Why don't you slipcover the sofa, get some great pillows, and down the road get an amazing sofa after you've lived in the house for awhile?

These are great suggestion! Thank you, @housegal200.

@ilikefriday, this rendering is awesome! Do you have some info on the leather couch?

Want to go rustic or classic? A rustic cabin with classic antiques (often found 2nd hand) can look really awesome.

Sorry, I don't have any info on that sofa but it looks like a pretty generic leather sofa. I'm sure you could find something similar almost anywhere.

I think a modern-industrial style would look good in the log cabin. If you want it a bit more layered, a Ralph Lauren look would work too.

Here is another look. More colorful than the last.

@ilikefriday this is fab! I love the contrast of the blue chesterfield sofa. I’ve been considering this style but wasn’t sure it would work—the rendering really helped! Now all I have to do is find one that is reasonably priced. Thank you!

I would not consider that either modern or clean lines. But those are both fine in a log cabin in fact the juxtaposition of modern with the logs is a nice relief IMO

I love chesterfield sofas although I've never had a leather one since leather just seems cold to me. Pick a beautiful color or a patterned one in a nice material and you may feel a lot more cozy than with leather. However, it's really a personal preference. I would begin with a big, beautiful Persian rug because they look good everywhere and you can pull so many colors from them. Again, a personal preference but try esalerugs for different styles of rugs, including lots of Persian types, which you can return at no cost if you don't like them.

@ingrid I agree that leather is cold but I think it may be more durable. Adding a big rug might bring in some warmth when paired with a leather couch. I think a darker colored fabric like blue or charcoal may also hold up well against wear and tear, although they are very bold for my taste. I live in Miami and the majority of homes are bright and airy, with white walls and cream furnishings. Dark furnishings and big rugs are unchartered territory for me! Thanks for your help!

In my experience bonded leather sofas degrade pretty quickly ("leather" peels off) but a true leather Chesterfield will last forever. Velvet, on the other hand, is almost impossible to get "ick" off of. I would do a leather sofa in a saddle brown or white leather and then add blue velvet pillows and a blue velvet side chair that's cheaper to replace if it gets ruined. A sleeper sofa is also a good investment for an Airbnb.

https://www.wayfair.com/furniture/pdp/omnia-leather-jackson-leather-sleeper-sofa-otl1790.html

https://www.wayfair.com/furniture/pdp/design-tree-home-katrina-3-seater-leather-chesterfield-sofa-dsag1656.html

https://www.wayfair.com/furniture/pdp/alcott-hill-potterslane-high-back-new-velvet-wingback-chair-alth2523.html