Software
Houzz Logo Print
mtnrdredux_gw

Bra Shopping Craziness

8 years ago
last modified: 8 years ago

The bras I have in regular rotation are a tad big now and I also want something pretty/fun.

I thought I'd measure myself. I was a little surprised at the online bra size calculator results, so I had DH measure me. He got the same numbers.

So I tried a few more sites.

And no lie, after looking on Soma, Victoria's Secret, Real Simple, Bare Necessities, 3rd Love, Vanity Fair and the Today show (?), I have all different sizes.

They include:

34G (g?!), 36D, 36DD, 36DDD, 38B and 40A and 40DD.

I mean, really, come on.

I don't wanna go to Soma and get measured, because I don't see any bras I really like on their site. Where else can I go?

Comments (95)

  • 8 years ago
    last modified: 8 years ago

    I've been wearing fairly expensive bras such as Wacoal and Natori for years. Once I bought a Third Love bra and it was the worst fit I ever had. I was in Lord & Taylor and in desperation I picked up a fairly inexpensive Warner bra and tried it. It was the best fit ever! I ordered more on line. Maybe try Vanity Fair, Warner etc. You never know.

  • 8 years ago

    For those who say they don't like underwire bras, that was me before finding the right fit, via the one and only brand that works for me (Aubade). It turns out my breasts are wider set then the average- who knew that was a thing.

  • 8 years ago

    Just going to add at the other end, there are places you can send your gently used bras for recycling.

  • 8 years ago
    last modified: 8 years ago

    I don't buy the very expensive bras...I like Bali and they do carry minimizers that seem to work well for me. Check out one hanes place for minimizers.

    What I miss are the ones that had the "no show flowers" in the cup to keep the nips from showing -- great for when I wear t-shirts, but I don't see that they carry them any more. Always happens that as soon as I like a product, they discontinue it!

    Now I see that wacoal makes no-peek concealers that you can slip inside the bra without adding bulk..I'll have to check them out.

  • 8 years ago

    I've always gone to Nordstrom for a fitting (boob sizes do change so once doesn't last a lifetime ;0) ), bought a couple from the helpful fitter, then price shopped elsewhere to add to my inventory. I've actually found I'm the same band and cup size in every name brand I've tried but Spanx. In Spanx, I am one cup size larger, one band size smaller.

    My typical bras are Le Mystere, Wacoal, Chantelle....and all the same size. I don't need a fitting when just changing styles.

  • 8 years ago

    Have not read all the responses but I understand about size differences between brands and even between styles in the same brand. I used to blame my the fact that I could not find a good bra on my larger breasts, had a breast reduction and I still have a incredibly hard time finding a bra. That said even with my reduction I am on the larger size of typical. Part of my problem is that I have a unusually deep sternum which affects fit, but really should not cause the radical size changes. My current bras that fit are a 34D, 34DDD, 36C, 36DD and 36DDD, so while a fitting was a starting point for me sizing is still not consistent. The bras are all Wacoal, Chantelle or Natori purchased at Norstrom (sizing indicated a 36D.). I just wear sports bras around the house, so much easier.

  • 8 years ago

    Gotta go to Wacoal and check out the no-peek concealers! Thanks. I use extra gentle paper medical tape - TMI.

  • 8 years ago

    I keep reading this thread as Braless Crazy Shopping.

    i hate shopping for bras.

  • 8 years ago

    LOL Linelle that sounds like more fun.

  • 8 years ago

    I would go braless if I could. But then I'd be like Phyllis Diller's MIL:

    My MIL complained she had a pain under her left breast...turned out to be a trick knee!

  • 8 years ago

    Oh my, shopping for a bra is the worst. Why do manufacturer's believe that if you have small band size, you must not need a larger cup size ?!?

    Mtn, take a look here:The Bra Lady


  • 8 years ago

    Ah! Arapaho - thanks for that link - There is a Bra Lady in NJ that's not too far.

  • 8 years ago

    Add me to the chorus. I don't think I've ever had a bra that truly fit well, just ones that are less awful :(. For some reason to get straps long enough I have to go up to a band size that is much larger than what I need in a cup size, if that makes sense. So my bras always, always, ALWAYS ride up in back. I seriously do not think there is a bra made that would actually fit me the way they are supposed to. Maybe that can be my retirement gig, looking for a bra that fits right.

  • 8 years ago

    A new bra should be hooked on the loosest row and the band still snug - that way you get a longer ‘bra-life’ period since over time the band elasticity decreases so you move in a row of hooks and then when those are a bit too loose you move in to the last of the rows (unless you have a 4 row with 3 hooks bra like some of mine so you have an extra one to move over to). I see so many ladies start out on the tightest hooks and then the upwards creep toward the shoulder blades begins because they keep adjusting the straps tighter trying to compensate for a too loose band.

    I don’t believe in sister sizing as a means for fitting - it’s more of a last resort and in some stores it’s a way to sell bras in the sizes they carry even if they’re sending women home with some atrocious fitting bras and a loathing for the process of bra shopping that makes them stay in bad bras a long time just to avoid doing it again. Bras and boobs come in all sizes and a range of shapes (bratabase.com and the subreddit abrathatfits are good online resources for info) and the sizes most imagine are gigantic, actually aren’t all that big - a woman with shallow wide breasts with the breast tissue up to almost the collar bone and then extending the tail of Spence under the arm won’t look as large but can wear a DD, F, G or larger. Another woman might have more projected breasts with fullness in the lower or upper portion and wear a J but needs a 32 band because her rib cage is so small. We’ve been conditioned to think a D cup is going to look really big and when we go into the fitting room with a tape measure we discover it’s not that big at all. Bra makers don’t disclose the numbers used in the construction of any given bra style, though the user added data on a bra over at Bratabase.com is the closest to that as we’re going to get. :p

  • 8 years ago

    I can so relate to most of the comments here. I have done and tried most of the suggestions here. I am currently still rotating a stash of probably 10 bras I bought over 5 years ago- happened to be a Playtex bra ( I never had worn playtex before) that was just perfection. Plain cups, underwire, adjustable straps, and came in DDD. I was able to get it at Kohl's online as well as another lingerie site. I was smart enough to order quite a few because this was perfection. Washed fine, held up (still holding up). This bra wears like iron. I noticed about a year or 2 ago that it was no longer made of course. I am so dreading when I need to actually get new bras. It was perfect flex 4718 and when I do a search I learn it was discontinued in January 2014. For a while it was possible to find some on ebay but no longer ( at least not my size). Oh well.

    I have tried Wacoal which everyone used to rave about (yes got fitted at Nordstrom) and didn't think it was all that. I am hoping I will find another one like this but at the rate it's going, I may never need to buy new because as I say these wear like iron.

  • 8 years ago

    runninginplace, see the sister chart above. If you go up a band size, you have to go down a cup letter to keep the cup size the same. That may help you in your quest. So a 36 C cup equals a 38 B cup.

    But if the cups fit properly, I wouldn't think you'd need longer straps. The band size would be more important as 90% of the support comes from the band. Maybe you could, if necessary, get the straps altered to add length if need be.

  • 8 years ago

    Several years ago (probably 10 or more), I read about a French company that periodically came to New York to fit women for custom made bras. The bras were quite pricey, several hundred dollars each, but were supposed to be so comfortable that you would forget you were wearing one. I’ve often dreamed of being fitted for a custom bra. Wonder if the French company still exists?

  • 8 years ago
    last modified: 8 years ago

    There used to be a tv program called Double Divas from Atlanta and they used to make custom bras as well as sell ready made...their store was LiviRae. They would go to women's meetings and gatherings and do bra fittings for the attendees. No idea of the pricing though. I think in one episode they made a bra for the women with the largest breasts in the world...supposedly a 102 ZZZZ! But who knows?

  • 8 years ago

    Annie, they seem to be still going strong although no longer on TV. There may be a trip to Atlanta in my future!


  • 8 years ago

    Whaattt!? Vanity sizing for bras?

    Interesting and annoying that as brick and mortar retail disappears, so does the standardization that would help with our online purchases. So annoying. I want to buy a dozen of everything I actually like to save myself hours of replacement research.

  • 8 years ago

    It's horrid how there's no standardization in women's clothing, especially bras. Years ago, I remember being fitted in Sears and the lady took out two boxed bras (Playtex? Warner's?) of the same size, measured the bands and found an inch difference. An inch! We both double-checked the bra size labels.

    It is no wonder the percentage of women wearing the wrong bra size is so high. The industry makes it so darn difficult to find the right size!

  • 8 years ago

    Even the same bra in the same size from the same manufacturer can fit differently. It's lack of quality control.

  • 8 years ago

    Standardized bra sizing has never existed, companies have kept their design measurements to themselves since bras first existed, and the same goes for individual corsetieres before that. However, when a manufacturer is cutting and assembling a run of bras in a specific size and the order has them doing this for several specific sizes before shipping to a retailer or company that then distributes to a retailer, there are bound to be some deviations in the garments. If the company pulls the ones that can be categorized as ‘seconds’ they will do so and then sell those to stores like marshalls, Ross, or tj maxx. If it’s a retailer they send them back to the company to then sell to overstock and ‘seconds’ retailers. Though they do sell things that they order themselves from manufacturers more often today, these are more cheaply made and they still add ‘seconds’ to the mix - outlets and discounters are the ‘they’ I’m talking about.

  • 8 years ago

    Clothing companies use a lot more stretchy material these days, as well. And the effort to cater to the variation of human bodies is why a 32G in one company’s bra doesn’t fit all those who wear 32G bras. They have to consider tissue distribution measurements of the breast root short/tall, upper/lower/center fullness, torso length and circumference, etc.

  • 8 years ago

    mtnrd, I hope you found your bra by now! I missed your comment before:

    As I understand it, the difference between the measurement under your breasts (ribcage) and at the fullest part of your breasts, determine the cup size. If the delta is 1", you are an A, if 2", B, 3" C, etc etc.

    So let's say you start out with a 38" band and 40" across the fullest for a 2" difference or B cup and you are 38" band size or 38B. Then you lose it in the band, but not in the bust, so you need a 36" band, but you still need the 40" across the fullest, so to get the same cup accommodation, you need a 36 C or even D as the difference is now 4", not 2". Down a band size, up a cup size.

  • 8 years ago

    A blogger that I was reading recommended this. https://shapeez.com/ Look at how you measure for cup size. Of course, it assumes that you have a well-fitting bra.

  • 8 years ago

    Measuring over the bust is a bad idea as that's not where your band is. Better to measure under the bust where the band actually sits...far more accurate a measurement.

  • 8 years ago

    Technically there’s a need for both the underbust and then around the fullest part of the bustline in measurement - one is for the band and the other is for cup size.

  • 8 years ago
    last modified: 8 years ago

    Yes but not overbust...that measures nothing.

  • 8 years ago

    I just bought two bali lace bras-- for me, the bali has always been the right fit for me-- much better than my Wacoal. IME you can try any of a variety of rules for how to measure but nothing is as solid as trying them on.

  • 8 years ago

    I'll chime in here as a representative of the Underendowed Ladies of the World. I had a fitting recently at Victoria's Secret (How come nobody mentioned their bras? Because they cater more toward Making Something of Nothing rather than those who Have Plenty?) and turns out I should be wearing a 34D! A D??!! Me, who sported mosquito bites on my chest until I had my first child?

    I think this is a vanity sizing issue. No way these boobs are D's. But the VS 34D does fit.

  • 8 years ago

    Depending on the company who makes the bra you have to find a store that sells them in your size. I have three choices for mine: Nordstrom, bra boutique, or online. Online is the least expensive but I have to have figured out my size in a given bra style first.

  • 8 years ago

    Littlebug, it is DEFINITELY a vanity sizing issue! Victoria's Secret is the worst offender. I used to be able to buy bras there on occasion by going up one cup and/or one band size from the size that I typically take in mainstream brands like Bali, Wacoal, Playtex, etc. Since I usually wear a DD, I was always on the big end of the sizes they carry but every now and again they'd come out with a style in DDD that I could wear. NO MORE. Sometime in the last ten years, they went completely nuts with the vanity sizing and now I can't get half a boob into one of their DDDs. I have friends who are completely flat chested and complain about it constantly, yet claim to wear a C cup simply because Victoria's Secret tells them they do. I'm sure it helps VS sell more bras but it surely is frustrating for consumers who just want to know what size to buy!

  • 8 years ago
    last modified: 8 years ago

    Yep, and that vanity sizing also explains why a 6-8 hr flight from Europe to the US makes your boobs expand by about 2 cup sizes. (Not pressurized air or airline food.)

    While we're at it, babies are double the size in the US, and butts in jeans are half the size. So you buy at least a 24 months size for a 1-year old, and size 34 inches jeans aren't really 34 inches.

  • 8 years ago

    Can someone explain to me the claim that most of the bra's support comes from the band? That makes no sense to me.

  • 8 years ago

    The straps need to be anchored to the band, otherwise there would be no support.

  • 8 years ago

    Most of the support -- 90% should come from the band. Only 10% should come from the straps. It's why you can have something like a strapless bra. If too much support is coming from the straps, then they will dig into your shoulders and cause irritation. If the band is too large and not providing the proper support then the straps will actually cause the bra to ride up in the back and the front to sag. That will lead to "back fat" and discomfort under the arms, esp if you have underwires. The band should be comfortable yet firm and if you let the shoulder straps loose, you should still be well supported. The straps will help hold the upper part of the cup in place. A proper fitting band should be parallel with the floor when looked at from the side and not ride up.

  • 8 years ago

    After reading reviews saying how comfortable a Playtex 18-hour bra is, I bought one last week. Yes, it is very comfortable. But it does nothing to enhance the girls. The one I bought is pretty basic, no underwire and not even a whiff of padding, although it does have a double lined cup for modesty. It will be good for vacation where I need a bra that I can rinse out in the hotel sink and have it dry overnight. I doubt that I will buy more.

  • 8 years ago

    Thank you Rita and Annie. I still don't believe the band provides much support or lift to the breasts. I was looking at the videos for the UpBra mentioned above and that seems to adjust the cups for lift and support and that, to me, makes more sense. There's no way a band under my breasts, no matter how perfectly snug, is doing anything for them.

  • 8 years ago

    suzmtl, the vast majority of women wear bras with bands too loose and cups too small, so no wonder they need to rely on straps to get any lift. But as the pic above indicates, it really undoes the proper lift because all a tighter strap does is pull up the back of the bra where it becomes more uncomfortable, allows the front to sag even more, and puts more strain on your shoulders which can lead to neck and shoulder pain. The support comes from the width and shape of the band and the integration of the cups into the band including the structure on the sides under the arms and the bridge in the middle.

    All I can suggest is go to a good bra store and try some on, even with cups larger than you think and bands smaller than you think. If you get a bra that fits properly, you will know the difference right away and it will feel so much better. And you will see and feel for yourself how much support comes from a proper band fit.

  • 8 years ago

    I have a band issue. My band size is 28" and C/D cup size. I can get away with a 32D for everyday bras but sports bras are a nightmare! I am an avid runner and most sports bra bands are too big and they rub at the band because they are too loose. I usually end up with bloody slash marks at the band after long runs or races. :(

  • 8 years ago

    I would think about taking the bra to a tailor to see if she can't take it in for a better fit.

  • 8 years ago

    I have found a few local places that measure, and that is on my to-do list. Before we left on vacation, we did the traditional new pantie run at Kohls (people talk of disappearing socks, but I am forever buying girls underwear). Anyway, while there I bought two bras, one with a convertible back. I like them both.

    But I will tell you why women are wearing the wrong size bra. It is because I did not see many sizes at all. They are mostly C and D, a few DD. If most people are wearing too large a band and too small a cup, that is why. The range of offerings is narrow.

  • 8 years ago

    I agree mtnrd -- the selection can be terrible in so many ways.

  • 8 years ago
    last modified: 8 years ago

    Caroline, my favorite bras right now are from the Fit Fully Yours line. FWIW, I see they have a sports bra available in a 28D.

    http://www.fitfullyyours.com/?p=568

  • 8 years ago

    Thank you for that site! I am a teensy bit hesitant to try something with underwire for running for that long but I will try it. The tailor suggestion is a good one too!

  • 8 years ago
    last modified: 8 years ago

    I have heavy breasts and have struggled with bra shopping for years (anywhere from 34-36 DD-E). My issues were always neck and shoulder discomfort. I was introduced to the Fit Fully Yours line after a custom fitting at a specialty lingerie boutique that I had to drive 2 hours to get to (I live in the boonies). I was a bit skeptical because I'd never even heard tell of Fit Fully Yours before, and they're not cheap, but I bought one that day. Then I went back a few months later and bought another. Turned out to be the best thing I've ever done. I haven't worn another brand since, but I have no personal experience with their sports bra. (I wear the Maxine Moulded which says it is 'engineered for women with heavy breasts'... maybe that's mainly just marketing hoopla... but it's worked for me!)

  • 8 years ago
    last modified: 8 years ago

    The way that ‘sister sizing’ bras bothers me most is that it keeps perpetuating a problem that the very real population who needs a better fit but spends on a poor one is how manufacturers interpret the data as - not enough in the small band large cup demographic to make it worthwhile.

  • 8 years ago

    I also wish that there was more available in my size range (30H, 32G/GG) that cost less, that there was a larger number of bra manufacturers whose styles weren’t more of the endless racks of the t-shirt variety. I don’t buy VS, they have a horrendous way of measuring so that they can convince a shopper to buy with the VS name cachet, their stock sizes and recent releases indicate they aren’t going to even bother trying to accommodate the non-matrix sizes nor are they likely to improve on quality when ‘disposable’ goods are sold cheaply in stores and that manufacturers who supply them still find it profitable to do so.