What are timeless kitchen choices?
Getting started on planning a kitchen renovation. I don't want to create a kitchen that will look dated in 10 years... But I find I can't even tell what a trend is!
Any tips on timeless choices for a kitchen?
(I also would like it to look high-end, but I guess that's out if I'm not going for a modern trendy kitchen!)
Here are my guesses:
* Avoiding slab/flat panel cabinets, avoiding shaker style cabinets
* Avoiding painted cabinets
* Going for natural wood stain cabinets on a vertical grain (cherry or maple)
* Going for an undermount sink instead of the new farmhouse sinks
* Going for regular neutral square tile instead of tile that looks like wood
* Avoiding narrow horizontal tile backsplash
* Avoiding dark countertops
* Going for square edge countertops even though it's a modern trend (just can't predict what direction countertop edging will take?!)
* Avoiding long narrow hardware
Thank you!
Comments (58)
- 8 years ago
I dunno. If you look at pictures of kitchens in the early 1900s, you will see a lot of Shaker, slab, and painted cabinets - all popular then and popular now (except for the 1970s-1980s when raised panels seemed to be the most popular).
- 8 years agolast modified: 8 years ago
Everything is timeless as long as it has not been labeled a fad, like avocado appliances! From my experience, and its been a long one since the 80's, things come and go and come back. Just like the stock market. Take white wash oak cabinets, their back! Yikes! There may be a variation on the theme but I see this trend back on the scene. So the moral of the story is do what you want and don't worry about it.
Related Professionals
Tyler Interior Designers & Decorators · Carbondale Architects & Building Designers · Newark Architects & Building Designers · Eau Claire Architects & Building Designers · Cape Coral Kitchen & Bathroom Designers · Lake City Kitchen & Bathroom Designers · Petersburg Kitchen & Bathroom Designers · Dubuque Kitchen & Bathroom Designers · Bloomington Kitchen & Bathroom Designers · New York City Kitchen & Bathroom Designers · Green Bay Kitchen & Bathroom Designers · Huntington Kitchen & Bathroom Designers · Canton Kitchen & Bathroom Designers · Kalispell Kitchen & Bathroom Designers · Killeen Custom Countertops- 8 years ago
Yes, do what you want - but do it well - do it thoughtfully. Make choices based on what looks good within the context of your house, your lifestyle and your taste. Of course you will be influenced by all the things manufacturers and media expose you to repeatedly, so think twice before adopting anything you see on TV or at Home Depot (which is not to say you should nix anything that is popular- just think about how to adapt the look and make it excellent and your own.)
- 8 years agolast modified: 8 years ago
What does your home tell you is appropriate to it’s style? A cute California Bungalow would look silly with formal cherry raised panel cabinets. But they would be perfect for a traditional Southern Greek Revival with lots of heirloom wood trim and furniture.
Also, if it’s available at the box stores, on the shelf, it’s jumped the shark. That’s how you know the white shaker and shiplap are done with. Every Lowes in the country has the trends. Go shopping there. Avoid anything you can buy off the shelf that they sell.
- 8 years ago
There are several trends I suspect will not age well: mandatory island; said island a different color than perimeter cabinets; different stone on said island; counter seating at said island.
Older kitchens generally have the same cabinets and countertops throughout, with the exception of a butcher block or maybe marble baking area. And they often have a kitchen table, which I suspect may come back, when people tire of sitting on bar stools.
We’ll see.
- 8 years ago
latifolia...I am already tired of sitting on bar stools. They are a nuisance for short people to get on/off. Some seniors also have problems with sitting on them.
- 8 years ago
I think kitchen tables are definitely on their way back in. I certainly wish I had one.
- 8 years agolast modified: 8 years ago
I think you need to focus on things you ENJOY rather than worrying about what is or is not timeless. If it is something you enjoy, and it suits the home as a whole, "time" does not matter. I would not want to walk into a charming little house built in 1901 and find a very modern and stark kitchen, just as I would not want to walk into a house with a very modern and stark exterior and find a very traditional kitchen.
Besides, many of the things you cite to avoid as not being timeless, are things that others would consider very timeless because they have stood the test of time, like farmhouse sinks, painted cabinets, and shaker cabinets.
I for example, consider maple and cherry cabinets to be, not dated since I am not fond of that word, but very "reminiscent" of a certain period(s) where they were more trendy during my lifetime and do not consider them "timeless". Fortunately not everyone would agree with me, and that is what makes life (and our homes) interesting.
- 8 years agolast modified: 8 years ago
Visuals (and their transmission) have morphed to speed of light. Nobody has a crystal ball. Do what appeals TO YOU, when you make an idea book on Houzz or google.. Keep loving the same kitchen style over and over? Ask yourself what you love. Then get a KD, to help plan it for function, and visual appeal...within the context of the rest of your home, and your budget. "A high end" look is a function of a high end budget, usually. Appliances, inset doors, quality finishing etc. and no matter if very modern, or very traditionally styled. Simple luxury will almost always outlast a "to the manor born gee gaw" look. Unless you live in the manor. Keep it appropriate to the house. And get PRO help on site.
- 8 years ago
What kitchen choices are timeless? Only time will tell.
No one has a crystal ball, and unless you're planning turn around and sell right after your reno, do what YOU want and like, and fits your life. Do it well and with quality, but don't let anyone else's choices of what's fashionable (now or in the future) decide what you'd like. - 8 years agolast modified: 8 years ago
(except for the 1970s-1980s when raised panels seemed to be the most popular).
Shaker was out from 1930 on till it had a revival about fifteen years ago. Slab doors were the thing during most of that time, followed by raised panel. I'm not saying people didn't like what would come to be called "shaker" during the 90s, but it wasn't a fashionable choice and was hard to find in stock cabinets.
Farmhouse sinks were common in Britain, but they were pretty much unknown in the US till about fifteen years ago, at least in kitchens.
- 8 years ago
At the advent of kitchen cabinets (previously it had been furniture pieces) "hygiene" was a big thing and white was the dominant color. White will always be timeless. Shaker style has and always will be timeless, mostly because it is generally less expensive than raised panel and that appeals to the masses. You'll always be timeless if you do white-painted shaker style. But YOU DO YOU! What do you love, what will make you smile when you turn the light on in the morning? What do you want? Unless you're selling in the next five years, I wouldn't worry about being "on-trend" (God, I hate that word!)
- 8 years ago
latifolia, I agree about the island that is a different color than the perimeter cabinets. I also think that gray kitchen cabinets are a trend.
- 8 years agolast modified: 8 years ago
A trend is different than "trendy" and different from a fad. A white kitchen has been a trend, because hardwood flooring ( entire floor of a home) has been an even larger trend for more than a decade.
Gray wood floors are a fad. So are your bare shoulders poking through cashmere turtlenecks in January. But cashmere , once the domain of only the wealthy is as common as cotton in summer!. Also not going anywhere soon!
Open reclaimed shelves, linear fire boxes?! Trendy , trend , in that order....... mostly due to the sizes of flat screen tv's and our desire to see fire and tv simultaneously.
Also: please cease the use of the word "pop" . I beg you lol.... that just might be the biggest fad.
- 8 years ago
I saw apron front sinks, aka farmhouse sinks or Belfast sinks back in the 80s. Could Martha have had one? Between how well this kind of sink functions and how attractive many people find it, I don't see it going anywhere any time soon - especially since there are lovely stainless versions allowing the look in a greater variety of kitchens.
- 8 years agolast modified: 8 years ago
These lists of what is timeless or not are such a waste of time. And the posts with these lists seem to pop up over and over again. I figure it’s to try to glean comfort when you’re about to spend tens of thousands. In any case, the advice already given above is good.
BTW, the Downton Abbey kitchen had painted cabinets and apron front sinks (what you called “the new farmhouse sinks”). Soapstone (a “dark countertop”) has been used for a hundred years. Give up on the list-making.
- 8 years ago
"BTW, the Downton Abbey kitchen had painted cabinets and apron front
sinks (what you called “the new farmhouse sinks”). Soapstone (a “dark
countertop”) has been used for a hundred years."I'm not sure what that has to do with anything, since the fact that something isn't new doesn't mean it's timeless, because it might mean its appeal simply waxes and wanes. But, still, I agree that looking for "timeless" is fruitless and misses the point of a reno, which is to create something that is better for you, not for matching a fashion or trend.
- 8 years agolast modified: 8 years ago
I'm not sure what that has to do with anything, since the fact that something isn't new doesn't mean it's timeless, because it might mean its appeal simply waxes and wanes.
Toronto Veterinarian - I notice your posts are often pedantic. That’s a good thing in a veterinarian, but doesn’t add value here other than the good feeling you get when writing them. You pointed out the shortcoming in my post, I’ll point out yours.
I said what I said about Downton Abbey because the OP gave the impression she thought painted cabinets and apron front sinks were not lasting kitchen features. Evidently not as exactingly accurate and precise as you’d like.
- 8 years agolast modified: 8 years ago
latifolia and day2day make good points- sitting at a counter isn't comfortable if you are older. In addition, if you have any back problems it isn't comfortable, and standing to work at an island for any length of time isn't too grand either. Not that kitchens shouldn't have islands if people want them, but there is something to be said for a proper kitchen table to eat at, and to shell the peas at too. And if you've spent years training your children to wait to pick up their utensils until the adults have been seated, why would you have them eat at a counter as if at a luncheonette with the adult at the stove like a short-order cook?
I love soapstone, it makes me nostalgic for years of science lab, and I love quilted stainless backsplashes behind the stove top, they remind me of those old-timey diners. Too much stainless steel and it looks like a morgue.
Well, we all like different things and have different needs.
And maybe we are all a bit pedantic. Because here we all are, busily typing at perfect strangers, offering up what we think we know.
Sheesh, that borders on introspection, time for a jolt of joe!
- 8 years ago
" I notice your posts are often pedantic."
I prefer to think of myself as often literal. Words have meaning. I expect people to mean what they say, not what they wanted to say or thought they said. And without the benefits of past knowledge (i.e. talking to strangers) and body language, it's even more important.
- 8 years agolast modified: 8 years ago
Nothing is timeless unless you make it and continue to be happy with your choices and do not try to keep up with trends that come and go and opinions from others that make you doubt your own taste, but in time even that changes like everything else that surrounds us. keeping up with the Jones was never my desire, I have purchased what I like and what works for my lifestyle and my budget.
- 8 years ago
I think the different color island than the perimeter is a new concept because kitchens are bigger now and part of entertaining. While in a smaller, older kitchen there would be no need for different colors, in a bigger kitchen with two large islands one color/type of counter may be too much of a good thing. So I would say it is not necessarily a trend but a function of new kitchen space. As long as kitchens stay large I don't see it going away.
- 8 years agolast modified: 8 years ago
Toronto Veterinarian - I googled the definition of timeless - in order to be certain not to say anything that you would think is not exactly correct. “Timeless” means “not affected by the passage of time or changes in fashion“. Since you think of yourself as literal, you should have advised that the only way to fulfill the literal meaning of timeless is to have only a fire pit and a rudimentary pot, since every other thing in a kitchen, down to the smallest detail, will change with the passage of time.
“I expect people to mean what they say, not what they wanted to say or thought they said”. Wow, you got all that judgement by my one comment about Downton Abbey.
- 8 years ago
"Wow, you got all that judgement by my one comment about Downton Abbey."
Good heavens no! I got all that judgement from your post judging me as pedantic!
- 8 years agolast modified: 8 years ago
"...the posts with these lists seem to pop up over and over again."
Yep, they do. Here are search results for threads discussing "timeless" kitchen elements.
I'm curious to know the reason behind your question, Summer.
Is it because you're about to spend lots of $$$ and you're worried about your choices and whether you're spending wisely?
As others have stated above, do what makes you happy, taking into account what's appropriate to your home's architectural style. Make it functional for how you use your kitchen. Plan your storage well. Choose function first and form will follow.
Kitchen remodeling is stressful (I lost 20 pounds in the process, I don't recommend that!) and the majority of us second guess every decision, not matter how thoroughly and carefully we considered each choice. We hyperfocus on every little thing when we're in the midst of the process. (How could my DH not understand that my Obsession Du Jour wasn't a crisis of epic proportion?)
Fast forward a few months and we realize that those things weren't catastrophic, end-of-the-world issues. Sure, there may be things we wish we'd done differently, but in the grand scheme of things, we're glad we remodeled.
Is it because you're planning to sell in the near future and you want to appeal to buyers?
You can do your best to meet that goal but there's no guarantee that your choices will appeal to everyone. Two new neighbors redid the recently remodeled kitchens (ala current style preferences) to suit their personal tastes. My new next door neighbors aren't doing more than changing cabinet hardware (polished brass) and counters (4 x 4 white tile) in a 23 yr old kitchen with white, raised panel, partial overlay cabinets. Go figure.
If you tell us more about why you're asking, we can do our best to help you find your answers.
- 8 years agolast modified: 8 years ago
Kitchen remodeling is stressful (I lost 20 pounds in the process)
I need then to start remodeling immediately.
- 8 years ago
I think people become concerned about "timelessness" because they interior styles changing and churning faster than in years past. Avocado lasted a lot longer than Tuscan, for example. And while, do what makes you happy, makes a great sound bite, it's a lot tougher when you are faced with a dizzying array of limited choices. In other words there are thousands of faucets, but only a dozen actual choices in style/shape. Gray might me on it's way out, but you will be looking at a ton of very nicely put together gray examples everywhere from Houzz to Home Depot and Waterworks, so how to make sure you choose something that looks good, suits your space and is not just the latest trend becomes harder to parse for people who are not immersed in design, like some of the good folks here.
- 8 years ago
Lisa, it is so funny you say that, because I did not feel our kitchen remodel was that stressful. I had a plan and the GC, cabinet maker, husband and family were all on board. I had been planning this for years. I had magazine pictures from the 80's of kitchens that I like. When I met with the GC and cabinet maker, I had all of my choices made.
The stressful parts were the basement flooding during the kitchen remodel....sump pump died!! And the cabinet maker's father got sick and subsequently died. That was a long 4 weeks. But, its not like he was blowing me off, so I did not stress. I am sorry to say I gained weight because of all of the take out food.
Is my kitchen timeless?? I don't really care!! I don't think it is trendy but it has trends in it. I just know that when I walk into my kitchen, it takes my break away!!!
- 8 years ago
"so how to make sure you choose something that looks good, suits your
space and is not just the latest trend becomes harder to parse for
people who are not immersed in design, like some of the good folks here."I think what most people are saying is that it doesn't matter whether or not it's the latest trend, as long as you're choosing it for the right reasons (i.e. it suites your aesthetic, use/function, and budget). If what you really like is a kitchen that looks like a European bistro, who cares if that's a trend now or will be trendy in 10 years?
- 8 years ago
To Rita and others who say gray is a trend. I agree but I think it is a trend with staying power. It's a neutral, which is much easier to match and doesn't stand out like Kraftmaid's Cardinal red.
In terms of the apron sinks, manufacturing is one of the things that drives choices. As long as the apron sink is available a section of the market will buy it. As long as a section of the market will buy it, it will be available. I don't see that going away, especially since you can get apron sinks in stainless for a contemporary setting.
Black stainless appliances on the other hand...
- 8 years ago
Carolina, you are absolutely right. Grey can be done in a perfectly timeless fashion. Anglophilia here has a grey kitchen that is a perfect example of using that color in a timeless way- the color suits her kitchen and her space. None of her other choices were trendy and her kitchen looks like a million bucks. Anything can look good or bad depending on the skill of the person wielding it.
- 8 years ago
Totally agree about gray having staying power. It is a neutral that works well in contemporary and traditional spaces. I always pause when I see comments that gray is dated already. Hard to believe, when such a huge percentage of the photos on Houzz with beautiful, timeless rooms continue to have gray. To me it is like saying white or beige is dated. I think any color that works with your house (cabinets, counters, etc.) is what you should pick.
I do agree that gray wood floors have a higher chance of becoming dated and that a safer choice for such a huge investment is a more traditional color. However, brown stain with a touch of gray to me is still timeless, it just reduces the orange/red color that some people want to avoid.
- 8 years ago
When folks say, "Who cares if that's a trend now, or will be in ten years?"
I think that the person asking the question is the one who cares. There are two issues at play for me.
One, am I the kind of person who would be upset if I designed a kitchen today and found it cringe-worthy in 10 years because I had unwittingly made choices that looked shabby in the future present?
Yes, I am that sort of person. I do not wear terribly trendy clothes, much the less want trendy furnishings. The tricky part is that with furnishings I am not an experienced furnishings buyer. I have been selecting my own clothes since I was in middle school and learning from my mistakes. Most people do not have that level of experience in making interior design choices, so they are not as capable of executing well. And they have the self knowledge to know these things about themselves.
The second issue is a budget one. If I am the kind of person who fears having a kitchen I am unhappy with in 10 years time, do I have the budget to redress the problem. For me, historically the answer was, no. Now I can afford to make a mistake or two and I take that into account when making my choices. For example, I have chosen Shaw's sink. Ten years ago, I would not have made that decision for fear of it chipping or cracking. Now, I can accept the fact that my sink may not hold up as well and I can afford to pay to buy a new stainless version and have it replaced. Some people may be able to afford bigger mistakes. (My sink is holding up well, btw :-)
- 8 years ago
"When folks say, "Who cares if that's a trend now, or will be in ten years?"
I think that the person asking the question is the one who cares. "
Yes, but when people ask that question it's their rhetorical way of saying "you shouldn't care". Especially when that person cares about something they can only guess at and nobody knows. If someone told me it was important for them to know what the weather was going to be in 10 years, or who was going win the Superbowl in 10 years, or what was going to lead ladies fashion in 10 years, I would say "don't worry about such things because no one can know. Dress for the weather today, root for the team you like best, and wear what you think fits and flatters.."
- 8 years ago
Right, Toronto, and my rhetorical point was it's not helpful to dismiss people's concerns by saying, who cares.
Plus I think you hit the nail on the head with : Wear what you think fits and flatters.
When I was in seventh grade and my mother let choose my own clothes, I was clueless as to what flattered me (I probably was sketchy on what fit properly too.) It took trial and error to learn about fit and flatter.
- 8 years ago
"French gray" has been around for centuries. Live!!!!!! The guarantee on the lack of a time and date stamp on any design ? Not possible. ....
Meanwhile.....time just ticks. Jackie Onassis knew one thing .So did Coco Chanel. Style is forever. :)
- 8 years ago
"don't worry about such things because no one can know. Dress for the weather today, root for the team you like best, and wear what you think fits and flatters.."
Toronto Vet, I wish houzz had a heart button or maybe applauding hands. Great advice!
- 8 years ago
I don't think any design or decorating is timeless. As hard as you try, things will date and age, it's inevitable so I wouldn't waste time focused on that. The most important thing to consider in any renovation of a space is .... all of the rest of the space. In other words, whatever room you upgrade it still needs to coincide with the rest of the house. You want to stick within the same style. So with that being the biggest mistake to avoid, next I would say .... avoid the heavy hitter trends. Understanding to some degree that's a matter of opinion, IMO i wouldn't do gray, farm house sinks, gold fixtures/hardware, all white. Lastly, steer clear of things that are already dated. Again, IMO, I wouldn't do cherry or maple cabinets, busy granite patterns, glass tile backsplashes.
- 8 years agoMake sure the kitchen fits with the house. Therefore a super modern kitchen in a Victorian will look off & dated sooner. That said you do not have to put a Victorian kitchen in a Victorian home but you will want to pay homage in terms of design so that your kitchen fits. The same thing holds true about putting a super traditional kitchen into a mid century modern home. Again, good materials coupled with great design/function always retain and remain timeless longer than poorly planned.
- 8 years ago
Love this quote by Nate Berkus "My rule of thumb is that if it looks like it could have been there in 1920, it's a safe bet for a kitchen." Frankly, many of today's kitchen trends are reminiscent of the 20's. Painted wood, "farmhouse"... They are popular but also timeless. Although most important is what style makes sense in your home and what finishes make you happy. We can also overthink timeless only to end up with something we don't like now and forever.
Serendipity M
Original Author8 years agoPhew... I'm the original poster and I'm so grateful for all the responses. I read through them and I must admit-- I'm pretty confused now! the current plan is to go for traditional style instead of contemporary, to match the rest of the house. as for all the details, I have no idea... the reason I wanted it timeless is because we are planning to sell in around 15 years and I don't want to have to remodel again at that time. but hey, no one can predict the future! we personally don't have strong preferences for a kitchen so the design doesn't matter to us, we'd rather go for what we guess may be sellable.- 8 years ago
the reason I wanted it timeless is because we are planning to sell in around 15 years and I don't want to have to remodel again at that time.
It's an appealing idea, but the sad fact of the matter is that no matter what you do now, in 15 years it will be just another middle-aged/old kitchen. Don't worry about that, and for sure don't spend any money today with the idea that you'll get back 15 years from now.
- 8 years ago
If you can guess 15 years out, if a designer could, if ANYONE could? Count on this: Your appliances will be fifteen years old, as will the rest. A lot can happen in fifteen years, that may have nothing to do with design but with life.. Get a KD, do a kitchen that suits the house, and you shall be her dream or nightmare, since you have no preferences one way or the other
- 8 years ago
Odds are that, when you come to sell in 15 years time, it won't be your kitchen that sells your house. It is going to look 15 years old, no matter what you do. (It never makes economic sense to remodel a kitchen just for sale, so that's not really the issue). Instead, focus on getting the layout right (a good layout really is timeless), get decent quality cabinetry and appliances, and install plenty of lighting. And make sure the kitchen fits stylistically with the rest of the house (you don't want it to look like it dropped in from Mars, as Sophie would say). Those are things that, if not timeless, will at least stand up better than fads.
- 8 years agolast modified: 8 years ago
There are frequent posts on this forum of people saying "we know we will be moving in 5 years", and asking for advice with that time horizon in mind. But 15 years - it's just a fact of life that your kitchen (anyone's) will look to be from around 2018, no matter what choices you make today. It will not look 2033, or even 2028. (think about how 15 years ago there weren't smart phones in use everywhere - see how things change?)
Also, your appliances will give out before then. Sadly, appliances today last 7-8 years. A few years ago you could say appliances last at least 10 years, and, a few years before that, the expectation was 15-20 years. With that in mind, be careful about building in a fridge, a microwave, or choosing a cooktop, because we've seen sizes of those particular appliances change over the years, and people complain they can't find replacements to fit. Dishwashers, wall ovens, ranges, and rangetops do stay consistent in size.
- 8 years ago
Better design lasts. Ephemeral decor does not. http://starcraftcustombuilders.com/kitchen.design.rules.htm#.Wrj8fn9OnYU













Diana Bier Interiors, LLC