Software
Houzz Logo Print
dlm2000

Want to keep Conversations private?

8 years ago

Of course there's no guarantee and it does smack a bit of exclusion but we all seem to value that we are not yet on the radar of the general Houzz population. Multiposting shows a direct link to any of the forums you choose and if someone has never heard of HD Conversations and this is one of your chosen forums, they might get curious. Which is not to say that we can't post to more than one forum but if we do it the old fashioned way, creating one post at a time on the chosen forums, then there won't be a link to this one. Just a thought.

Comments (31)

  • 8 years ago

    I can see plusses and minuses. The first thought I had is that there is really a treasure trove of thoughtful people, friendship and good advice in HD, and the world needs more of that.

    DLM2000-GW thanked lucillle
  • 8 years ago

    It’s not gw anymore and if you take a look at the mess the home decorating forum has become, that’s what many of us hope to avoid conversations becoming. Good reminder DLM!

    DLM2000-GW thanked olychick
  • 8 years ago

    It seems to me that Conversations has become pretty stagnant and it's mostly about shopping and vacationing now. At one time there were some great, thought-provoking conversations in this forum of smart, articulate women. I don't spend more than a few minutes here now because I'm not interested in what someone wears to a wedding. So some new blood might make it more interesting. At the very least, you might get members from the Houzz side who also like to shop and vacation.

    DLM2000-GW thanked User
  • 8 years ago

    I hesitated posting because it reminds me of middle school girls at a lunch table and I don't want to be that way. But. As you say, oly, the decorating forum is a mess and they aren't the only ones.

  • 8 years ago

    cross posted with you mayflowers. I think we still have those conversations on an as needed basis. I don't want to speak for anyone else but right now I'm grateful to have or read conversations about wedding attire and upcoming vacations. I'm on overload and feel frayed every day so I'm ok with the lighter touch here right now.

  • 8 years ago
    last modified: 8 years ago

    See, I'd rather hear about your overload issues than your vacation. ;)

    I always liked the advice threads. It was like a forum full of Dear Abbys and people gave such good advice. One of my favorite threads was roarah's "Do you believe in God?", which brought out such diverse ways of thinking about God.

    I read Kitchen Table much more than here even though they are mostly not my demographic. But there's more variety.

    DLM2000-GW thanked User
  • 8 years ago
    last modified: 8 years ago

    mostly not my demographic

    What?

    I wasn't aware that demographics were a large part of interesting, thoughtful conversations. In fact, diversity seems to help such conversations, in my opinion.

  • 8 years ago
    last modified: 8 years ago

    I would love threads like that mayflowers. I was considering starting a more philosophical thread about middle age, but censored myself for fear of sounding silly and nebulous. I am always, always amazed at how thoughtful, well informed and considerate posters are on this forum, which is what makes me so uncomfortable with DLM's worthy, but discomfiting, question.

    When this subject came up before in one incarnation or another, MtnRd mentioned the importance of new blood to the group, and that made sense to me (and not just because I am one of the newer people here ;-) But it also makes sense that we want our group to evolve organically, so that people who join are attracted to what those who came before built and respect that. The norms among this group are wonderful. People are unfailingly polite, helpful and supportive, even when they disagree.

    PS When I say this subject came up before , I mean the subject of leaving and going off on our own away from a place like Houzz that funnels people toward the various forums, thus ensuring a steady stream of new voices to the group.

  • 8 years ago

    Private suggests some are in and some are not. Who decides?

    DLM2000-GW thanked Bunny
  • 8 years ago
    last modified: 8 years ago

    I didn't think DLM's question was about excluding people, as much as it was about how far and wide to throw the net in recruiting people.

    DLM2000-GW thanked Rita / Bring Back Sophie 4 Real
  • 8 years ago

    I took it as a suggestion to consider which other forums you check for cross posting from HDC. I am overwhelmed by the wide net of Houzz forums. I do not want to wade through a thread of 5k posts mostly by the pros batting suggestions back and forth.

    DLM2000-GW thanked User
  • 8 years ago

    I stand corrected Bunnyfoof. We can't be private. We've never been private. Not now, not pre Houzz, not ever. Wrong word choice. I enjoy'meeting' new people here. I don't enjoy the churning of new posts and revolving door of posters that is Houzz and made a suggestion to try and keep this little corner a bit more more like what we're accustomed to. You may feel differently and that's fine. None of us have a lot of say in what happens here so what will be will be.

  • 8 years ago
    last modified: 8 years ago

    I also took it as an idea for how to post, in other words, just limit it to HDC, like it would have been before "the change." (hmmm-no pun intended.)

    I do not comment often, and start new threads on here even less, but I have been reading and learning and enjoying this particular forum for years. I've only been on GW for 8 years, and in the beginning exclusively kitchens. But I have to say that no matter which forum I am perusing now, if the person starting a new thread is posting to more than 2 forums, I hardly ever open it. Maybe I am limiting myself by not reading these, but it is too confusing/off putting/exhausting for my old feeble brain.

    ETA: I also open threads when they are started by people I recognize. I know I will always learn something from you guys.

    DLM2000-GW thanked leela4
  • 8 years ago

    I understand what you're trying to say DLM. Many other parts of the forums that used to be Gardenweb are being over-run with hit and run posters. I'm not against meeting new people at all - but sadly, many of the new people aren't even returning to their own threads. It feels like a lot of electronic noise now rather than any actual dialogue.

    GW always had a little bit of hit and run posting, but now that HOUZZ has thrown the doors wide open some forums are being overrun. That was part of the reason I've been so upset with this change. All the active GW forums had their own subculture and regular posters. There was a small sense of community. Now it feels like people are just shouting messages in passing.


    DLM2000-GW thanked User
  • 8 years ago
    last modified: 8 years ago

    I have never "followed" this forum. I would see the post when I scrolled "all discussions" and would drop in if something interested me. What I don't like is the posters (and the two or three I am thinking of are long time pre Houzz posters) that have to start an argument on any thread they post on. Not just disagree politely, but argue their point over and over. They will admit no other view and stomp all over everyone else.

    If they would stay to "Hot Topics" I wouldn't mind, because that is why that forum is there and I stay far away from it.

    There are two "Pro's" that post on the regular "Home Decorating" that I don't care for. I think they are from the Houzz side and they are usually very nasty with their opinions.

    DLM2000-GW thanked User
  • 8 years ago

    The things that I read in Hot Topics from a few old time HD posters turns my stomach. I do not want to start politics in here.

    DLM2000-GW thanked deegw
  • 8 years ago

    When I talk to my friends, a lot of the conversations are about day to day stuff. Sometimes we do talk about God, the meaning of life, etc. So I would expect that wherever people get together to have discussions, some will be serious, some will be more ordinary.

    I'd be willing to bet that in a room full of priests having lunch, not all the conversations are about religious topics. It is I think natural to share our everyday lives as well as our philosophy and thoughts of the future.

    DLM2000-GW thanked lucillle
  • 8 years ago

    LOL, Lucille, you are right. We happen to have struck up a friendship with a bishop, and it is just like any other friendship except I have particularly great admiration for him. : ) From the quotidian to the sublime.

    DLM2000-GW thanked mtnrdredux_gw
  • 8 years ago

    When we did talk current events here, the conversation was always informative and mostly respectful, nothing like Hot Topics. I learned a lot about healthcare and other topics here. I don't find the discussions very meaningful on HT because the goal is to antagonize each other, so threads degenerate into squabbles. That seldom happened here.

    DLM2000-GW thanked User
  • 8 years ago

    There are so many heartfelt posts that come up here and the conversations don't have to be about politics to be thought provoking or informative. Empty nest issues, sandwich generation issues, personal aging issues, health and on and on. There is always someone who has been there before or is there now. And the continuity of voices from people we have come to know carry a lot of value. That certainly does not mean new voices can't be valuable or welcome and I truly hate to think anyone takes that as my meaning. Just as in real life, it takes time to get to know someone virtually and get a fix on who they are, what their experiences are and where their voice comes from. There are relatively new people who post here (by that I mean within the last couple/few of years) who are as much a part of this forum as people who have been here 10 or 15+ years but they are not fly by nighters who post once or twice and disappear. For fluffy topics here of course a link to a dress from a one time poster is as valuable as anyone else's. But when hearts are being opened, the voices we are seeking first and foremost are the familiar ones.

  • 8 years ago
    last modified: 8 years ago

    I think what hurt Conversations was that the gw switchover seemed to happen, which we weren't happy about, and then the election primaries and then the election was so heated and conversations kept turning political really quick, and turned a lot of people off.

    I agree with Sherry, and I think quite a few people feel the same way about posting and being hesitant to post and getting stomped on with a couple of posters point of view. Expect it in HT, but shouldn't here.

    DLM2000-GW thanked OllieJane
  • 8 years ago

    There was a time in the old Gardenweb when everyone in every forum could look on the right side of the screen and see current or trending conversations in all forums. That brought in some fly-by posters. I don't think that is happening now. DLM's suggestion is a good one.


    DLM2000-GW thanked graywings123
  • 8 years ago

    “we are pretty assiduously staying apolitical here” - Maybe, but I’m still thinking about offering my free nanny services for Emmett so I can move northward.

    DLM2000-GW thanked User
  • 8 years ago

    I left GW for a time and came back to find it on Houzz. I never spent a lot of time in Conversations but more on Home Decorating when it was really insightful and interesting. Now I keep going back hoping for more of the old and now it seems like 50% of the posts are "I just bought this house. Here are the listing photos. Someone play decorator for me so I don't have to do any work myself. Help." I miss seeing the interesting and varied designs people were working on. They helped me learn and grow in my own decor. Now when I feel like I could really use some help I can't get anything real. Would be great if Conversations became the new space for interesting home decorating conversations. Maybe those can be hidden between other random topics.

    DLM2000-GW thanked pricklypearcactus
  • 8 years ago

    What is really funny to me is to see grown women post on Home Decorating with a title that says 'Emergency, need to pick paint color by tomorrow'. That always seemed to me to advertise lack of foresight.

    DLM2000-GW thanked lucillle
  • 8 years ago

    Lucille,

    We are limited to how long of a title we can use on posts. The rest of that “emergency, need to pick paint color by tomorrow!” woud probably read “and I’ve narrowed it down to two – help! “


    DLM2000-GW thanked jojoco
  • 8 years ago

    Yeah, but the two "colors" are sure to be dove white and simply white.

    Sigh.

    DLM2000-GW thanked writersblock (9b/10a)
  • 8 years ago
    last modified: 8 years ago

    Jojoco,

    To me, an emergency involves seeing quarts of human blood outside of its usual environment, or looking out one's airplane window and seeing a fire on the airplane, something like that. I do not regard the choice between two colors of paint as an emergency. I'm not saying my viewpoint is the only viewpoint, only that I think characterizing the situation in such terms is funny.

    DLM2000-GW thanked lucillle
  • 8 years ago

    One wrong decision on wall paint color, and years of regret. Ask me how I know. I first joined the Home Decorating Forum after one such mistake . . . :) Got some great advice on how to live with it. I learned that the last thing you want to do is surround a color you don't like with highly contrasting colors, even if you love them. That will simply serve to highlight further what you don't like. Yes, you can also take the time and effort to repaint, but not if your dad painted it in the first place, (well, if your dad is my dad, and I imagine most dads would feel the same way, and SO helpers too.) That is also when I learned to test the color on a wall in a paint blob first. I had created a big paint chip and tested my pepto bismol wall color in all kinds of light, but even a large chip is too small, you need a fairly sizeable blob. Unless you are a color savant, like some of the folks here. Sample cans are both my friend and my weakness. Seven cans of beige and grey paint anyone?? I also learned that you can get color palette tips from movies. "Father of the Bride" 1991, for example. Fascinating stuff . . . ahem . . .

    DLM2000-GW thanked l pinkmountain
  • 8 years ago

    I pink, LOL, been there, done that!

    DLM2000-GW thanked OllieJane