Software
Houzz Logo Print
jetehel

Favorite white David Austin?

8 years ago

I only have white flowers in the front of my house and I have a spot to add a rose bush, so it needs to be a showstopper! thinking maybe Claire Austin? I love David Austin’s but open to anything as long as it has that old rose look

thsnks for your suggestions!

Comments (34)

  • 8 years ago
    last modified: 8 years ago

    The perfect white English rose for my garden has yet to be created. I've posted about it a number of times, but the best so far is not an Austin, it's Bolero, which is almost an Austin since one of its parents is Fair Bianca. Bolero is still very susceptible to thrips in my yard, edges brown in the dry hot wind that we get, but the fragrance is wonderful, the bush compact, it is floriferous and beautiful.

    Here they are today, not the best photo but you get the idea.

    Claire Austin has nice form, and vigor, but in my yard bloomed bright yellow. When I contacted David Austin Roses, they said this was normal. In my climate, the yellow of any rose becomes much more pronounced for some reason.

    Fair Bianca: lacked vigor in my yard (I've seen stunning photos, however). Beautiful flowers, licorice fragrance.

    Winchester Cathedral: odd fragrance, but a pretty tough plant. Not a crisp white in my yard, but a little buff or grey.

    Glamis Castle: smelled like mothballs to me when I grew it (smelled great in Oregon), and had a lot of big thorns. The scent made me remove it.

    Wollerton Old Hall had the same fragrance as Glamis Castle and is not really white.

    Pure Perfume has a full look to the flowers, glossy modern looking leaves. Mine are in too much shade to be happy, so not a full report.

    I can't tell you about Desdemona, but I'm tempted to try her.

  • 8 years ago

    What size of rose are you looking for? If you’re looking for something shorter (around 3 feet) I would recommend Bolero.

    Claire Austin is healthy and very fragrant but she makes a better short climber - narrow shrub with thin/flexible canes. She reblooms well but the blooms are short lived.

    Desdemona was new in the US last year but I have loved it and if you’re looking for a medium to large shrub, it should do well for you.

  • 8 years ago

    I would also recommend Bolero or Earth Angel. They are longer lasting than most Austins , both are disease resistant, tidy , and fragrant, too.

    Earth Angel below:

  • 8 years ago

    Wow, a yellow Claire!!!

    these are all so lovely!

    I recently planted wollerton old hall in my back yard and impatiently waiting to see what that looks like.

  • 8 years ago

    Noseometer- your third pic is Winchester, right? It’s gorgeous

  • 8 years ago

    I like my Claire Austin. Quick repeat, winter hardy, fragrant, nice bloom form, decent disease resistance.


    My only complaint is that blooms only last 2 days, maybe 3.

  • 8 years ago

    Noseometer, I really doubt the yellow rose is truly Claire Austin. It is not only the wrong color, but also the wrong form. Claire Austin has higher petal count.

  • 8 years ago

    Jaime - yes, the third picture is Winchester Cathedral. At its best, it is gorgeous.

    Palytoxin - That's what I thought as well. I sent that photo to DA Roses (I got it from them) and they said that they were certain that it was Claire Austin. I still don't fully believe it. The Claire Austins at the nursery didn't show a hint of yellow, but maybe because they were grown out of state?

  • 8 years ago

    BenT- your earth angels are beautiful! All the pics online show it more pink

  • 8 years ago

    I too have all white flowers in my front garden & the one that performs the best is Mme Jules Bouche. I love watching people stop & admire her & then drink in her perfume. Even teenage boys(on their way to the skate park) admire her & was told by one of them that she's really cool! HMF says she's prone to BS but she only gets a very tiny amount & I just pluck off the leaves. My area is very prone to BS. I loved her so much that I ordered 2 more.She is an older HT from 1910.

  • 8 years ago
    This is my winchester cathedral. I like it. It has winter hardiness, I love the blooms. This one is not fussed over and it is exposed to the elemts
  • 8 years ago

    Smithdale- thsnks! Do you happen to have pics of your front garden? I love looking for inspiration

  • 8 years ago

    Kristine- what do you find odd with Winchester?

  • 8 years ago

    I like lichfield angel. Its the prettiest of the white austins in my opinion, although its more like a cream color than white. It has full well formed blooms. I wish my Earth Angel looked like BenT's. Mine never blooms and always blooms one small flower on top of a long long gangly stem. I wonder if I'm doing something wrong with it. Its own root from Chamblees and very healthy, but not very bloomy for me. :(

  • 8 years ago
    last modified: 8 years ago

    Love EA, but slow to repeat for me.

    I and others love Bolero, its form, fragrance, disease resistance and fast repeat. Stays smaller so I hear. Same bloom opening, 2nd year in ground

  • 8 years ago

    Bolero is lovely and has the most delicious scent.Possibly my favorite rose although it struggles in my z5b garden. But a David Austin that is carefree that I love is Windermere. Almost always in bloom, creamy white smallish flowers, for an Austin, and little to no disease. Not heavily scented like some of the other Austins but it does have some scent, and stays fairly small at about 3- 3.5 feet.

    I have Desdemona on order since it's promoted as being Austin's best white to date. Pictures are breathtaking.

    sharon

  • 8 years ago

    How tall and wide do you want this white rose to be?

  • 8 years ago
    last modified: 8 years ago

    I only have Winchester Cathedral and Frau Karl Druschki for whites. For what you seek and my limited growing experience, WC is what I would suggest. I've been happy with mine.

    Very different plants and forms. Both will black spot, and FKD will mildew for me before WC. WC is shrubby, full, and flowers plentifully with decent repeat. The fragrance is unique and I enjoy it: like hanging cream! She is unstable and will display partial reversions to Mary Rose (pink). Sometimes in cool weather the blooms have a hint of buff or blush that fades soon.

    FKD grows and looks like a husky hybrid tea. Thick canes, not a lot of branching, ZERO scent, not too generous with repeat and modern flower form. It's very crisply white, with blush only in very cool weather.

    Winchester Cathedral in autumn

    Frau Karl Druschki

    I prefer WC due to better scent and floriferousness, but aside from being white roses, they aren't fair to compare.

    Steven

    Jaime 7a NY thanked MiGreenThumb (Z5b S.Michigan/Sunset 41) Elevation: 1091 feet
  • 8 years ago

    Sold on bolero! The more I look at the space, I think I can add a few roses in. Happily willing to pull out an old azalea to make room if need be.

    Do you think it looks nice to mix white roses? Since some cast more blush, some more yellow, do thry look nice together or am I better off just adding multiple of the same rose? for example, I already have a white drift in the front and a Sally Holmes to the side. Should I put 2-3 bolero or 1 bolero and 1 Winchester cathedral (or Windermere)?

    If anyone has any pictures to share it would be greatly appreciated

    thanks!

  • 8 years ago
    last modified: 8 years ago

    I have a white/white-blush rose bed. It has Bolero, Desdemona (previously Earth Angel which was moved), Sharifa Asma, Eden and Sombrueil. Also white asiatic lilies, hellebores, peonies, blusging bride hydrangea. Lots of purple salvia too. And pale lavender and blush clematis.

    Seems like it is working but still lots of young plants.

  • 8 years ago

    Sounds gorgeous!!


  • 8 years ago

    totoro, show us pictures!

  • 8 years ago

    Looking at everyone's pictures of Winchester Cathedral, I see what is different about mine, my leaves are all curled. They were last year too. The plant has gotten huge with those apperently diseased leaves. No wonder I don't love it


  • 8 years ago

    I love Winchester Cathedral, blooms non stop plus I am partial to the name.

  • 8 years ago

    I love Sally Holmes. I think a soft white with blushing pink is so romantic. Bolero has a palest pink center and a sometimes a pale green button eye. Gray leaved plants would look beautiful in this combination like artemisia or lamb's ear. Totoro's combination sounds gorgeous.

    Bolero stays small for me but it could be that she's just not quite hardy enough here. A friend in a warmer zone had some and they got fairly wide but not too tall. Just a nice rounded shrub. I think you could plant two together.

    My three Windermere are planted about 15 inches apart, a little closer than Austin suggests but it works fine in my colder zone. I don't have any pics since mine have barely woken up here but her flower is nice and she's probably my best repeat flowerer.

    Desdemona has gotten excellent reviews. I have three on order from Austin. It's supposed to stay short and smell amazing.

    both pics from DA site

    Desdemona

    Windermere

    Bolero from Houzz

    The colors for Windermere and Bolero are pretty accurate. Windermere is softest creamy white. Bolero white blushed pink. The pink is more pronounced in cooler weather, at least for me.

    sharon

    Jaime 7a NY thanked enchantedrosez5bma
  • 8 years ago

    Thank you Sharon!

  • 8 years ago
    last modified: 8 years ago

    Hello =),

    I would also recommend Bolero as an outstanding rose. I don’t have it yet, but my mom grows it and it is spectacular. I can’t wait to add it to my garden.

    I do grow Lichefield Angel. I loved it so much that I end up with 9 of them sprinkled all over. It is definitely more cream specially with cooler mornings. My small lichefieds are covered in huge blooms that drop to the floor due to their weight. I am sure with some time they will get stronger stems.

    Earth Angel is beautiful and globular. It has a bit more pink in cooler weather too. This is a great rose. Much more healthy here than the Austin’s. (No offense) I actually love all Austin’s and want their entire catalog of roses lol.

    Desdemona is a beautiful Austin. It blooms a lot and it is pretty healthy here too, specially for an Austin. To me she smells great. Much smaller blooms when compared to lichefield angel. The colors also have more pink in cooler weather before it turns white. Sorry I am repeating pictures I have posted already this week because I am far from home and can’t take new ones.

    Dianela.

    Jaime 7a NY thanked dianela7analabama
  • 8 years ago

    Daniela, beautiful!!!


    i just purchased bolero and my local nursery has Winchester, I need to drop some Mother’s Day hints, lol

  • 8 years ago

    Earth angel is absolutely amazing, I think I need to add it to my main backyard rosebed

  • 8 years ago
    last modified: 8 years ago

    Here are 3rd to bloom from my white bed. 2 Eden roses with white peony Lenora. Bolero was the first


    Bolero

    sombrueil was 2nd

    Too bad my Pink Enchantment rose died after I moved it to this bed. I may need to get another.

    Salvias and clematis have not bloomed yet. I will have to take a wide angle shot when that happens.

  • 8 years ago

    Beautiful!

  • 8 years ago

    Thank you everyone for your suggestions. I planted Winchester cathedral and bolero this past weekend.

    Im obsessed with bolero, the flowers are gorgeous, thank you so much for the recommendations

    how big does bolero get? I think I read it stays small, if so I may add another 1 or 2 to give it a fuller look

  • 8 years ago

    Jaime- You will love Bolero. Mine stay tiny but they're own root and I'm zone 5b. My grafted ones really struggled but my friends did well and were about 2 1/2 feet tall and maybe 3 feet wide. Even as small as mine are they always have a few blooms and smell incredible. This is probably my favorite rose.

    sharon