Software
Houzz Logo Print

The instructions say 1 1/4 cup per month per mature plant.

Does anyone use this exclusively and have good results.

Seems like a variety of foods would be more beneficial

Comments (8)

  • 8 years ago

    David- most here love Rosetone. Another one is Tomatotone if you can find it which has a bit more potassium and a bit less nitrogen. Each have different trace minerals. I know some alternate between the two. I'm very lax at fertilizing and still a bit green behind the ears. One amendment that I have found to make a huge difference is mycorrhizae fungus which helps with root development. I use this on all of my roses and the difference in root growth is really noticeable. Paul Zimmeran, rose expert and former nursery owner, recommends this amendment for all your roses.

    sharon

  • 8 years ago

    "Seems like a variety of foods would be more beneficial"

    Can you explain why you think this?

  • 8 years ago

    David, I have used Rosetone for years, and like it a lot. But its quite expensive, so this year I am trying the less expensive FlowerTone and GardenTone. We'll see if my roses like these as much! I also highly, highly recommend adding alfalfa meal. Its very inexpensive and I know nothing better for encouraging basal breaks. I'm afraid I'm not at all generous about fertilizing - my roses get their dose of fertilizer (the "tone" plus alfalfa and sometimes a little epsom salts for the weaklings) in the spring and then that's it. I have too many roses and it would just be way too expensive to fertilize monthly. In general, I'm very happy with how my roses do on this regime, they all flower well and frequently for me (well, the repeat bloomers). However, my memory is you grow HTs, which I don't really much grow, so they may have very different needs from my roses. My soil is pretty good, and I do add as much organic stuff as I can, so I think that helps make up for my stinginess re: fertilizer.

    Enchantedroses - I am intrigued but confused about mycorrhizae fungus. In many places, I have read that these are recommended, but almost as many other sources say that unless your soil is very very bad and sterile, its a waste of time and money because your soil already has these fungii. Could you explain how you used them (only at planting time, or as an amendment each year?) Also, you say the difference in root growth was noticeable. Did you do a comparison-type experiment, or is that more of a general impression? I'd love to hear any and all opinions about this issue, particularly from those with a more scientific perspective than mine (which would be practically anybody, lol!) Thanks in advance!

  • 8 years ago
    last modified: 8 years ago

    David: Rosetone is "a variety of foods" (including alfalfa meal, I believe, frances).

    frances: I have mentioned here before that Hollytone is regularly $15 for 27 lbs at Costco (starts appearing on shelves probably early March in NJ), and typically is rediuced to $10 to clear out stock (early May, probably, here in NJ). Several posters here, including a consulting rosarian, have stated they use it interchangeably w/Rosetone for roses.

    Tractor supply in NJ has 50 lb alfalfa pellets for $14.

  • 8 years ago
    last modified: 8 years ago

    There wasn't any Rosetone on the shelf whennI was going to plant do I grabbed some of the "Knockout Rose" fertilizer. The price was decent and anything that can feed something with the continual growth and bloom of a Knockout should be good. It has microbes in it too..

  • 8 years ago

    My rose mentors always said, "roses can't read" when it comes to fertilizers. "Variety" doesn't matter to plants, the fertilizers break down into the elements that plants take up. The reason why many of us use dry organic fertilizers is that they help to add organic material to the soil while they are decomposing. I primarily use Holly-tone and occasionally fish emulsion.

  • 8 years ago

    For NPK components: rosetone 4/3/2; plantone 5/3/3; hollytone 4/3/4 and tomato tone 3/4/6. Each type of "tone" have magnesium, calcium and sulfur, plus the same beneficial bacteria. In Hollytone, there is more sulfur than the other "tone" (at 5% contrast to 2% in rosetone), thus Hollytone can acidify your soil if that's necessary.

    I wonder if a soil test may help to individualize fertilization need. For example I just got my soil test, which showed alkaline pH of 7.7, excessive of phosphorus (5 x over the upper limit!), excess of K (3 x over the upper limit), bordeline nitrate, and basicially all other elements are over the upper limits or within normal. The soil test recommends only supplementation with nitrogen. Therefore, I regret a bit that I gave the roses bone meal this spring, as bone meal is full of phosphorus but little nitrogen or potassium. In retrospective rosetone will work OK, or Hollytone because my soil is alkaline.

    Also I wonder if the season matters. In the spring when vegetative growth is required, higher nitrogen is necessary, but once the roses are blooming, may be K is more important. Phosphorus is important for blooming but I don't think you need a lot of it. Also Phosphorus and potassium takes a while to get down to the soil if the fertilizer are slow release and are put on top.