Of the two, I prefer autumn yellow. Heritage cream is a bit lemon-y for my taste--already looks faded out.

Thanks!

Hi -- on a previous house that we had built, we went with Certainteed Desert Tan. I wanted a pale yellow color that wasn't too bright. I loved the color, since it was subtle and looked great throughout the day as the sun hit it. I could only locate a couple photos, so I hope this will help.