order to maintain the warranty chain and ensure quality control over a job. And that includes the required prep. A great installer will talk to you about the needed floor prep on the front end.

    Only the low rent bottom of the barrel “floor guys” guys will show up, do no moisture testing, no prep, and install seconds garbage from seconds retailers like Gloor and Decor or Limber Liquidstors.

Sponsored
AIS Renovations
Average rating: 4.5 out of 5 stars15 Reviews
Custom Craftsmanship & Construction Solutions in Franklin County, Ohio