Software
Houzz Logo Print
cpartist

Prep sink issue - What would you do?

8 years ago
last modified: 8 years ago

This is the faucet I had planned on using for the clean up sink. However when the granite installers drilled the holes for the sprayer and my disposal switch, they drilled them too close to the center hole, so my sprayer would be in the same space as the lever on my faucet. The disposal switch would be under the lever on the left.

So the plumbers had the idea to put my clean up sink faucet in the prep sink place like below. And then I'd get a second bridge faucet, exactly the same for the cleanup sink.

However, the sprayer and the disposal switch would be slightly out of the perimeter of the sink like below. The sprayer would be where it is shown (it's not attached right now) and the disposal switch would be an equal distance on the left side from the faucet.

Or this might be my one other choice although I'm not in love with a single handle. I would have to turn the handle so it is front which doesn't thrill me because then your hand is practically under the water when you turn it on. With this one, I could keep the three holes where they are and put the disposal switch on the left and the sprayer on the right like I had planned.

So do I go with:

A. The bridge faucet at the prep sink and at the cleanup sink with sprayers at both? That would look like my first picture.

B. The bridge faucet at the prep sink and at the cleanup sink with a sprayer only at the cleanup sink? That would mean I'd have no sprayer at my cleanup sink.

C. The single arm faucet with the handle turned and the sprayer at the prep sink and the bridge faucet and sprayer at the cleanup sink?

Your thoughts and what would you do?

For reference HERE is my other thread that shows where the cleanup sink is.

Comments (37)

  • 8 years ago

    A. not having a sprayer would drive me nuts. The consistency of the faucets overcomes the sprayer / switch being outside the lines of the sink, IMO.

    cpartist thanked just_janni
  • 8 years ago

    No sprayer. I don’t have a sprayer even on my large farm sink and doesn’t bother me at all. Had a sprayer years ago and hardly used it. All that being said, your granite people need to consider replacing granite.

    cpartist thanked User
  • 8 years ago

    I think I prefer C, then A.

    We're so helpful.

    cpartist thanked caligirl5
  • 8 years ago

    I would prefer A. Even though the sprayer and disposal switch will be outside the perimeter of the sink, I think it looks fine.

    cpartist thanked Jennifer
  • 8 years ago

    Or can you find a bridge faucet that has a pull-down sprayer in the faucet head? So you don't need a separate sprayer on the side?


    cpartist thanked Jennifer
  • 8 years ago

    I think you need a new piece of granite so it can be done right. You shouldn't have to adjust for their mistake! I'm another one who doesn't use a sprayer. When my mother first got one in the 50s she just knew if we kids used it we would break it so we were told NEVER to touch it and I haven't and didn't even when I lived in a house with one. I don't miss it.

    cpartist thanked User
  • 8 years ago

    Since you were going with the bridge faucets to begin with (and I love them, we’ll have two also – one at the prep, one at the cleanup), I’m also not in love with the single handle. I think it’d be great in another style kitchen… I don’t see it in yours.


    Ok, I see what you’re saying about the sprayer and air switch – the sprayer will reach, but aesthetically, they might look a bit crowded…


    Option A with no doubts. Yes, your original plan was perfect, ideal, but I think the pic above looks just fine and I’ve stared at it a long time wondering what I’d do; I don’t think it looks over-crowded; living without a sprayer at either sink… nope.


    cpartist thanked 2ManyDiversions
  • 8 years ago

    I'd do the bridge faucet with sprayer at both. It wouldn't bother me a bit to have the sprayer and disposal switch beyond the perimeter, and it's actually kind of a bonus in my mind to have the identical faucets at both sinks.

    I am often cooking on autopilot, and it would annoy me to have two different faucets with two different handle actions at the two sinks.


    cpartist thanked Brickman House
  • 8 years ago

    I have a single lever faucet with the handle turned to the front and I love this set-up. I find it so much easier to control water temp with one handle.

    I have 8 1/4" between faucet stem (the back part) and the spout (front
    part). Is that similar to the single lever faucet you show above? Is it fixed or
    does it swivel? Mine swivels but even so, I've never gotten wet when
    turning the water on.

    I worried at first (as we tend to do, or more accurately, overdo with every kitchen decision, lol) about my hand being under the water when I turned the faucet on, getting wet each time, but I haven't done it once. In fact, turning the faucet on has become so automatic that I had to go turn the water on to remember how I avoid getting wet.

    I don't reach in a straight line to the faucet because that would mean my wrist would be at an odd angle to turn the handle on. I reach in with a slightly bent elbow, much like how you'd reach for a coffee cup when the handle is turned facing you. That elbow bend keeps the arm from being directly under the faucet.

    So I vote C for the above reasons. Plus, I think the scale of the single stem, single lever faucet is better for the prep sink. The bridge faucet option with sprayer and air switch outside the sink perimeter looks crowded and busy to me. Besides, I much prefer lever controls to turn knobs. When I have messy hands, I often turn my faucet on with the side of my hand. You can't do that with turn knobs.

    cpartist thanked lisa_a
  • 8 years ago

    As I mentioned in the other thread, I was surprised to learn that I did not miss having a sprayer when I had to do without one for a while. My biggest concern would be about not compromising the beauty of the countertop.

    cpartist thanked Rita / Bring Back Sophie 4 Real
  • 8 years ago

    I'd rather have a single handle to begin with, but assuming you don't I think "A" looks fine.

    cpartist thanked DrB477
  • 8 years ago

    Thank you all. To those who said get new granite, this is not ordinary granite you can find anywhere. It is a one of a kind granite and there is no more of it. I'm stuck with it the way it is with the three holes.

    Thank you all. I went this afternoon to the plumbing supply place (Fergusons, lol) to look at my other options and the two I like the best are still the bridge faucet or the one I originally picked for the prep sink. I think I'm going to go with option A.

  • 8 years ago

    If you do a single handle faucet, don't put the handle in the front--put it on the left. It works especially well for righties, and lefties are used to having things not ideal.

    cpartist thanked Fori
  • 8 years ago

    I vote C. What a bummer all around.

    cpartist thanked User
  • 8 years ago
    last modified: 8 years ago

    Or this might be my one other choice although I'm not in love with a single handle.

    My vote is easy because I AM in love with the idea of a single handle faucet, and I WOULD turn the handle forward-facing. This means you can turn it on easily with either hand, and when you turn it off with wet hands, the water drips into the sink instead of the counter.

    Since you're not sure about the front-facing control, could you go with a foot control? Yeah, you'd still have the handle, but you'd fall into the habit of not using it, so not problem with wetting your hands before you mean to do so.

    I would NOT switch your two sinks. You put more than a bit of thought into this placement, and I don't think you'll be happy in the long run if you alter your well-thought out plan.

    No sprayer.

    I never use my sprayer, but I suspect that if I had a GOOD sprayer, I would use it. You can get a single hole faucet with a pull-down sprayer.

    I think you need a new piece of granite so it can be done right. You shouldn't have to adjust for their mistake!

    In theory, I agree ... in reality, I suspect you'd never find an equal to this piece of granite. Since they made the mistake, I'd expect something off the bill.

  • 8 years ago

    C is my vote.

  • 8 years ago

    I love my single handle (which is in the front to the left) because water does not collect on the deck around the faucet from dripping hands, and I am so happy to be done with needing two hands to turn on the water and adjust temp and flow. I use my side sprayer all the time, but I have a large apron front sink.

    https://www.houzz.com/photos/my-pics-work-in-progress-phvw-vp~58831076

  • 8 years ago

    Joseph I messaged you.

  • 8 years ago
    The granite is stunning! May I ask how you found it if it is so rare? I love that you found a one of a kind piece, I wanted something unique for my island and remove the builder installed granite. I hope the installer makes it right and offers a credit or refund of some sort.
    cpartist thanked lshack17
  • 8 years ago

    We went with C, but our faucets have pull-down sprayers. We love having the handle in the front for the aforementioned reasons, and it took no adjustment period at all. I had to do some 'adjusting', as our sinks were scratch 'n dent models, and the drillings weren't what we would have preferred, but I made it work.

    cpartist thanked mushcreek
  • 8 years ago

    I hope that Joseph is a real option for you. This would be a wonderful example of how the GW community comes together to solve a problem.

    cpartist thanked nhbaskets
  • 8 years ago

    I think the single faucet fixture would be less cluttered looking and I prefer it. We have a single lever faucet with the lever facing forward, over the sink. I love that as water drips from my hand stay in the sink. When I am working with raw meat or something I can just use the edge of my hand or wrist to get water running and rinse my hands. Because that clean up sink isn't huge, I would skip the sprayer and put a dish soap pump in that hole. I find that so handy as well. Sorry it didn't go to plan, but it will still look gorgeous, whatever you choose.

    cpartist thanked silken1
  • 8 years ago

    Keeping my fingers crossed Joseph is an option also : )

  • PRO
    8 years ago

    cpartist and I finally met this afternoon. Her top installation seems fine.

  • 8 years ago

    Awesome!!

  • 8 years ago
    last modified: 8 years ago

    Yes a huge thank you to Joseph for alleviating my concerns. I'm so grateful he took the time to look over my counters. My DH and I are looking forward to having him and his wife over once the house is finished as we both found him delightful.

  • 8 years ago

    Fantastic news! Joseph, you're a sweetheart!

    cpartist thanked 2ManyDiversions
  • 8 years ago
    last modified: 8 years ago

    I would definitely go with a single handle. Not even a moment of thought needed for me.

    **edit

    Clearly I missed the resolution, and so nice that Joe was able to fix this for you!

    cpartist thanked Chessie
  • 8 years ago
    last modified: 8 years ago

    Fantastic news! Joseph, you're a sweetheart!

    Yes he is.

    OH I almost forgot. Remember up thread where I said only Joseph or myself would be able to see where they repaired the chip? I was right! Joseph found it almost immediately.

  • 8 years ago

    OK not counter pics, but overall pics of the kitchen with the two over window lights and the window trim finished but not painted. The counters are covered with ram board to protect them. The tile will go up to the hatband that divides the tan from the green.


  • 8 years ago

    Gorgeous!!

    cpartist thanked lisa_a
  • 8 years ago

    cpartist and I finally met this afternoon. Her top installation seems fine.

    What a good ending to a story that began badly!

    Things are coming together nicely! I like your pendant lights.

    cpartist thanked Mrs Pete
  • 8 years ago

    cpartist, those pendants are lovely - I remember when you were choosing your lighting, and it's fun to see them now! What are you sills? They look different than the trim - ?

    cpartist thanked 2ManyDiversions
  • 8 years ago

    I Ike your window pendants, too. And they will look so nice from the outside. Oh no, now I'm thinking about the father in Christmas Story running out to see how the Major Award looks from the street. But, you know, it matters :)

    cpartist thanked bpath
  • 8 years ago

    One word bpathome, FRAGILE.

    fra jeel ay

    cpartist thanked cluelessincolorado
  • 8 years ago

    What are you sills? They look different than the trim - ?

    They are wood. The side trim is a primed wood product. Neither is painted yet.