Software
Houzz Logo Print
gameangel64

What to do with these cabinets?

8 years ago



This is the kitchen of the house we just bought. I have a feeling these cabinets might be original to when the house was built in the 70s, but I actually don't hate the color or general style. I will surely want to change the pulls/knobs, which is easy enough. What is not so easy to fix is the giant crack in one of the doors and some bleach staining on two cabinets (that you cannot see thanks the fridge being in the way). I also am not a fan of the built in cutting board, and there are two tiny drawers that I would prefer as one large drawer instead.


That said, we are doing a lot of renovations and I am not sure if we can make peace with the expense of pulling out and replacing the cabinets too, especially since I expect the footprint of the kitchen to remain basically the same. Another complication is that we want to replace the tile and paint the walls, but my contractors have advised that they shouldn't do that work until the kitchen is sorted out... so if it takes 6-8 weeks to replace the cabinets, I wouldn't be able to start the other major work until then - meaning we won't be able to move in as soon as we wanted.


What would you do with these cabinets? Replace? Reface? Something else? I have so many projects going on at once right now and I am feeling overwhelmed. Thank you for your counsel!

Comments (20)

  • 8 years ago
    last modified: 8 years ago

    If you are happy with the basic layout of the kitchen you should reface them. Way less expensive and can be done after you paint and replace your floors since you will not be pulling them out.

    Adding a pretty backsplash would be nice!

    Elana thanked Jamie Ludwig
  • 8 years ago

    Thanks, I am planning to add a backsplash, new appliances, and light fixture. Maybe an island. Was hoping to save on changing the cabinets, since that is so expensive.

  • 8 years ago

    You could look into buying new doors.

    Elana thanked mark_rachel
  • 8 years ago
    Take the cracked door to a cabinet person to see if it can be repaired. Maybe the bleached spots will take some stain. The cabinet person may be able to take care of both issues. If I were to suggest any improvement to the kitchen, it would be to replace the tile grout with new grout which matches the tile, or to replace the flooring. The tile/grout combination looks older than the kitchen.
    Elana thanked felizlady
  • 8 years ago

    Yup, we are definitely replacing the flooring! Tile has already been purchased and scheduled for installation. :) We also plan to paint and update the stove and dishwasher for sure.

  • 8 years ago

    I have a suggestion if you decide to reface the cabinets that will give your kitchen a very current look. Remove the upper cabinets over the sink and around the stove. Then put in a stainless steel vent hood over the stove.

    Elana thanked Jamie Ludwig
  • 8 years ago

    My mom had a few wood cabinets with some damage to the finish from water. A refinisher was able to strip and refinish the doors so they match the originals. This was several years ago and I still cannot tell the older from the refinished. I changed out a few things in my kitchen and did the same - stained the new to match the old, and I am very happy with how things came out.

    This will also depend on your budget, and the how you feel is the quality of the older cabinets. They look very pretty in the picture, but we cannot see close up or check out the construction.

    My wood cabinets are not as dark, but I did change out countertops / backsplash and added an apron front sink. I am very happy with the refresh - pics in my my pics idea book.

    Here is another older refreshed kitchen with darker wood cabinets which I think came out very well - just some ideas:

    https://www.houzz.com/discussions/finally-finished-with-kitchen-updating-dsvw-vd~4512247

    Elana thanked jhmarie
  • PRO
    8 years ago
    I’d do the minimum. Wall Paint, hardware, light fixture for now.
    Live with it a bit and then decide. The space is large enough that you may want to completely change the footprint, or even add a door/deck/patio. Kitchen renovations are about $15,000-125,000. and he impact your everyday life. Take your time, plan with a pro.
  • 8 years ago
    In the pic the cabinets look fine ....so I understand not wanting to re-do all the cabinets because a few have a problem...but you do not offer any pics of the problems or their location....I might try getting a cabinet maker to consult on how to re-purpose the areas or whether the damaged parts can be repaired....this just takes some thinking outside the box......
    Elana thanked btydrvn
  • 8 years ago

    I apparently don't have any photos of the bleach stained doors, but here are some other photos I have:

    @maggicoast, We already have French doors leading to a giant deck, so that won't need to be a part of our renovations. :)

    Here is a close-up of one of the cabinets.

    One of the more unflattering angles...

    The large crack.

    I might just be freaking out, but I'm really feeling like the expense to replace them at this time will be too great. I got some quotes for replacement, and will be gathering more quotes soon, along with quotes for refacing.

  • 8 years ago

    Your cabinets will look nice with a good cleaning, some repairs and new hardware. If this was my kitchen I would replace the tile with light hardwood. That change alone will add so much and give the kitchen a rich, warm feeling.

    Elana thanked grapefruit1_ar
  • 8 years ago

    I used this website and was really impressed at the concept.

    Elana thanked Audrey
  • 8 years ago
    If repairing and cleaning the existing doors gets eliminated, then a refacing (doors only) job will really brighten the room.
    I would make a floor choice after the cabinet option is decided. I agree with others that the tile is very dated and drags down the whole look.
    Shop for hardware after making the door decision. The handles also look dated and tired but that can be done after you’re sure of the doors.
    I’ve refaced two kitchens. It’s about 2-3 days’ work depending on the number of doors.
    You can do the countertop at the same time as the doors but you can also wait. Your backsplash, after removing the one you don’t like, can be done any time. I waited a year with a painted backsplash because I couldn’t make up my mind.
    Hopefully you can restain the bleached area and repair the cracked area. Then choose your hardware and spend your money on the other elements (countertop, backsplash and floor).
    Take your time. Lots can be done after you move in.
    Elana thanked RedRyder
  • 8 years ago
    Is that peninsula thing attached and are you keeping it? You really don’t have room for an island, unless it’s a skinny island on wheels.
  • 8 years ago
    As has already been mentioned.....I sympathize with the stress you must be under, but I don't think it is ever a good idea to rush into any type of renovation (that usually winds up being a costly mistake), so if you are generally happy with the cabinets/layout then I would look into just having the damaged areas repaired, at least for now. I have to believe that would be the most affordable/least stressful option for you, and that the only real difficulty it should present is finding the right person to do the job. Changing out the floor alone, I think, will go a long way to updating what you've got. Once you've done that, and replaced the appliances, added new counters/backsplash and updated the knobs and lighting...the cabinets will probably work just fine. You can always look at refacing them down the road, assuming you are still good with the layout. Good luck!
  • 8 years ago

    The peninsula is not attached. Both the peninsula and cabinet above it will be gone soon. :)

  • 8 years ago

    Yea, glad your not keeping that peninsula and extra cabinet. It will look more open without them!

    What direction are you going with the flooring? I know someone above suggested hardwoods. I would really really really advise you to NOT do hardwood in a kitchen from personal experience. When we purchased our current home 10 years ago the last owner had just installed high quality hardwood floors throughout the great room, entry and kitchen. We were Soooo careful and babied them and are currently replacing them because the are a total mess. We are installing a commercial grade porcelain tile that looks just like wood. It even has the waviness of hand scraped wood. We have had this same tile in our bedroom for five years and it looks as great as the day it was installed, No special cleaners to treatment needed!!

    Elana thanked Jamie Ludwig
  • 8 years ago

    We are installing tile in the kitchen. We had hardwood in the kitchen of our old place, and it was okay, but tile seems better for a kitchen space.

  • 8 years ago

    "If you are happy with the basic layout of the kitchen you should reface them. Way less expensive"

    Quality refacing by a real company will cost you 3/4 the price of new cabinets. Your tile appears to go under your existing cabinets, don't forget to figure out how you will handle that in the overall plan..........................

    Elana thanked millworkman