Software
Houzz Logo Print
mxk3

Need recs for good supportive work boots

8 years ago
last modified: 8 years ago

I've been wearing my Hunter rubber boots to do garden work for a while now but they finally sprung a leak. I was thinking about getting new boots anyway, since rubber is REALLY COLD in cooler weather (even with boot socks rubber gets so cold!) and after I jacked up my foot the lack of support in the Hunter's is really a problem (and the coldness of the rubber intensifies the stiffness in my foot). Anyway, I'm not hearbroken about this, they needed to go regardless, so now I'm on the hunt for new work boots.

I'd like something that is easy-on easy-off (read: a pull-on) because they'll be my barn boots, and the last thing I want to do at 5:00 am on cold, dark winter mornings is fiddle with laces - plus I have to haul *ss to get to work on time, I need to pull on those puppies and hightail it out to the barn and feed the horses as fast as I can. I'd like something at least mid-calf height so I can tuck my pants in (the mud can get sloppy and splashy back in the pasture in rainy weather). If the boots can handle barn work, they can handle garden work, so I'd like to have just one pair that meets my needs. Need to be supportive or able to accommodate a slip-in orthotic (oh man I'm starting to sound like a grandma already aren't I LOL!). Don't mind paying for good quality - my feet are worth the expense.

So, where should I start looking? Any recs?

Comments (16)

  • 8 years ago

    You and I are on the same wavelength this morning -- the local Tractor Supply carries Muck boots, I saw them online and was going to post in the thread for raves/rants on these. I'm thinking about the Wetland style. I think I'm going to stop by the store on my home from work this evening to try them on (they carry men's in-store, men's would probably fit me better anyway, I have wide feet).

  • 8 years ago

    based on your location ... it must be the most high end tractor supplys in the US ... lol ... i was going to refer you there .. but figured they wouldnt have one in that zip code ... lol


    the only thing i wish.. was that they had a steel toe version ... or some such thing ...


    one hint.. dont go kicking rocks or things with them ... lol ..


    ken



  • 8 years ago

    I'd check out Bogs as well - fully waterproof, insulated and with decent foot support and cushioning.

  • 8 years ago

    Another vote for Muck boots which have good support and are made of neoprene. I was introduced to them by a friend who had a cut flower business, grown in greenhouses all winter so she was walking on chilly cement as well as to and from the greenhouses through NH snow. I have a knee high pair that I find warm, dry, and lighter weight than most other boots. Bogs aren’t as warm and are narrower than the Muck boots I own which are men’s as I also have wide feet.

  • 8 years ago

    I WANT these... really, really *want* them!

    https://www.muckbootcompany.com/pub/media/catalog/product/image/600x600/wm2-500-pur-050_8.jpg

    I'm assuming from the multiple recommendations that these boots are durable. Figuring out what size I take in a woman's boot would be tricky though. I usually buy men's footwear and clothing because they fit better.

  • 8 years ago

    Ken - I thought I saw a steel-toe version on either the Muck website or Tractor Supply site. TS doesn't carry women's in the store, so no - we're not high-end LOL!

    Spedi - Get them!! You need them for GardenWeb research purposes :0p. I think the rule of thumb is size down 2 sizes to go down to men's. Or just look at the size converters on-line and take a stab at it.

  • 8 years ago
    last modified: 8 years ago

    Bogs are the bomb! Just love mine.

    Great for winter/cooler temps...but too warm for summer.

    Crocs flip flops are my go to summer shoes...so durable and comfy.

  • 8 years ago
    last modified: 8 years ago

    ^^ I am not traipsing through horse manure in flip flops LOL! (I do have a pair of plastic slides on the patio, though - can't stand dirty feet so don't do yard work in them)

  • 8 years ago

    Aww come on be adventurous lol!!

    I can’t stand hot feet while gardening! I have a special foot brush for scrubbing them clean for my post gardening showers....and a separate one for my nails :)

  • 8 years ago

    i wear them 24/7/365 .. yeah.. i even sleep in them ... and they last 2 to 3 years ... i usually get a blow out in the sole ... that lets water in ...


    as noted ... i fill them with hot water and a part scoop of laundry detergent once or twice a year ... let them stand an hour or so ... then throw them in the washer with some rag towels ... i have the short shoe type ... i prefer to let them dry in summer out in the sun ... i am pretty sure.. a hot dryer would not be good as they age ... and my god.. all that thumping ... lol .. so i try to wash them in spring and fall .. to avoid the dryer ...


    ken

  • 8 years ago
    last modified: 8 years ago

    Can't you just hose them off? Unless you're wearing them to a wedding or something, who cares if they're muddy they're just going to get muddy again.

    I guess I am high falutin', the Tractor Supply by me did have ladies' Muck boots - only 2 styles, but one of them fit perfectly! 20% off too - can't beat that! I did try on the men's and found, strangely enough, that the ladies fit better. This surprised me because I have Fred Flintstone feet and tend to have trouble with width, especially in the forefoot.

  • 8 years ago

    Can't you just hose them off?


    ==>>> well.. of course ... but why did you used to wash your tennis shoes back in the day .. was it because they LOOKED bad ... or was it because you could smell them for across the room.. if you get my drift ... or i should say.. their drift ...


    again.. i have the shoe type.. i dont really see how you would use the washing machine with taller versions .... so maybe you ought to forget all that .....


    ken



  • 8 years ago

    My feet don't smell.

  • 8 years ago
    last modified: 8 years ago

    If you wear cotton socks, the insides of waterproof boots stay pretty clean. My washing machine would make mincemeat out of a pair of boots anyway. I'm squarely in the hosing-off camp. (I can count on one hand the times I've laundered sneakers. It pretty much destroys the inner soles, so I avoid doing it.)

    So I guess if I take a mens size 7.5 (US) boot, I should order these womens muck boots in womens size 9.5 ? How accurate are muck boots sizes ? Are the boots as durable as they look ? How are they with returns, if the size turns out to be wrong?

  • 8 years ago

    ^^Oh, gosh, I don't know about returns directly from them. You might want to order from someplace like LL Bean that has a great return policy (and if there's any stores in VT, you can just return in-store). Turns out DH has a pair of Muck's he got at Dick's Sporting Good, you could try there or Tractor Supply, if that chain is in your area.