Software
Houzz Logo Print
dedtired

Prices on 1st Dibs?

8 years ago

I found exactly the same credenza that I own on 1st Dibs. I nearly fell over when I saw what they are asking for it -- $4500.. It is John Widdicombe furniture, and I always knew the quality is good. I have this credenza, a chest of drawers, two bedside table and a king headboard. I paid $750, used, for the entire set about 40 years ago. If the 1st Dibs price is anywhere near accurate, I would be tempted to sell the set for something different and also enjoy the windfall.


I suspect the prices are high, but how high? I'd be thrilled to get $1k for the credenza. Thoughts?


my furniture on 1st Dibs

Comments (8)

  • 8 years ago

    Check completed auction prices at some of the auction sites, even eBay. ( I think the 1st Dibs credenza is also listed on eBay.)

    dedtired thanked maddielee
  • 8 years ago

    That was my suspicion. I'll look at ebay. Oh well, nice to think I was near-rich for a moment.

  • 8 years ago

    The prices are mostly inflated, and the vendor generally accepts offers. However, these are retail prices of convenience for buyers and/or designers who do not have the time to look high and low for vintage pieces in good condition.

    It depends on how valuable your time is and how much a designer charges per hour. If the designer charges over $100 an hour, or you make more than $100 an hour, how many $100 hours are you going to spend looking for something?

    And some of the prices are not that far off some of the auction results, particularly for some Nakashima, Paul Evans and the like.

    I lost out on a piece of furniture on eBay. It was not local, the final eBay price was over $4000, and it would have been pricey to ship here. The last two prestige auction house prices for an identical piece were slightly under $5000 and $6800.

    I could have spent almost $5000 total getting one sight unseen from eBay (obviously I didn't).

    I've seen the same table for about $7000 on 1st Dibs and for more than $12,000 on 1st dibs.

    For some people the difference between paying $7000 from a reputable dealer vs. jumping through a bunch of hoops for a table you haven't even seen in person for $5000, it is worth the extra $2000 for convenience and a safer purchase. $12,000 is a different story.

    But it depends upon what the market will bear. Clearly some people can and do pay premiums. But it won't sell if the price is too high, that will settle out in the long run.

    I followed a bronze ice bucket in the shape of an incense burner on 1st dibs because I have one and it was listed at $4000. Of course it lingered, and the price eventually dropped below $1000 and it sold. If I put that out at a sidewalk sale, I doubt anyone in that market would want to pay $50 for it. But the vintage furniture and accessories dealer around the corner could get a lot more than $50 for it, because he is a retailer not a person selling stuff on the sidewalk. But would he get $1000? Doubtful in my city. In Manhattan or LA or Silicon Valley? Maybe.

    dedtired thanked palimpsest
  • 8 years ago

    Interesting perspective, pal. Convenience and time do have value. As you say, it depends on what that is worth to the buyer. If someone wants my bedroom set for say $10k, I will gladly include local delivery!

    I checked out the “sold” prices for Widdicomb furniture on eBay and generally they were much less than the price asked.

  • 8 years ago

    The advantage of 1stDibs is that they have a huge audience/market, and therefore the price can be higher because they have a better chance of finding the right buyer. If you try to sell locally, the buyer pool will be much smaller and therefore the price is likely to be lower.

    dedtired thanked Lars
  • 8 years ago

    Ded, that's a beautiful piece. Nice to know others value it also.

    dedtired thanked westsider40
  • 8 years ago

    Heck, Ded, I'd be heading over to Medford and hitting every antique store there with a offer to sell them yours!

    dedtired thanked cyn427 (z. 7, N. VA)