Should I be here on perennials?
Coming up to the midsummer solstice, I always cast a (jaded) eye about the gardens and note what is working (and what isn't)...and this year, as in just about every year, I realise I am posting on the wrong forum since, as usual, perennials have taken a decidedly back seat to my first and abiding love, those exuberant annuals (with a shout out for biennials). True, I should be over on the annual forum except it is hopelessly moribund with a massive bias towards zinnias (an annual I grow maybe one in 3-4 years).
Anyway, suffice to say, I grow a lot of hardy annuals - easily sown in September then ignored until they burst into vigorous growth for a May/June explosion. Larkspurs, gypsophilia, osteospermums, various flax, ammi, orlaya and wild carrots. sweet peas, cosmos, poppies, phlox etc etc, are always sown with abandon on the allotment...but the most iconic annual, for me, has always been the tall cornflowers. Needless to say, the show is bright and fleeting...since a daily bike ride to deadhead simply does not happen. But for a few weeks, every vessel in the house is filled to bursting with posies of brilliant flowers, costing next to nothing and requiring the barest effort. What's not to love? And yet, I have noticed that I have had to look a bit further afield for seeds since vegetables and bedding plants seem to be far more popular with the growing public. And fortunately, the internet provides...with a whole array of Californian, South African. Mediterranean and North American delights to be had, again for pennies.
Every year, I try a few unknowns (still in my malva and poppy stage).
However, (and the purpose for my rambling post), this year, I had a few spare seedlings of purple larkspur, lime green nicotiana and lilac cornflowers which I sowed into deep. 5litre rose pots and stuffed into any tiny gap in the garden. Just a handful of cornflowers has been revelatory. They are easily deadheaded, being just outside my back door, maintain a gorgeous presence, and look tremendous nestling amongst the salvias, parahebes, agapanthus, geraniums, grasses and geums (which comprise the bulk of the planting in my tiny, sheltered walled garden). This is a trick I formerly employed with summer bulbs...but always left me with that problem of sordid foliage when the lilies, glads, watsonia, ixias et al were finished. With annuals, you simply pull and compost the lot...although, if deadheading and feeding is kept up, the show can continue all summer.
So yes, the point of this long preamble is a request for us to look again at these common stalwarts of the garden. Although not often available to buy (we have no real equivalent to Annie's Annuals in the UK)...they are cheap, easy and a great addition (nay, asset) to a perennial garden. Anyone up for sowing a few this autumn or even next spring?
With massive apologies, I am unable to download a single photo since my only camera is 65miles away, in an unreachablewoodland (without a bike, train and hike) since my chauffeur carelessly mangled his arm...but I certainly took a few before the (ahem) 'log incident'...specifically of the lovely legousia (Venus' Looking Glass) and the bright pink Moroccan peas (.l.tingitanus).
Comments (26)
- 8 years ago
Why not here?? They may not be perennials in the strict sense of the word but they make great, if temporary, fillers or additions to a perennial garden.
To be honest, I don't have any perennial garden beds. All of mine are mixed plantings and may or may not include a tree or two but always various shrubs, dwarf conifers, sometimes vines and perennials and groundcovers. And seasonally, annuals or temperennials :-) It wouldn't be a complete planting in my view if it did not include a few Papaver somniferum, calendulas, snapdragons and nicotiana. And my recent seasonal must haves, Euphorbia 'Diamond Frost' and Cuphea 'Vermillionaire'.
Thankfully, gone are the days when annuals were treated only as bedding plants - IMO, the least appealing form of presentation! I would much prefer to see them intermingled into established plantings to provide long lasting color and interest.
User thanked gardengal48 (PNW Z8/9) Related Professionals
Vincennes Landscape Architects & Landscape Designers · Cumberland Landscape Architects & Landscape Designers · Columbia Landscape Architects & Landscape Designers · Danville Landscape Architects & Landscape Designers · Ocala Landscape Contractors · Columbus Landscape Contractors · Watertown Landscape Contractors · Wheeling Landscape Contractors · San Angelo Landscape Contractors · Redding Landscape Contractors · Vincennes Home Builders · Monroe Home Builders · Atlantic City Home Builders · Waterbury Home Builders · San Jose Home Builders- 8 years ago
Hopefully, I will benefit from some advice.
We live rurally surrounded by pastureland and woodland as well as neighbors who share a fence line that doesn’t get mowed on their side. Not to mention living in the PNW, the weed capital of the U.S.
i have tried sowing annuals but they always end up being overcome by weeds. Last year I planted Orlaya and Ammi Majus. These were started in pots and looked pretty good when I put them in the ground but looked homely and thin in the ground. This year their offspring look fabulous, a lesson for me that timing is everything with annuals and those that seed themselves and grow in their own time do better than my transplants that mess with their innate timing and are at the mercy of cold nights and fluctuating temperatures sometimes through June.
So the offspring are looking great but the trade off was averting my eyes from a mass of weeds among the shared perennials in the bed until these seedlings were strong enough to survive the needed weeding.
I, too, check in with the Annuals Forum and find it pretty boring, at least as far as my interests go and much prefer the conversations happening in this forum.
So after this long winded post, does anyone have suggestions for successfully interspersing seeded annuals into mixed plantings?
And an additional question for you both: Do you grow in a greenhouse or on a window ledge, etc. and are the annuals mentioned easily germinated?
- 8 years agolast modified: 8 years ago
Yes, you should be here because if you weren't you would be missed...
When I think of cornflowers, I think Centaurea montana, which for me is a perennial. So, see -- that qualifies you as a perennial gardener! I'm with GG -- I favor mixed plantings, but most of my annuals are in pots on the porch and patio, save those in the veggie garden (calendula, marigolds, and a carnival color of tall zinnia). Right now I'm on a salvia kick, my favorite being "Mystic Spires", and S. guaranitica "Black and Blue". I also have geranium (Pelargonium), petunias, vincas, elephant ears, heliotrope, pentas. Nothing out of the ordinary, but they make me happy so I plant them.
User thanked porkchop_z5b_MI - 8 years ago
Definitely you belong here Camp.! This forum is the best option for all-round garden discussion that I’ve found. Like many here, all my garden beds are a mix of perennials, trees, shrubs, bulbs, vines.... Note that the thread I posted yesterday is about a shrub. But this forum’s wide-ranging discussions made me not think twice about posting it here... Also, since I post here quite often, I feel many of you ‘know’ my garden so can put it in the larger context of the overall space. I think the same rationale applies on your case Camp. If the discussions here were strictly limited to perennials, I think it would be a much less interesting forum!
User thanked woodyoak zone 5 southern Ont., Canada User
Original Author8 years agoyeah well, the fact is, even if I didn't grow a single perennial, I would still head to this forum because we are internet mates, right? Annuals have always interested me because I have a tiny garden but like to try a lot of plants. Simple though they are, to raise from seed, it has taken me a lot of experimentation and literally hundreds of fails to get an idea of what works for me.
My biggest disappointment was the year I followed the 'rules for successful annual beds' in some gardening mag. I duly dig and raked (to a fine tilth), marked our areas with fine sand, drilled in straight rows (so I could differentiate from weeds), sowed half a dozen varieties,covered with fine sand, watered and settled back to wait...for a horrible, weedy tangle - a complete mess. For many years afterwards, I used smaller annuals such as phacelia, limnanthes, nemophilia to edge my veg beds or tuck in with pot roses. I had the space to grow annuals in drifts at the allotment,,,and also much taller scabious, cosmos and larkspurs...but yep, the deadheading was impossible.
Finally, although I worked in garden design and build, my own gardens are a woeful mess of seedlings, try-outs and half-dead cuttings...so I grew fast growing annuals for fun, rather than as part of a finished picture...until I had woodland and annual growing kicked off again in earnest.
Best of all, for me, is the cost equation. It is hard to get too demoralised over the deaths of cheap annuals (persicaria orientalis, for example - another persistent snail victim)...while a £10 perenhnial would sting.
If I ever opened a nursery, it would be annuals all the way - there are so many of them...and clearly, the british public simply cannot get enough of edible annuals (veg plugs - I was amazed) so the longevity isn't as essential.
- 8 years agolast modified: 8 years ago
"Should I be here on perennials?". Absolutely "Yes", Camp.
Your breadth of knowledge and experience is a valuable asset to this forum.
I also strongly agree with sentiments expressed notably in gardengal48's last paragraph (above) about the use of annuals in perennial situations.
User thanked sunnyborders - 8 years ago
If I ever opened a nursery, it would be annuals all the way - there are so many of them...
I am seeing this with many existing nurseries ie for the past few seasons I think I am observing a decrease in the perennial section with a corresponding hike in the amount and variety of annuals offered. With the explosion of high rise condominium living people are 'decorating' their balconies with containers of flowering annuals, veggies and herbs.
- 8 years ago
I noticed a local nursery, who used to have a tremendous selection of perennials, pared that down and expanded their hydrangea selection to the max. It's kind of ridiculous - they have THAT MANY hydrangeas.
- 8 years ago
You certainly have my approval, as unimportant as that is, to post wherever you like. Your contributions and wit are always appreciated, especially in a world where so much of that is lacking. Just because a person doesn't "dwell" in whatever space or topic, doesn't mean they don't have anything valuable to add...and I've certainly gotten lots of ideas and pointers from everyone who posts, and very often a good laugh to brighten up my day thrown in for extra measure!
User thanked LaLennoxa 6a/b Hamilton ON - 8 years agolast modified: 8 years ago
Rigid compartmentalizing just sucks. So post away about those annuals.
I like annuals that seed out a lot. I find that they do great in a grass field. Just like in they do naturally. People say that annual are expensive. I guess if you plant bought bedding plants every year and watch them die and toss them in the trash. I just let them go to seed and they seem to come back on their own. Not always where I put them. I like their wandering habit. I also like that when the dry summer hits and my garden goes dormant, they need no care and will return when the conditions are right. I enjoy their cyclical appearances. It was dry this year so it was not that good of a year for gaillardia and even the monada citriodora, but the dry loving Monarda punctatata saved the day. The palafoxia is still growing. I think annuals a re a great way of filling out a garden fast while the perennials are small.
User thanked wantonamara Z8 CenTex User
Original Author8 years agolast modified: 8 years agoThe gardening gene skipped a generation in my family, so it is my grandmother who nurtured the horticultural know-how in my family...and almost always, common hardy annuals, bought in sixpence seed packets, were the order of the day. Between leaving home, having a family and doing that very ubiquitous thing of middle age gardening myself, the garden industry embraced those often sterile, long-flowering stalwarts such as petunias, geraniums, lobelia erinus, nemeria and so on. Clearly, the temporary nature of these are not any sort of hindrance for the plant buying public because the garden centres are stuffed with million bells and diascias, most of which are destined to be tossed at the end of the season. So whilst I appreciate how little time and space, busy families can devote to raising plants, I honestly fail to see why the numerous garden worthy annuals have failed to catch the imagination of either the commercial growing operations or the public. I am guessing the clonal nature of greenhouse cuttings (conformity, predictability and regularity) dictates the decisions in the industry. (plus that 21st century phenomenon of 'built-in obsolescence and guaranteed insatiable markets)..but surely more of us might find a little time to try a few temporary beauties. True, most (but not all) of my US tryouts have been SW or Cali based (platystemon, tidy tips, phacelia, ipomopsis, claytonia nemophilia, browallia, phlox, sand verbena, verbesina, mentzelia, texas flax, gaillardia, gomphrena, gaillardia...and these are just the common, easily available seed packet types). I don't think the NE is as blessed with as many annual garden worthy plants (but what do I know?)...but for those of us not constrained by going native, there is a heap of global variety out there, and companies like B&T World seeds who are happy to indulge us.
So yep, rest assured, I will continue to harp on about the virtues of annuals...and this autumn and next spring, would really like to revive some of the old-fashioned varieties which have apparently fallen out of favour as we all over stretch our budgets spending dollars and pounds on some over-hyped nursery must-have...while annual seeds are a snip and a boon for the impatient or easily bored amongst us.
- 8 years agolast modified: 8 years ago
I am trying out a tender perennial, mostly annual here in Z8, Pentapetes phoenecea. It is not a commonly grown plant at all around here. They were originally collected by Thomas Jefferson. One of those founding fathers. Me Thinks that they are from India. I get the seed from a friend in San Antonio. They do like some moisture and good soil , so I might have failure with these in my garden during a drought year, but what the hey, they were free and I can always hit her up for seeds in the fall and try again next year. They come in Red and a pink variety. I put it in a place that gets some grey water.
- 8 years ago
Campanula yes you should be here. I keep reading and enjoying your older posts too.
Your name on the list of threads says rosaprimula so didn't know it was you at first. Don't know if everyone else sees you as RosaPrimula or not.
- 8 years ago
Yes, Camp, you should be here and, if you’d like to help me, post more about annuals amongst the perennials. I love the peek-a-boo look that happens when plants comingle, and annuals can play such a beautiful part as they seed around the garden. But, I have sooooooo many questions. Right now one reason I wintersow is because I do not trust Mother Nature to germinate a seed sown in the fall. Well, I do trust Ma Nat, but seed companies now sell so few seeds in each packet! There isn’t enough seed to just scatter and watch. So, I sow in jugs. Sometimes my sown seeds say to scatter, but scattering seeds is scary sowing, and so-so wintersow spring seedlings are certainly superior to scarce soil sown seedlings. (Can’t I could “certainly” as part of the illiteration because it makes the right sound?). I worry that mulch will be bad. Can I scatter seeds in fall on mulch?
Now, this spring I’ve answered part of my own question because I have some volunteers from last year’s poppies. But, it ain’t a ton of volunteers. Poppies are seed factories, and I had many poppies. The germination rate for those poppies through the mulch has got to be pretty low.
I would love to hear you add many many comments and hints about scattering annual seeds among existing perennials and mulch. Of course, if you do all your sowing in pots, you can still add that helpful info.
I would also love love love some great annual combos or annual/perennial combos. Right now I’m waiting for Clarkia to flower amongst my coneflowers. My annuals are way behind because we have been dry dry dry. My larkspurs is at most 8 inches tall.
As for Northeastern annuals...what a good point. We have Eastern Columbine, which is the only columbine I like and an important hummingbird feeder in spring. We also have some Campanula (bingo!) that are annual. But, you’re right. I think we owe other US areas a big “thank you” for annuals!
- 8 years ago
And, yes, we are all internet mates! The personalities come through the writing.
- 8 years ago
Yes, me too! (Don’t go).....
Last year I had good luck with Ammi majus, Orlaya grandiflora, Cleome and red poppies. The Ammi, Orlaya and poppies have seeded themselves luxuriously throughout the bed. It is a hodgepod of a bed which is how I seem to like my garden. But the original plants I grew from seed were paltry and sad looking and didn’t contribute much to last year’s bed.
I am wonering how I could improve to grow stockier plants. I am pretty sure the timing of seeding and planting out is trickier than I assumed. Right amount of time for growth but not too much or they get leggy. Planting out in time to bloom but not early enough to sit there shivering in our cold spring/early summer nights.
I have tried winter sowing unsuccessfully but will give it another try this year as generally that process gets good reviews.
Campanula, i too rely on your experience, knowledge and good advice as well as your sense of humor (something we gardeners must have in good supply). Please stick with us!
- 8 years ago
I may be mistaken, but I did not interpret this post as an indication that Camp was moving on.........only that she started a post about annuals in the Perennials forum!!
With all the nonsense going on with Houzz's insistence on bizarre cross-posting, I would much prefer to see a post about annuals in the Perennials forum (and we have already established they intermingle handsomely) than to have it posted in Annuals, Perennials and Appliances or some such other preposterous combination!! The Landscape Design forum has already deteriorated into a general gardening question catch-all!!
I trust after almost 2 weeks, we have gotten used to - if not comfortable with - all the changes and that early thoughts we might have had about "moving on" (to where, who knows) have faded. I look forward to any post Camp initiates regardless of its location as well as her responses to any others. In fact, I greatly value everyone's input regardless of topic!!
And while I know I could greatly increase my selection of both perennials and annuals if I grew them from seed, I just do not have the patience for that :-) Or any space for other than some direct sowing or some restrained self seeding. I just harvested my first bouquet of the season of sweet peas..........and patience NOT being my long suit, some were seeded and some were planted as starts!!
- 8 years ago
Other annuals that I have had luck with are the simple orange cosmos, Ipomopsis rubra, blanket flower, Calirhoe leiocarpa. pallafoxia callosa, a Pallafoxia hookeriana ( a brand new introduction), blue bonnets, Daucosma laciniata, Dysodia, a very dimunitive cudweed, Texas Star flower, Ammi Magnus, larkspur, poppies. an annual tall heterotheca, clasping cone flower. I grow some of those mentioned by Campanula. I love the idea that they blow in on thew wind. .... sometimes it is an irritant to. I love and hate that I am not in control. I guess it depends what side of the bed I wake up on or what I am doing when I think it.. God knows where that clashing cone flower came from. I think it hitchhiked on some cobble I brought in from a friend 50 miles away.
- 8 years ago
Great post Camp and thank you.
I have been reading quite a few cut flower farm blogs and find them quite enjoyable to read as well as brings to light some new ideas for planting annuals.
Two blogs that i am reading often are:
https://www.thegardenersworkshop.com/
what a wealth of info from Lisa, the owner. I have her books that I enjoy reading.
AND:
https://www.floretflowers.com/
PS, Camp your Profile page does not show your activity anymore, at least for me. I believe I use to go there often and search yours posts that I thouroughly enjoy reading always.
Patty
User
Original Author8 years agolast modified: 8 years agoMoving on? No no no never...I am proud to be a member of this forum (although I fear we are a tiny rearguard army fighting against the mass invasion of FB). The willingness to share knowledge and experience has always been a shining light of the internet...and given how our education systems and employment prospects have been under attack as profit becomes the only metric of value, I am profoundly thankful that a mere mouseclick opens up transatlantic friendships and learning possibilities (and of course, snark and gossip). And the pleasure of reading and replying to posts is a two-way transaction, let me emphasise this again..
I have never really felt at home with HOUZZ - not least because thousands of posts went astray and I had to re-register (think rosaprimula stems from this period). I generally only post in perennials but will skip about in woodlands, native plants, the seed fora and occasionally propagation...but many of the other fora are truly moribund (alpines, for example, gets about a post a year).
But anyway, my original post was a recognition that annuals have always been a mainstay of my gardens...by a ratio of at least 5:1 , grown in various ways, from volunteers to nursing along in the greenhouse. I was sort of apologising, for being a perennial poster while annuals are always holding my heartstrings...yet bemoaning the limited nature of the dedicated annual forum. In truth, here in the UK, there is a little bit of confusion as to what we mean by annuals...with the definition based on how we use them in our gardens, rather than the innate botanical nature of the plants. I also feel a little sorrow that many of our common annuals (such as clarkia and godetia) are vanishing from the trade stands in real life shops and garden centres (although still available from seed merchants).
I have 3 deep 'Long Tom' pots of purple cornflowers which have been blooming for 2 months now...with purple larkspur just starting to take over. When they look dismal, they will be composted while tithonia, plum coloured annual scabious and white cosmos can go in the same pots to see the season out...for absolutely no cost at all because I saved the seeds from last year...and in a tiny garden, this is exactly the strategy I employ to have something blooming all season. I forgot to plant the deep pink gyp which enchanted us last year, but seeds are still in the fridge for next season. Strikes me as a bargain (especially for those of us with short arms and deep pockets).
- 8 years ago
With each year I enjoy our annuals more and more. We don't plant anything exotic. For example here are one of my faves...the simple portulaca. It thrives in hot dry weather...the opposite of a "foo foo" plant (using Ken's phrase)

- 8 years agolast modified: 8 years ago
It often seeds itself around here. I will take cuttings of the big huge hybrids and grow plants indoors over the winter( which is very short)
- 8 years agolast modified: 8 years ago
Cool wantonamara.
(You are able to provide enough light indoors to have them thrive?)
- 8 years ago
(I didnt realize until this year that there are (at least?) two different types of Portulaca).
- 8 years ago
They don't need to thrive, they just need to stay alive and root. Our winters are short. I can also dig up the plant, pot it ,chop it back and put out on a shelf by a window in the shop , maybe watering it about once or twice over the winter. I do this with the special multi colored big flowers ones. The others seed them selves. They look tired when I put them back out but they perk up in a hurry. So, I guess I make them into a perennial.










ken_adrian Adrian MI cold Z5