Software
Houzz Logo Print
jeanneprismon

too much wood!!!

8 years ago
I am going to be living for a few years in a 100 year old stone homestead in the Rockies mountains. The ceilings are handcrafted wood, the floors are original pine ( wood cut from the surrounding trees) the walls are hand hewn paneling. Help! Too much of a good thing. I’m thinking of mitigating the dark box by painting or drywalling over all or parts of the wood paneling. Any suggestions? Should I pick certain walls or drywall the top halves? Or? I think I’d like to keep the ceilings wood and the integrity of the flooring leaves me no choice but to update them ( probably with a similar product but the walls baffle me( and suffocate me as well.

Comments (26)

  • PRO
    8 years ago

    Delete this now.

  • PRO
    8 years ago
    last modified: 8 years ago

    Live somewhere else? The house was meant for..... NOT YOU. I am certain there are other places : )

    Or do ALL of all soft furnishings in pale tones......leave the house alone. No antlers needed. You may surprise yourself.


  • 8 years ago
    You guys are a little unkind, anyone friendly that can help ( and no this is where we will be living) I like character just a little less
  • 8 years ago
    last modified: 8 years ago

    The first thing you do is to leave all of the wood be. You don’t take a historic home and ruin it. You have a responsibility to the house to maintain it in fairly original condition. You don’t own it. You are merely a steward to future generations.

    You bought the wrong house if you want to immediately ruin it with a remuddle and drop the value by tens of thousands of dollars. Shame on you for even thinking of ruining that house.

    Go buy a tickey tacky modern box that has no character and that you can paint every single surface if that’s what you want.

  • 8 years ago
    If you could post some pictures, it would help us see what you see. To me, it sounds like you do want to be a good steward of this home, while making a few strategic changes.
  • PRO
    8 years ago
    last modified: 8 years ago

    Not unkind to say don't ruin that which another may LOVE. It is three years, not a lifetime sentence. Decorate your way to loving it......and drywall isn't the "character"...... unless incredibly skillfully done by an architect respecting the bones of the house.Post photos of

    "The ceilings are handcrafted wood, the floors are original pine ( wood
    cut from the surrounding trees) the walls are hand hewn paneling".............please..

  • 8 years ago
    I strongly disagree with the pros on this. Houzz, This Old House, Veranda, etc. are full of projects of historic homes where kitchens are ripped out, walls are taken down, bathrooms are ripped out, layouts are reconfigured- all with stunning results sympathetic to the homes history. Sometimes, they might even hang drywall - gasp!
  • 8 years ago
    last modified: 8 years ago

    Cjohnston - actually the episodes of This Old House that I have been watching for 20 years do everything they can to preserve the original wood of the home. Often that means removing the wood and restoring it and putting it back, or stripping the floors, or sanding the wainscoting and applying varnish to it by historical wood specialists.

    Of course kitchens and bathrooms are ripped out in those renovations, and layouts are reconfigured, but This Old House has never taken an 1800s stone cottage and ripped out or drywalled the original wood.

    Jeanneprismon - you said in your TWO other posts that the home is from the 1800s, so a lot more than 100 years old you are saying in this post. It's a stone homestead from the 1800s so it's going to have wood. It is really a shame that you bought it when you don't like it. A crying shame--literally, it makes me want to cry how you want to manhandle it. Leave it alone though, if just for the sake of the money you will be saving.

  • 8 years ago
    following.
  • 8 years ago
    I do own the home. My husbands family homesteaded it in 1870. I don’t intend to “ruin it” I think some pictures might help. I love wood and have worked many hours at restoring the wood. It’s just too much of a good thing. Wood floor, handcrafted wood ceilings ( our handcrafting) and wood paneling everywhere.I have lived in this house before and have a lot of respect for it’s history. I just want to get a little light ( it has 12 inch stone walls and windows can’t be made larger) into it and keep it from feeling like a small dark wood box.
  • PRO
    8 years ago
    last modified: 8 years ago

    As I said........IF you are going to attempt the re do........it requires tremendous skilled input . That is how the This Old House/ Veranda photos appear. Much skill involved ......it's not just slapped up drywall.

    To ask opinion minus even photos is to get varied "shoot the fish in the dark barrel" type answers. A thousand words...need a few pictures, at the very least.

  • 8 years ago
    If you can’t try to be a little understanding you shouldn’t reply. I wrote this for help not judgement. I’m sure you guys “ know best” but you haven’t lived in a stone homestead and would rather it be “ historical” and empty, than livable and historical. Please find someone else to attack. I won’t ask questions in this forum again.
  • 8 years ago

    Sorry for your bad experience Jeanne, you should know that wood paneling ignites passions. One needs a sense of humor on these forums. I hope you stick around

  • 8 years ago

    there isnt a lot of hand holding here but there tends to be a lot of good advice. whether to dismantle what you own or live with what you own is strictly a personal decision. we're all here, giving personal decisions.


    rugs on the floor, large art on the walls. based on your desires, and lack of pics for more specific suggestions, thats all i got.

    (i live in an 1870 house. it still has all of its horsehair plaster and lath. someone before me took a paintbrush to the woodwork, so i didnt have to be angsty over whether i should do it or not.)

  • 8 years ago
    Shannon, you made my point exactly. By ripping out kitchens and baths, and reconfiguring layouts, some original woodwork is always lost. If it's okay in those projects, it's okay for the op to consider it. In fact, maybe TOH would like to feature the Reno of an 1800s stone farmhouse.
  • 8 years ago
    Thanks for your recent comments. I really want to keep the historical character and almost all of the dark wood I just need a little relief , it is small ( the living room is the original structure used to prove up the homestead) and has low ceilings although we have raised them as much as we could. I should have put up pictures but it is currently occupied and we don’t have good recent ones. I think curtains and rugs will help some but I still need to lighten things up and installing larger windows is problematic as the walls are 12 inch thick stone.
  • 8 years ago
    last modified: 8 years ago

    Call in an electrician and add additional lighting. With minimal windows, even if you painted every single surface white, the rooms would still be dark. Fix the actual issue, which is the lack of light. More light is always the solution. Even if it involves an electrical upgrade to do it.

  • 8 years ago
    Jeanne, if you look at the two Veranda pictures Jan posted above. You'll notice the ceiling in the sleeping loft is paneled, while the ceiling in the bedroom is drywall. Given that some other ceilings in this cabin are paneled, my guess is that the drywall ceiling is new. It doesn't ruin the integrity of the cabin. ID was the brilliant Tammy Connor.
  • 8 years ago
    I am sorry but how can you comment on this post without pictures. I can think of several suggestion which would be temporary but without the context of what you are talking about it is rather pointless. OP quit just saying it is too much wood and pony up the photos.
  • PRO
    8 years ago

    Agreeing with others that we need some pics please.

  • 8 years ago
    last modified: 8 years ago

    You are getting mad at the responses because we cannot read your mind, nor have the ability to conjure up what your house must look like. That we can't do that appears to frustrate and dismay you. Let's put the shoe on the other foot. Someone comes to YOU and gives you a bare bones description of an 1800s home, and says she's going to be living in it for just "a few years", she wants to cover the wood, and have the home have less character, and provides no other information. Please tell us the detailed answers and advice you'd give that person that you are expecting from us.

    It's only after multiple posts that you reveal it's a family home handed down from generations. That you want to muddle because you will be living there for "a few years".

  • 8 years ago

    Add lamps if it's dark.

  • 8 years ago
    Maybe people who can't conjure up what the home looks like shouldn't get worked up about doing anything to it. Lol.
  • 8 years ago
    I sort of think that, if the OP wants meaningful advice, she should put in the effort to add a few pictures. Otherwise, any advice is entirely a shot in the dark (which brings us full circle).
  • 8 years ago

    following